University of Birmingham · S1 2026 · FACULTY OF LAW

18389 Regulation of IT and Intellectual Property Law

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
10 Chapters36-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Built to mirror S1 2026 · updated this semester
The Complete Study & Assessment Guide · S1 2026/27

18389 Overview

Regulation of IT and Intellectual Property Law
— Why, when and how law should govern new technology, argued from regulatory theory.
  • Postgraduate
  • Semester 1, 2026/27
  • Birmingham Law School
  • Lectures, seminars and Writing Labs
  • One summative essay

What this module asks

Regulation of IT and Intellectual Property Law is a master's module at Birmingham Law School. It brings together three perspectives on technology law: regulating technology itself, data protection, and intellectual property. Its stated aim is an integrated understanding of how law governs innovation.

  • Assessed by one essay A single 5,000-word essay answering one question from three themes carries the whole mark.
  • Define before you judge Say which sense of regulation you mean before arguing whether a rule is good.
  • Theories are lenses Public interest, private interest and public choice can all explain parts of the same rule.
Why read this guide

What you get in the full 18389 Study & Assessment Guide

  1. 10 chapters, 36 pages — every assessed topic
  2. 23 original practice questions, each with a model answer
  3. 10 worked examples, solved the way 18389 marks
  4. 15 computed figures, redrawn from the course’s own numbers
  5. Before-you-submit checklist for the Individual essay (100%) — what markers reward, what costs marks

Free on this page: assessment table, chapter map, one worked example, key terms, FAQ. The rest is in the full study & assessment guide.

18389 · University of Birmingham
An independent, AskSia-authored study guide. AskSia is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by University of Birmingham; the course code and name are used for identification only.
Assessment

How 18389 is assessed

ComponentWeightFormat
Individual essay100%Summative, 5,000 words: one question from three themes (Regulation and Governance; Data Protection; Intellectual Property), argued from legislation, case law, policy and scholarship
Writing Labs (formative)0%Three supervised exercises of about 500 words, one at the end of each teaching block, with tutor and peer feedback

According to the module guidance, one individually written essay of 5,000 words provides 100% of the module mark, while three formative writing exercises of about 500 words each carry no weight. Submission dates are published on Canvas.

Assessment structure

One summative piece carries the whole module markIndividual essay, 5,000 words: 100%Plus three formative Writing Labs of about 500 words, feedback only

The essay answers one question chosen from the module's three themes. The Writing Labs come at the end of each teaching block and do not count towards the mark.

Other students are asking · 18389

What other students are asking about 18389

Where can I find lecture notes or study guides for 18389 at Birmingham?
The 18389 study guide in AskSia Library covers Regulation of IT and Intellectual Property Law in 10 chapters, with the assessment table, a chapter-by-chapter topic map, key terms and a worked example, free to read on this page.
Is there a final exam in 18389?
No final exam is listed in the offering this AskSia Library guide is built from; 18389 is assessed by Individual essay 100%.
What does 18389 cover on public interest theory and market failure?
In AskSia Library's 18389 guide, the Public Interest Theory and Market Failure chapter explains three theories of why regulation emerges, four market failures with platform examples, and what the public interest account cannot show.
What does 18389 cover on regulatory capture and public choice theory?
In AskSia Library's 18389 guide, the Regulatory Capture and Public Choice Theory chapter explains lobbying, the revolving door, self-regulation and soft law, four conditions and four diagnostic questions for capture, the Amazon case, and incentives inside institutions.
What does 18389 cover on technology as a moving regulatory target?
In AskSia Library's 18389 guide, the Technology as a Moving Regulatory Target chapter explains driverless taxis in London, supervised rides from 3 September 2026, the regulator's three options, competing interests and forces, wicked problems and the four-layer uncertainty map.
Weights, dates and every chapter are set out with their sources further down this page.
Contents · every chapter, one map

What 18389 covers

Ten chapters move from what regulation is and why it emerges, through risk, precaution and timing under uncertainty, to the 5,000-word essay.

01

Defining Regulation Beyond Command and Control

Narrow and broad senses, the functional control loop, Lodge and Wegrich's definition, decentred regulation and Winner on artifacts

What regulation means

The module starts by refusing a single definition.

  • Narrow and broad meanings of regulation
  • Command and control: rule, monitor, sanction
  • Rules, markets, norms and design
  • Regulation as a control system
  • Lodge and Wegrich's three-part test
  • Decentred regulation and the politics of artifacts
In the full guide: 3 pages · 2 practice questions · 1 figure
02

Public Interest Theory and Market Failure

Three theories of why regulation emerges, four market failures with platform examples, and what the public interest account cannot show

Why regulation appears

Lecture 1 offers three theories of why regulation emerges, each answering its own question: what problem does it solve, whose interests might it serve, and how do institutional incentives shape it.

