University of Birmingham · FACULTY OF ARTS & HUMANITIES

11359 Theories of Language

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
8 Chapters37-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
The Complete Study & Assessment Guide · 2026/27

11359 Overview

Theories of Language
— Compare the great theories of language and argue for your own
  • 2026/27
  • Level 1 module
  • College of Arts and Law
  • Two summative assignments
  • Weekly workshop and seminar

What the module covers

Theories of Language is a first-year module for students of English Language and Linguistics at the University of Birmingham.

  • Assessed by Two summative assignments of equal weight: short answers first, then an argued essay-type question.
  • Hardest step Keeping paired terms apart: signifier and signified, langue and competence, syntagmatic and paradigmatic.
  • How to prepare Read each extract with its guiding questions, then test every theory on one example of your own.
Why read this guide

What you get in the full 11359 Study & Assessment Guide

  1. 8 chapters, 37 pages — every assessed topic, week by week
  2. 20 original practice questions, each with a model answer
  3. 8 worked examples, solved the way 11359 marks
  4. 11 computed figures, redrawn from the course’s own numbers
  5. Before-you-submit checklist for the Assignment 1 (50%) — what markers reward, what costs marks

Free on this page: assessment table, chapter map, one worked example, key terms, FAQ. The rest is in the full study & assessment guide.

11359 · University of Birmingham
An independent, AskSia-authored study guide. AskSia is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by University of Birmingham; the course code and name are used for identification only.
Assessment

How 11359 is assessed

ComponentWeightFormat
Assignment 150%Summative. Short answers to questions on the key topics and theorists of the first half term; due before Christmas. Generative AI category Yellow, type B.
Assignment 250%Summative. Material from the second half term, including an essay-type question arguing your own view; due after Christmas. Exchange students here for one semester take a separate version, also weighted 50%.

Both weights come from the module assessment overview and sum to 100%. Details of each assignment, including exact deadlines and length, are released through the Assignments tab on Canvas, which is also where you submit; check there for any change.

Two summative assignments, equal weight50%Assignment 1: short answers50%Assignment 2: argued viewbefore Christmasafter Christmas
Other students are asking · 11359

What other students are asking about 11359

Where can I find lecture notes or study guides for 11359 at Birmingham?
The 11359 study guide in AskSia Library covers Theories of Language in 8 chapters, with the assessment table, a chapter-by-chapter topic map, key terms and a worked example, free to read on this page.
Is there a final exam in 11359?
No final exam is listed in the offering this AskSia Library guide is built from; 11359 is assessed by Assignment 1 50%, Assignment 2 50%.
What does 11359 cover on saussure's sign: signifier, signified and arbitrariness?
In AskSia Library's 11359 guide, the Saussure's Sign: Signifier, Signified and Arbitrariness chapter explains saussure's life and Course, semiology, the two-sided sign, arbitrariness, social convention and iconicity.
What does 11359 cover on langue, parole and the value of signs?
In AskSia Library's 11359 guide, the Langue, Parole and the Value of Signs chapter explains synchrony and diachrony, langue and parole, chess and trains, value by contrast, syntagmatic and paradigmatic relations.
What does 11359 cover on chomsky, behaviourism and the cognitive revolution?
In AskSia Library's 11359 guide, the Chomsky, Behaviourism and the Cognitive Revolution chapter explains american linguistics before Chomsky, Skinner's stimulus and response model, the 1959 review, cognitive science.
Weights, dates and every chapter are set out with their sources further down this page.
Contents · every chapter, one map

What 11359 covers

Eight chapters follow the theorist weeks: what a theory is, Saussure's sign and structure, Chomsky's generative grammar and Universal Grammar, and Halliday's functional linguistics with its corpus evidence.

01

What a Theory of Language Has to Explain

Theory, hypothesis and model; falsifiability; Construction Grammar's caused-motion example; working definitions of language

Why the module starts here

Before meeting any theorist, the module fixes what a theory is. A theory is a set of ideas that explains a phenomenon, the best explanation available given current facts and data.

  • Theory, hypothesis and model
  • Falsifiability and prediction
  • Construction Grammar and caused motion
  • Scope and foundational assumptions
  • Working definitions of language
  • Borderline cases and nonverbal meaning
In the full guide: 3 pages · 2 practice questions · 1 figure
02

Saussure's Sign: Signifier, Signified and Arbitrariness

Saussure's life and Course, semiology, the two-sided sign, arbitrariness, social convention and iconicity

Saussure and his Course

Ferdinand de Saussure, often called the father of modern linguistics, never wrote the book that made him famous.

