13344 Chap.2 Research Ethics, Consent and Public Involvement
Research Ethics, Consent and Public Involvement
Where the principles came from
The chapter traces research ethics from wartime atrocities and the Doctors' Trial to the Nuremberg Code of 1947, the principles of benefice, respect and justice, and the ESRC's six principles.
Approval, power and involvement
It explains when University and Health Research Authority approval are needed, why ethics is a reflexive process rather than a form, how power and rapport shape a study, and why public involvement differs from participation.
Using it in your proposal
The chapter ends with a model ethics paragraph for a study of young adults after a first episode of psychosis, covering capacity at each contact, a youth advisory group, withdrawal, data storage and a researcher log, so you can see how principles become concrete design decisions.
What this chapter covers
- 01
The Doctors' Trial and the Nuremberg Code
- 02
Benefice, respect and justice
- 03
The ESRC six principles
- 04
University and HRA approval
- 05
Power relationships and rapport
- 06
Patient and public involvement
Worked example · free
Trace a consent rule back to its source
- 1Origin: the Nuremberg Code of 1947 states that participants must be free to end their participation at any point.
- 1Modern principle: respect, meaning participation is informed and voluntary.
- 1Current framework: the ESRC principle of voluntary participation free from coercion, applied through University review.
Key terms
- Benefice
- Benefice is the principle of maximising benefit and minimising harm to participants.
- Procedural Ethics
- Procedural Ethics is what researchers do to satisfy an ethics committee, as distinct from ethical decisions made in the field.
- Informed Consent
- Informed Consent is voluntary agreement to take part, given with understanding and the capacity to decide.
- Equitable Recruitment
- Equitable Recruitment is the application of the justice principle, spreading the benefits and burdens of research fairly across groups.
Research Ethics, Consent and Public Involvement FAQ
Why does the module start ethics with the Second World War?
Many current principles were written in response to experiments carried out without consent on concentration-camp prisoners. The Doctors' Trial led to the Nuremberg Code of 1947, whose first principle, voluntary informed consent given with full legal capacity, still anchors research ethics.
Does reanalysing anonymised data need ethical review?
Yes. The University's Code of Practice for Research requires review whenever people are a source of data, and it names secondary analysis and anonymised data sets explicitly. Postgraduate taught students apply through their School or College.
Is patient and public involvement the same as recruiting participants?
No. Involvement means people with relevant experience help design, conduct and disseminate the research, for example by shaping materials or questions. Taking part as a participant and providing data is a different role.
When do I need Health Research Authority approval?
Usually whenever a study involves NHS or social care patients or staff. The teaching lists trials of medicines and devices, randomised comparisons, questionnaire and interview studies, qualitative studies and work with tissue or data. University review is needed as well, so a timeline should allow for both.
Why does power matter in mental health research?
The researcher holds responsibility and power, and participants may take part to help, to share an experience, to change something or for an incentive. Each motive can leave them in a weaker position, and closeness can slide into friendship, dependency or a sense of loss when the study ends.
What are the three principles in modern regulation?
Benefice means maximising benefit and minimising harm, respect means participation is informed and voluntary, and justice means a fair spread of benefits and burdens, which shapes who is recruited. Naming the principle each safeguard serves makes an ethics section easier to follow.
What is the difference between procedural ethics and ethics in practice?
Procedural ethics is what you do to satisfy a committee, such as forms and approvals. Ethics in practice is the set of decisions you make in the field once a study is running, such as how to respond when a participant becomes distressed. A good proposal addresses both.
Assessment move
Build a one-page ethics template with headings for approval route, consent and capacity, confidentiality, risks and their mitigation, power and rapport, and public involvement, and fill it in for every practice study you design. Before each seminar, note one study you have read and say which of the ESRC principles its ethics section addresses well and which it leaves vague.
Working through Research Ethics, Consent and Public Involvement in 13344? Sia is AskSia’s AI Psychology tutor — ask any 13344 Research Ethics, Consent and Public Involvement question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how 13344 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.