13339 Chap.13 Psychological Therapies and Their Evidence
Psychological Therapies and Their Evidence
What a psychotherapy is
Week 9 defines psychotherapy by a trained relationship and the systematic use of psychosocial principles, and lists the elements common to all forms.
Kinds of therapy
Therapies are classified by model, target and purpose, with CBT, psychoanalytic and brief psychodynamic therapy, counselling, and couple and family work described in turn.
Does it work?
Meta-analyses, the dodo bird effect and common factors frame the evidence, along with the difficulty of researching therapy within a biomedical hierarchy.
Therapy with more than one person
Couple therapy may be psychoeducational, psychoanalytic or cognitive behavioural, and often helps partners see problems as shared patterns of interaction.
Family therapy treats the family as a system that is more than the sum of its members, and is used when stress overwhelms a family or one member's chronic illness strains everyone.
Research directions
Research increasingly asks how therapy changes the body and brain, with interest in neuroplasticity and a new discipline, interpersonal neurobiology, that studies how relationships influence bodily, brain and mental functioning.
The newer waves of therapy have a stronger evidence base than traditional psychoanalysis.
What this chapter covers
- 01
Two defining features of psychotherapy
- 02
Common elements across therapies
- 03
Four purposes of therapy
- 04
CBT structure and thinking errors
- 05
Psychoanalytic and brief dynamic therapy
- 06
Couple and family therapy
- 07
Effectiveness and common factors
Worked example · free
Identify thinking errors in a diary entry
- 2Ruined my career from one frown is catastrophising, exaggerating the negative side of a situation.
- 2Always fail at everything generalises from a single episode, which is overgeneralisation.
- 1Assuming the frown was about them is personalising a negative event.
- 1Suggest the next CBT step: treat the thought as a hypothesis and test it.
Key terms
- Transference
- Transference is the patient's unconscious transfer onto the therapist of attitudes formed in earlier relationships.
- Dodo Bird Effect
- The Dodo Bird Effect is the finding that therapies may be effective regardless of their theoretical brand.
- Countertransference
- Countertransference is the therapist's own unconscious emotional response to the patient, used in psychodynamic work.
Psychological Therapies and Their Evidence FAQ
What do all psychotherapies have in common?
The teaching lists a trusting, emotionally engaged relationship within a safe and secure setting, a shared and plausible understanding of the problem, often a formulation, and the discovery of new knowledge about the problem and its sources. Research adds common factors such as the therapeutic alliance, empathy, expectations and therapist effects.
How long is CBT and what does it involve?
CBT is structured and relatively brief, about 16 sessions. Therapist and patient work actively to identify problems and goals, recognise faulty thinking, frame it as a hypothesis to test, keep a diary of automatic thoughts and practise alternatives as homework, until the patient can act as their own therapist.
Is psychoanalysis still relevant to psychiatry?
Joel Paris argues that Freud's ideas have gained little empirical support and that attachment theory is the only psychodynamic model with an extensive scientific literature. Against that, Peter Fonagy shows short-term psychodynamic psychotherapy with efficacy comparable to CBT, so the seminar asks you to weigh both.
Can psychotherapy cause harm?
Yes. Poorly delivered therapy, or therapy from people with little training and supervision, can do harm. The teaching reports that symptoms deteriorate in up to 10% of cases when therapy is poor, which is one reason well-run trials rate recorded sessions for fidelity to the intended model of treatment.
What is the difference between counselling and other psychotherapies?
Counselling helps people tackle a life-challenging issue while they remain well enough not to receive a psychiatric diagnosis. It is usually short-term, often in primary care or non-specialist settings, is less directive than other therapies, and may draw on psychodynamic, cognitive behavioural or humanistic approaches depending on the counsellor.
Assessment move
Read Wampold's paper on common factors and list the factors with one sentence each for the seminar. Then write down why psychological treatment is hard to study with the hierarchy of evidence used for drugs: blinding, therapist effects, fidelity and the interaction between patient and therapist. Prepare a view on Paris's question about psychoanalysis, citing one argument from each side.
Pair every therapy you describe with one piece of evidence and one limitation, so that the essay's treatment comments stay evaluative rather than descriptive.
Working through Psychological Therapies and Their Evidence in 13339? Sia is AskSia’s AI Psychology tutor — ask any 13339 Psychological Therapies and Their Evidence question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how 13339 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.