  • Saussure's life and the Course
  • A language as a system of signs
  • Semiology, the science of signs
  • Signifier, signified and unified duality
  • The arbitrariness of the sign
  • Iconicity and motivated signs
In the full guide: 3 pages · 2 practice questions · 1 figure
03

Langue, Parole and the Value of Signs

Synchrony and diachrony, langue and parole, chess and trains, value by contrast, syntagmatic and paradigmatic relations

From the sign to the system

If signs are arbitrary, what stops a speaker from deciding what words mean, as Humpty Dumpty claims to?

  • The Humpty Dumpty problem
  • Synchronic and diachronic study
  • Langue and parole
  • Chess, trains and identity
  • Value as contrast
  • Syntagmatic and paradigmatic relations
In the full guide: 4 pages · 2 practice questions · 2 figures
04

Chomsky, Behaviourism and the Cognitive Revolution

American linguistics before Chomsky, Skinner's stimulus and response model, the 1959 review, cognitive science

The world Chomsky reacted against

American linguistics in the early twentieth century sat close to anthropology, described individual languages without seeking universals, and, under Bloomfield's positivism, set aside meaning and thought.

  • Chomsky's life and early works
  • Anthropological linguistics and relativity
  • Description and positivism
  • Behaviourism and operant conditioning
  • The 1959 review of Skinner
  • The cognitive revolution and cognitive science
In the full guide: 3 pages · 2 practice questions · 1 figure
05

Generative Syntax, Competence and Performance

Levels of language, syntax as a generating device, phrase structure rules, competence and performance, Hymes

Syntax at the centre

Chomsky defines syntax as the study of how a language builds its sentences.

  • Levels of linguistic analysis
  • Chomsky's definition of syntax
  • Grammaticality and meaning
  • Phrase structure rules
  • Generativity and creativity
  • Competence and performance
In the full guide: 4 pages · 2 practice questions · 1 figure
06

Universal Grammar, Recursion and Its Critics

Language as biology, the poverty of the stimulus, recursion, Pirahã, usage-based critics and large language models

The case for an innate grammar

Chomsky treats linguistics as a branch of biology. Children acquire comparable, complex grammars quickly, from limited and untaught input, encountering performance yet acquiring competence.

  • Language as biology
  • Universal Grammar
  • The poverty of the stimulus
  • Recursion and infinite expressivity
  • Pirahã and the universality question
  • Usage-based alternatives
In the full guide: 4 pages · 2 practice questions · 2 figures
07

Context of Situation and Halliday's Metafunctions

Firth and the London School, context of situation, field, tenor and mode, the three metafunctions, context of culture

Language as action

The British functionalist tradition, running from Malinowski through J. R. Firth to M. A. K. Halliday, studies what people do with language rather than an internal capacity.

  • Halliday's life and influences
  • Firth and the London School
  • Language events and context
  • Systemic functional linguistics
  • Field, tenor and mode
  • The three metafunctions
In the full guide: 4 pages · 2 practice questions · 1 figure
08

Corpus Data, the Idiom Principle and System in Use

Stubbs's principles, IRF exchanges, the British National Corpus, dialect and register, the idiom principle, weather and climate

Three functional principles

Stubbs summarises British functionalism in three principles: study authentic language in use, recognise that use balances routine and creation, and reject the dualisms of langue and parole and of competence and performance.

  • Stubbs's three principles
  • Initiation, response and feedback
  • Corpus linguistics and the BNC
  • Dialect and register
  • Slot-and-filler grammar and idioms
  • The idiom principle
In the full guide: 3 pages · 2 practice questions · 1 figure

It introduces the major theories of language developed within linguistics from the beginning of the twentieth century to the present day, together with the key figures associated with each tradition.

It begins with the structuralist linguistics of Ferdinand de Saussure, moves to the generative approach established by Noam Chomsky, and then turns to the main alternatives to generative linguistics: functionalism in the British tradition founded by J. R. Firth and developed by M. A. K.

Halliday, and the usage-based theories of cognitive linguistics linked with Lakoff, Fillmore, Langacker and Tomasello.

How the term is organised

The first half of term is dedicated to key theorists: an introduction to what a theory of language is, then Saussure and structuralism, Chomsky and generativism, Halliday and functionalism, and Lakoff and cognitivism.

After a student support week, the second half looks at general issues and controversies: language and communication, design features and AI, language and thought, and learning a language, closing with a summary week.

