11359 Chap.8 Corpus Data, the Idiom Principle and System in Use
Corpus Data, the Idiom Principle and System in Use
Three functional principles
Stubbs summarises British functionalism in three principles: study authentic language in use, recognise that use balances routine and creation, and reject the dualisms of langue and parole and of competence and performance.
This chapter takes each in turn.
Evidence from use
The evidence comes from beyond the sentence, as in classroom exchanges, and from corpora such as the 100-million-word British National Corpus.
Sinclair's idiom principle shows that words like budge live in preferred patterns, and Halliday's weather and climate comparison joins system and text.
Variation as data
Because different texts and kinds of text genuinely differ, functional approaches treat variation as something to investigate rather than to idealise away.
Dialect names variation according to the user and register variation according to use, and a corpus with many genres, such as the British National Corpus, makes both visible in ways a single invented sentence never can.
The chapter in the module
This chapter completes the first-half theorists covered in detail here.
With structuralism, generativism and functionalism in place, you can compare all three on what they count as data, where they locate the system and how each would critique the others.
What this chapter covers
- 01
Stubbs's three principles
- 02
Initiation, response and feedback
- 03
Corpus linguistics and the BNC
- 04
Dialect and register
- 05
Slot-and-filler grammar and idioms
- 06
The idiom principle
- 07
Weather, climate and system in use
Worked example · free
Use corpus evidence against the slot-and-filler view
- 1State the slot-and-filler view: structures are slots filled freely from the dictionary.
- 1Predict from it: as a verb, budge should appear freely in positive and negative frames.
- 1Report the evidence: corpus lines cluster around refusal and negation, such as refuse to budge.
- 1State the idiom principle: speakers draw on semi-preconstructed phrases that act as single choices.
Key terms
- Corpus
- A big digital collection of texts, usually studied with counts and statistics.
- IRF exchange
- A classroom pattern of initiation, response and feedback described by Sinclair and Coulthard.
- Register
- Variation in language according to its use.
- Dialect
- Variation in language according to its user.
- Idiom principle
- Sinclair's principle that speakers use many semi-preconstructed phrases as single choices.
- Slot-and-filler model
- A view of grammar as structural slots filled by free choices from the dictionary.
- Concordance
- A list of corpus lines showing every occurrence of a word in its immediate context.
Corpus Data, the Idiom Principle and System in Use FAQ
Why do functionalists distrust intuitions as data?
People misjudge their own usage and disagree with one another, judgements cannot be checked or repeated, and they say little about real language events, which are exactly what functional linguistics sets out to study.
What is the British National Corpus?
A collection of 100 million words of written and spoken English, about 90% of it written, drawn from many genres including newspapers, journals, fiction, letters, essays, conversations and radio shows.
What does the weather and climate comparison mean?
System and text are the same phenomenon at different time depths: texts are the weather, the system is the climate, and the climate can only be studied by observing the weather.
What is an IRF exchange?
A pattern described by Sinclair and Coulthard for classroom talk: the teacher initiates, usually with a question, a student responds, and the teacher gives feedback. It shows a structure that exists only across several turns, beyond any single sentence.
What does Stubbs's third principle reject?
The dualisms of Saussure and Chomsky, langue and parole, competence and performance, which functionalists regard as misconceived. Halliday instead treats system and text as the same phenomenon seen at different time depths, as climate and weather are.
Assessment move
Choose one common verb, write down what you think its typical frames are, then check them in a public corpus interface and note one pattern your intuition missed. Repeat the exercise with an idiom such as kick the bucket and test which changes destroy its idiomatic meaning. Close by writing one paragraph that compares how Chomsky and Sinclair would each decide whether a sentence is part of English.
Working through Corpus Data, the Idiom Principle and System in Use in 11359? Sia is AskSia’s AI Arts and Humanities tutor — ask any 11359 Corpus Data, the Idiom Principle and System in Use question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how 11359 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.