  • Three theories, three questions
  • Market power and platform terms
  • Information asymmetry in data collection
  • Externalities on people who never signed up
  • Vulnerable users such as children
  • What the theory cannot show
In the full guide: 2 pages · 2 practice questions · 1 figure
03

Regulatory Capture and Public Choice Theory

Lobbying, the revolving door, self-regulation and soft law, four conditions and four diagnostic questions for capture, the Amazon case, and incentives inside institutions

Influence from outside

Private interest theory holds that regulation need not be a neutral response to a problem, because organised groups may shape it.

  • Private interest theory and its four channels
  • Why private interest theory is not capture
  • Conditions that make capture likely
  • Four diagnostic questions
  • The Amazon and European Commission case
  • Public choice incentives and constraints
In the full guide: 3 pages · 2 practice questions · 1 figure
04

Technology as a Moving Regulatory Target

Driverless taxis in London, supervised rides from 3 September 2026, the regulator's three options, competing interests and forces, wicked problems and the four-layer uncertainty map

Regulating before we know

Lecture 2 drops the assumption that the regulator already understands the problem.

  • What you would want to know before getting in
  • Supervised, testing and intention distinctions
  • Authorise, wait or authorise under conditions
  • Who is in the room and the four forces
  • Tame and wicked problems
  • The four-layer uncertainty map
In the full guide: 3 pages · 2 practice questions · 1 figure
05

Hazard, Risk, Harm and Uncertainty

Four disasters, the move to acting before harm, a vocabulary of hazard, risk, harm and uncertainty, competing risk judgements and risk versus uncertainty

Why risk

Four disasters, Bhopal, Chernobyl, Fukushima and Beirut, open Part II of Lecture 2. They show modern systems producing risks that are complex, interconnected, delayed and hard to foresee, rooted in failures of organisations and oversight.

  • Four disasters and what they teach
  • From ex post to ex ante
  • Hazard, risk, harm and uncertainty defined
  • Why hazard or risk figures alone mislead
  • Same danger, different judgements
  • Risk compared with uncertainty
In the full guide: 3 pages · 2 practice questions · 1 figure
06

Regulatory Tools for Uncertain Technologies

Command and control, principles-based rules, co-regulation and self-regulation and regulatory sandboxes compared by fit, accountability and institutional capacity

Beyond choosing a rule

Under uncertainty the right approach depends on how much we know, how fast the technology is changing and whether experience can teach us anything.

  • Why the rule is only part of the answer
  • Command and control under uncertainty
  • Principles-based duties
  • Co-regulation, self-regulation and accountability
  • Regulatory sandboxes and their limits
  • Matching form to harm, evidence and capacity
In the full guide: 3 pages · 2 practice questions · 1 figure
07

The Precautionary Principle and Its Costs

Google Glass from 2012 to 2015, AI smart glasses, Norway's October 2026 proposal, three conditions for precaution and four costs of acting early

A recurring case

Google Glass met public resistance and venue bans within a few years of launch, which makes it the timing problem in miniature: a 2012 rule and a 2015 rule would have looked very different.

  • Should the minister act now or wait?
  • Google Glass as the timing problem in miniature
  • AI glasses and the Norwegian proposal
  • Three conditions for precaution
  • Four costs of precaution
  • Targeted rules and assistive uses
In the full guide: 2 pages · 2 practice questions · 1 figure
08

Timing, Pacing and Lessons from Regulatory History

Four stages of a technology, the timing trade-off, five causes of the pacing problem, seat belts, aviation, electric cars, CFCs and ride-sharing, anticipatory and responsive regulation

Timing

A technology passes through four stages, new, developing, adopted and entrenched.

  • Four stages from new to entrenched
  • The timing trade-off
  • Five causes of the pacing problem
  • When delay is deliberation
  • Five histories, no scoreboard
  • Anticipatory against responsive regulation
In the full guide: 4 pages · 2 practice questions · 2 figures
09

The Collingridge Dilemma and Adaptive Regulation

The 2031 scenario, the information problem and the power problem, tools for each, adaptive regulation and the design exercise for autonomous passenger services

The dilemma

The final part of Lecture 2 imagines 2031, five years after a pilot of autonomous taxis was approved. The service is now part of daily life, the developer has invested heavily, and cyclists have evidence of near-misses.