Each week combines a two-hour workshop with a one-hour seminar built around a short required extract by the theorist being studied, read with a set of guiding questions.

What you will be able to do

The module's learning outcomes ask you to show sound basic knowledge of the major theories, to name the most important figures and say what each contributed, to identify the theoretical assumptions behind a piece of published linguistic research and how rival traditions would critique them, and to describe and defend your own preferred perspective on language.

Throughout, you are encouraged to think critically about each tradition and to decide which theories you find most compelling or useful.

How this guide follows it

The eight chapters here follow the theorist weeks in detail, from the definition of a theory through Saussure's sign and the langue and parole distinction, Chomsky's break with behaviourism, generative syntax, Universal Grammar and recursion, to Halliday's context of situation, metafunctions and the corpus evidence of British functionalism.

Each chapter works a model answer and closes with practice questions, and a final chapter shows how the first-half theories become evidence for the argued view the second assignment asks for.

Worked example · free

Analyse the word cat as a Saussurean sign

Q [6 marks]. AskSia-authored practice. Using Saussure's model, analyse the English word cat: identify its signifier and signified, explain in what sense the link between them is arbitrary, and say where its value comes from. The marks shown are an AskSia study allocation, not an official University of Birmingham marking scheme.
The linguistic sign as Saussure draws it.The linguistic sign as Saussure draws it. The concept sits above the bar and the sound pattern below it, and the paired arrows show that neither half can exist as a sign without the other.concept: DOGsignifiedsound pattern /dɒg/signifierunifiedduality
The linguistic sign as Saussure draws it. The concept sits above the bar and the sound pattern below it, and the paired arrows show that neither half can exist as a sign without the other.
  • 1Signifier: the sound pattern of the spoken word, the form side of the sign.
  • 1Signified: the concept CAT, the meaning side; the two are inseparable, a unified duality.
  • 2Arbitrariness: nothing cat-like links the sounds to the concept, which is why French has chat and German Katze.
  • 1Convention: the pairing is a shared social code that no individual speaker can change.
  • 1Value: cat means what it does by contrast with neighbouring signs such as kitten and dog in the English system.
The signifier is the sound pattern and the signified the concept CAT, joined as one two-sided sign. Their link is arbitrary, since other languages pair the same concept with different sounds, yet it is fixed by convention for the community. The word's value comes from its contrasts with neighbouring signs in English, which is Saussure's reply to anyone who thinks words mean whatever a speaker chooses.
Sia tip — Say signifier and signified, then mention once that the Harris translation of the Course uses signal and signification, so either reading of the extract is covered.
Glossary

Key terms

Theory
A set of ideas that explains a phenomenon, the best explanation available given current facts and data.
Linguistic sign
In Saussure's model, the union of a concept, the signified, with a sound pattern, the signifier.
Arbitrariness
The absence of a natural link between a signifier and its signified, held in place by social convention.
Langue
The collective, social system of a language at a given time.
Parole
Individual, actual uses of the language system.
Synchronic study
The study of a language as a system at one point in time.
Generative grammar
A rule system that generates all the grammatical sentences of a language and none of the ungrammatical ones.
Competence
In Chomsky's terms, the speaker-hearer's knowledge of their language.
Universal Grammar
Chomsky's proposed innate linguistic knowledge common to all humans.
Recursion
The embedding of one structure inside another of the same kind, which makes endless sentences possible.
Context of situation
The environment of persons, actions and events from which an utterance takes its meaning.
Metafunction
One of Halliday's three broad kinds of meaning: ideational, interpersonal and textual.
Idiom principle
Sinclair's principle that speakers rely on semi-preconstructed phrases that act as single choices.
FAQ

11359 FAQ

How is this module assessed?

By two summative assignments worth 50% each. Assignment 1 asks for short answers on the key topics and theorists of the first half term and is due before Christmas. Assignment 2 covers the second half term, includes an essay-type question arguing your own view, and is due after Christmas. Exchange students here for one semester take a separate version of Assignment 2, also worth 50%.

Which theorists does the first half of term cover?

Saussure and structuralism in Week 2, Chomsky and generativism in Week 3, Halliday and British functionalism in Week 4, and Lakoff and cognitivism in Week 5, after an opening week on what a theory of language is. Each week pairs a workshop introducing the theory with a seminar on a short extract by the theorist.

Can I use generative AI for the assignments?

Only for researching, brainstorming and developing ideas. The module's statement places both assignments in the Yellow category, type B, and says no AI-generated content may be included in what you submit; doing so breaches the University's Code of Practice on Academic Integrity. Write every sentence of your answers yourself.

