13339 Chap.14 Deinstitutionalisation and Service User Involvement
Deinstitutionalisation and Service User Involvement
Closing the asylums
Week 10 traces the move from Victorian asylums to community care and the pressures, from cost to criticism, that drove it.
Involvement and co-production
Service user involvement values experiential knowledge, and co-production goes further by sharing power over how services are designed and delivered.
Recovery
Personal recovery began with people who felt written off by services, and its adoption into mainstream policy has drawn sharp critiques.
Why involvement needs care
The teaching warns that stigma, compulsory treatment and the power gap between practitioners and service users make involvement in mental health especially delicate.
Bee and colleagues describe services shaped by a history of containment and compulsion, which is why involvement standards were developed by and with service users themselves.
Lived experience in research
Service users have challenged how clinical mental health research is designed and applied, and have developed their own theories of knowledge and research methods.
Glasby and Beresford argue that lived experience can be as valid a way of knowing as formal research.
What this chapter covers
- 01
Asylums and their treatments
- 02
Pressures behind deinstitutionalisation
- 03
Terms: service user and survivor
- 04
Experiential knowledge and involvement
- 05
The involvement continuum
- 06
Six principles of co-production
- 07
Personal recovery and its critics
Worked example · free
Test a service against the co-production principles
- 2Assets-based approach: are students treated as equal partners rather than passive recipients? Here they are recipients.
- 2Blurring distinctions: are professional and recipient roles mixed in design and delivery? Here they are kept separate.
- 2Recommend a change, such as co-writing and co-teaching courses with people with lived experience.
Key terms
- Experiential Knowledge
- Experiential Knowledge is knowledge gained from first-hand experience of distress, service use or caring.
- Co-production
- Co-production is professionals and citizens sharing power to plan and deliver support together.
- Deinstitutionalisation
- Deinstitutionalisation is the closure or downsizing of asylums and the move to community-based care.
- Service User
- A Service User is a person who uses mental health services, a contested term also chosen by some to describe themselves.
Deinstitutionalisation and Service User Involvement FAQ
Why were the asylums closed?
By the mid-twentieth century asylums were very expensive to maintain, public and political concern about mistreatment and wrongful detention was growing, new drugs were changing treatment, and both psychiatrists and patients criticised how people were treated. These pressures led to gradual closures and an incremental move to community-based care.
How is co-production different from service user involvement?
Involvement can range from tokenism, where users comment on plans already made, to valuing their expertise. Co-production co-designs the processes themselves, aims to equalise relationships and relocates power towards service users, with professionals moving from fixers to facilitators in an equal and reciprocal partnership.
What are the critiques of mainstream recovery?
Slade and colleagues describe seven misuses, such as assuming services make people recover or that recovery means independence. A review found services using clinical, personal and service-defined meanings, and the collective Recovery in the Bin argues mainstream recovery blames people for not getting better amid cuts to services.
What does the term survivor mean in mental health?
Some people call themselves survivors, or psychiatric survivors, to say they came through both mental health crises and the treatment they received for them. Many who choose the word are critical of psychiatric treatment, and activists in the user and survivor movement use it widely.
What are the six principles of co-production in mental health?
Mind and the New Economics Foundation list an assets-based approach, building on people's existing capabilities, reciprocity and mutuality, peer support networks, blurring distinctions between professionals and recipients, and facilitating rather than delivering. Co-production in practice should align with all six, which share similar underlying values.
Assessment move
Watch the 1986 documentary set for the seminar and note how it reflects the later stages of deinstitutionalisation. Then design a short involvement strategy for a service you know, placing it honestly on the continuum and checking it against the six co-production principles. Finally, write a reply to critics who say recovery has lost its meaning in mainstream services, because the week's exercise asks exactly that.
Use the language of the people you write about with care, and explain your choice of term once, because the module treats terminology as part of the argument.
Working through Deinstitutionalisation and Service User Involvement in 13339? Sia is AskSia’s AI Psychology tutor — ask any 13339 Deinstitutionalisation and Service User Involvement question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how 13339 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.