  • The 2031 scenario
  • Knowledge rises while power to change falls
  • The information problem
  • The power problem
  • Tools for learning and for keeping control
  • Adaptive regulation and the design exercise
In the full guide: 2 pages · 2 practice questions · 1 figure
10

Writing the Module Essay on Technology Regulation

A single 5,000-word essay worth 100%, three themes, three formative Writing Labs, the module's generative AI rules and using theory as an analytical tool

The task

One individually written essay of 5,000 words carries the whole module mark.

  • The 5,000-word summative essay
  • Three themes and one question
  • Formative Writing Labs
  • Permitted and prohibited uses of generative AI
  • Theory as an analytical tool
  • Building a thesis and introduction
In the full guide: 2 pages · 2 practice questions · 1 figure

Across the semester students work with statutes, cases, policy papers and scholarship, and apply legal principles to problems raised by AI, online platforms, data governance and new digital services.

Teaching combines lectures, seminars and writing workshops, and the module guidance asks you to think across the three parts rather than treating them in isolation.

How the guide is organised

The chapters follow the opening block on regulating technology.

They begin with what regulation means, from command and control to decentred regulation and design, then compare three theories of why regulation emerges: public interest theory and market failure, private interest theory and regulatory capture, and public choice.

The second half turns to regulating under uncertainty, covering driverless taxis in London, the vocabulary of hazard, risk, harm and uncertainty, the choice between regulatory tools, the precautionary principle and AI smart glasses, timing and pacing with five historical cases, and the Collingridge dilemma with adaptive regulation.

Built for one essay

Assessment rests on one essay of 5,000 words, written individually and worth the entire module mark, on a question chosen from three themes: Regulation and Governance; Data Protection; Intellectual Property.

Three formative Writing Labs of about 500 words give feedback before it. The final chapter, the practice pages and the submission checklist turn the concepts into argued legal positions, and explain the module's limited-use rules on generative AI.

Worked example · free

Test whether precaution justifies limiting AI glasses in schools

Q [6 marks]. AskSia-authored practice. A school board is asked to restrict AI-enabled smart glasses on its premises before any incident has been reported. Use the three conditions of the precautionary principle to decide whether acting now is justified, then say what form the response should take. The marks shown are an AskSia study allocation, not a University marking scheme.
When precaution is justified.When precaution is justified. The three boxes are the conditions in the framework used by the lecture, read left to right: possible serious or irreversible damage, scientific uncertainty about its likelihood or scale, and an available policy response, which together justify acting before proof. 1 Damage serious or irreversible? 2 Knowledge scientific uncertainty? 3 Remedy response available? Precaution justified each box must be answered yes
When precaution is justified. The three boxes are the conditions in the framework used by the lecture, read left to right: possible serious or irreversible damage, scientific uncertainty about its likelihood or scale, and an available policy response, which together justify acting before proof.
  • 2Damage: covert recording of pupils and staff, followed by sharing they cannot control, could cause serious and lasting harm.
  • 1Knowledge: how often and in what ways the glasses would be misused in schools is uncertain.
  • 1Remedy: responses short of a total ban exist, such as rules on recording functions in classrooms and changing rooms.
  • 2Proportionality: weigh the costs of precaution, including assistive use by blind or partially sighted pupils.
All three conditions are met, so the lack of a reported incident is not a reason to wait. A proportionate response targets recording functions in sensitive places and allows assistive use, rather than banning the glasses outright, and it should be reviewed once evidence of actual use builds up.
Sia tip — Run the three conditions in order and stop if one fails; argue proportionality only after all three are met.
Glossary

Key terms

Regulation
Regulation, as Lodge and Wegrich define it, is any deliberate exercise of authority, by public or private actors, aimed at changing how others behave.
Decentred Regulation
Decentred Regulation is regulation carried out by many actors, such as companies, standards bodies and civil society, alongside the state.
Public Interest Theory
Public Interest Theory explains regulation as a response to market failures that leave wider social interests unprotected.
Private Interest Theory
Private Interest Theory holds that organised interests may shape regulation to advance their own ends.
Market Power
Market Power is the ability of a dominant firm to influence the terms of exchange.
Vulnerability
Vulnerability is the position of groups who cannot protect their interests through ordinary market mechanisms.
Harm
Harm is the actual or potential adverse consequence of an event, such as injury, loss or damage to public interests.
Co-Regulation
Co-Regulation is an approach in which industry helps develop or administer rules under some public oversight.
Timing Problem
The Timing Problem is the trade-off between the power to shape a technology early and knowledge of its effects later.
Information Problem
The Information Problem is the early stage of the Collingridge dilemma, when too little is known to predict a technology's effects.
Power Problem
The Power Problem is the later stage of the Collingridge dilemma, when an embedded technology resists change.
Ex Ante Regulation
Ex Ante Regulation is intervention that acts on what might happen, before harm occurs, rather than after it.
Staged Deployment
Staged Deployment is releasing a technology in steps, each opened only when evidence from the previous one supports it.
FAQ

18389 FAQ

How is this technology law module assessed?