What reading do I need to do each week?

Each week has a short required extract by a theorist, such as Saussure's Course in General Linguistics or Halliday's Language as Social Semiotic, used as the basis for seminar activities and paired with guiding questions. Recommended reading comes from Chapman's Thinking About Language (2006), which covers most of the module.

Why do students find the readings difficult?

The module overview is frank that the extracts can be dense, technical or simply hard to read. You are not expected to understand every word: use the guiding questions to find the main ideas, discuss them in the seminar, and compare the workshop, the extract and Chapman's chapter, since several versions of an idea make it clearer.

What is the difference between langue and competence?

Both name an underlying system that matters more to the theorist than actual use. Saussure's langue is the collective, social system shared by a community, whereas Chomsky's competence is the individual speaker's internal, ultimately biological knowledge of the language. Their counterparts, parole and performance, both describe what people actually do with language.

How should I prepare for the argued essay question?

Treat the first-half theories as tools for second-half debates. Keep a running note of which arguments persuade you and why, then build a position that states your view, gives the strongest opposing case a fair hearing and supports both with the readings, as the module asks you to use readings to support your ideas.

Chapter questions

Questions students ask in each 11359 chapter

Why does the module begin by defining a theory?
Every later week tests a theory, so you need a yardstick first. A theory explains, covers many cases, predicts and could be proven wrong; the first seminar asks you to define theory, hypothesis and model, and later answers lean on those distinctions. Chapter 01 · What a Theory of Language Has to Explain
Who wrote the Course in General Linguistics?
Not Saussure himself. After his death in 1913, colleagues and students edited notes from his Geneva lectures into the book, first published in 1916 and revised in 1922. Chapter 02 · Saussure's Sign: Signifier, Signified and Arbitrariness
What does the chess analogy show?
A knight matters only through its value in the game; a lost piece can be replaced by any object given the same value. Langue is like the rules of chess, and parole like one particular game. Chapter 03 · Langue, Parole and the Value of Signs
What three tendencies did Chomsky react against?
An anthropological emphasis on linguistic relativity, an emphasis on describing individual languages rather than explaining language in general, and behaviourism in linguistics and psychology, best known through Skinner's stimulus and response account of verbal behaviour. Chapter 04 · Chomsky, Behaviourism and the Cognitive Revolution
Is 'Colorless green ideas sleep furiously' grammatical?
Yes. It is nonsense, but English speakers recognise its structure as well formed, which shows grammaticality can be judged independently of meaning, while the same words reversed are not grammatical. Chapter 05 · Generative Syntax, Competence and Performance
What is the poverty of the stimulus?
The argument that children are not explicitly taught their language and meet only a small sample of it, yet acquire a complete grammar, so some linguistic knowledge must be innate. Chapter 06 · Universal Grammar, Recursion and Its Critics
How does Firth differ from Saussure and Chomsky?
Saussure set concrete utterances aside as parole and Chomsky as performance. Firth argued that people saying and writing things in real contexts is exactly what linguists should study. Chapter 07 · Context of Situation and Halliday's Metafunctions
Why do functionalists distrust intuitions as data?
People misjudge their own usage and disagree with one another, judgements cannot be checked or repeated, and they say little about real language events, which are exactly what functional linguistics sets out to study. Chapter 08 · Corpus Data, the Idiom Principle and System in Use
Study strategy

How to prepare for the assessments

Work through the module in weekly cycles that mirror its structure. Before each seminar, read the required extract with its guiding questions beside you and write a two-line answer to each question, even when you are unsure; the seminar then corrects and extends your notes.

After the workshop, write one sentence defining each key term in the theorist's own vocabulary, attach a name and date to it, and invent one example of your own to test it. Keep a comparison table running across the weeks, with a column for each tradition and rows for what counts as data, where the system lives, and how each would criticise the others.

By the end of Week 4 the table becomes a ready-made answer to the learning outcome on identifying theoretical assumptions. For Assignment 1, rehearse short answers that name, define, illustrate and relate in four or five sentences. For Assignment 2, start a position note early, adding each argument that persuades or troubles you, so the argued view grows from the whole term rather than a last-minute choice.

Study 11359 with AI

Your AI Arts tutor for 11359

Stuck on a hard 11359 question? Sia is AskSia’s AI Arts and Humanities tutor — ask any 11359 Theories of Language question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how the course is actually taught and assessed. Read this whole study guide free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 17 of your subjects at University of Birmingham, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your 11359 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 37-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works