13344 Chap.1 Research Design, Methodology and Validity
Research Design, Methodology and Validity
Framework before tools
The chapter separates research design, the framework for collecting and analysing data, from methods, the tools used within it, and places both beneath a researcher's ontology and epistemology.
Validity and questions
It then defines internal and external validity with the module's anxiety scale example and shows how to turn a vague idea into a focused, arguable question with PICO, so that the question points to a design.
Using it in your writing
Both summative pieces reward the same habit: say what framework a study uses and what it lets the researcher conclude before describing any instrument.
The chapter closes with a worked rewrite of a vague question and a short case exercise that leads from a clinical story to a cohort or a case-control design.
What this chapter covers
- 01
Design versus method
- 02
Ontology, epistemology and the positivist to constructivist spectrum
- 03
Six families of research design
- 04
Primary and secondary, qualitative and quantitative data
- 05
Internal and external validity
- 06
Research questions and PICO
Worked example · free
Place a study's choices on the design ladder
- 1Beliefs: distress as partly socially constructed sits towards the constructivist end of the spectrum.
- 1Question: how carers explain a relative's psychosis.
- 1Design: a qualitative framework, because the question is about experience and explanation.
- 1Method: semi-structured interviews are the tool, with thematic analysis of the data.
Key terms
- Epistemology
- Epistemology is the study of knowledge: how we know what we know.
- Ontology
- Ontology is the branch of philosophy concerned with what exists and what reality is like.
- Pluralist Methodology
- Pluralist Methodology is analysing the same dataset with several methods and synthesising the findings.
- PICO
- PICO is a framework that breaks a question into population, intervention or indicator, comparator and outcome.
- Unit of Analysis
- The Unit of Analysis is what each case in a study counts, such as a survey respondent or an organisation.
Research Design, Methodology and Validity FAQ
How does research design differ from methodology?
Design is the plan or framework that lets a study answer its question, such as a cohort or a randomised trial. Methods are the tools used inside it, such as questionnaires, interviews or observation. The module's shorthand is plan versus tools, and essays should name the design first.
What makes a good research question?
The first seminar asks for questions that are clear, focused, concise, complex enough to need analysis and arguable rather than settled fact. PICO then names the population, the intervention or indicator, the comparator and the outcome, which usually reveals which design fits.
Is a valid scale enough to make a study valid?
No. A well-validated instrument can still sit inside a study whose internal validity is weakened by confounding or whose external validity is limited because the sample came from one setting. Say which kind of validity your point concerns.
What are the six types of research design in the module?
The first seminar lists descriptive, experimental, quasi-experimental, qualitative, correlational, and review and meta-analytical designs. Each suits a different kind of question, from how common a difficulty is to what a body of studies shows overall, so learn what each cannot show as well as what it can.
What is the difference between mixed methods and a pluralist methodology?
Mixed methods integrate qualitative and quantitative approaches to answer a complex question, which is common in mental health. A pluralist methodology analyses the same dataset with several methods and then synthesises the findings. The difference is whether the approaches gather different data or reread the same data.
Where do ontology and epistemology fit in a methods essay?
They sit above the design. Ontology concerns what exists and epistemology how we can know it, and a researcher's position on the spectrum from positivist to constructivist shapes which designs seem convincing. Mention them when a design quietly assumes one, for instance that distress can be measured objectively.
Assessment move
For each design you meet, write the kind of question it can carry and the one thing it cannot show. Practise rewriting two vague questions a week with PICO and decide which design each points to. Keep a running table with one row per design, recording its typical question, its main threat to internal validity and its usual limit on external validity, and add to it every week.
Working through Research Design, Methodology and Validity in 13344? Sia is AskSia’s AI Psychology tutor — ask any 13344 Research Design, Methodology and Validity question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how 13344 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.