Entirely by one essay of 5,000 words, written individually, which counts for the whole module mark. You pick a single question from three themes, Regulation and Governance; Data Protection; Intellectual Property, and you are expected to use legislation, case law, policy material and academic scholarship to build a reasoned legal argument.

Which themes can the essay questions come from?

The questions are drawn from three themes: Regulation and Governance; Data Protection; Intellectual Property. Problems involving AI, platforms and online innovation seldom belong to a single field of law, so the module guidance encourages you to draw connections across the three parts even when your question sits mainly in one of them.

What must I hand in if I used generative AI?

If you made permitted use of generative AI, for example for brainstorming, finding sources or feedback on your writing, you complete the Generative AI Declaration supplied with the assessment and submit a full record of your interactions with the tool alongside the essay itself.

Which theories explain why technology is regulated?

Lecture 1 sets out three. Public interest theory points to market failures such as market power, information asymmetry, externalities and vulnerability. Private interest theory looks at how organised interests shape rules, sometimes ending in capture. Public choice examines the incentives and constraints of politicians, regulators and agencies themselves.

Why does the module separate risk from uncertainty?

Because they call for different responses. Risk exists where there is enough evidence to judge likelihood and severity meaningfully, so probability-based rules can carry weight. Uncertainty means evidence is too thin to predict outcomes confidently, which points towards precaution, staged deployment, monitoring and review rather than relying on estimates.

Should regulators act early or wait for evidence of harm?

Lecture 2 treats both as bets about time. Acting early gives more power to shape a technology but less knowledge; waiting gives more evidence but less power to change it. The answer depends on the severity and reversibility of possible harm, the evidence, the technology's maturity and whether rules can be changed later.

How does the Collingridge dilemma affect regulatory design?

It explains why regulators struggle to have both knowledge and control: information is scarce early and power to change is scarce later. Good design therefore combines tools for learning, such as pilots and monitoring, with tools for keeping control, such as staged deployment, review clauses, sunset clauses and temporary permissions.

Chapter questions

Questions students ask in each 18389 chapter

Is a platform's own rulebook a form of regulation?
Yes, on Lodge and Wegrich's definition. A platform that writes and enforces rules for users acts intentionally, uses its authority over access, and affects others, so it regulates. The definition describes the rulebook; whether it is legitimate is answered by the theories of why regulation emerges. Chapter 01 · Defining Regulation Beyond Command and Control
What are the three theories of why regulation emerges?
Public interest theory asks what problem regulation solves, private interest theory asks whose interests it might serve, and public choice theory asks how incentives and constraints inside institutions shape the outcome. Lecture 1 presents them as lenses that can all be applied to the same rule, not as a ranking. Chapter 02 · Public Interest Theory and Market Failure
Is private interest theory the same as regulatory capture?
No. Private interest theory is a broad analytical account that organised interests may influence regulation. Capture is one possible outcome or mechanism, in which regulation comes to serve the industry over the public, and it has to be shown with evidence rather than assumed. Chapter 03 · Regulatory Capture and Public Choice Theory
Why is waiting not a neutral regulatory option?
Because delay affects the company, anyone who would have gained from the service, and the path the technology follows. Lecture 2 compares it to a doctor with ambiguous results: sending away a worsening patient is itself a treatment decision. Perfect knowledge may only arrive after deployment. Chapter 04 · Technology as a Moving Regulatory Target
What is the difference between hazard and risk?
A hazard is a potential source of harm, such as a wet staircase or a shark in the sea, and it is there even if nobody measures it. Risk is the assessment of how likely harm is and how bad it would be, so the same hazard carries more risk on a crowded, poorly lit staircase. Chapter 05 · Hazard, Risk, Harm and Uncertainty
What is the main weakness of self-regulation?
Accountability. When industry develops or writes its own rules, the notes ask who verifies that firms comply and what follows when the rules are disregarded. Lecture 1 also lists self-regulation among the channels through which organised interests can shape regulation, so it needs a credible check. Chapter 06 · Regulatory Tools for Uncertain Technologies
Does the precautionary principle mean banning new technologies?
No. The Lecture 2 notes say precaution does not mean banning everything; it means uncertainty does not automatically justify waiting. Responses range from bans to restrictions, postponement, research and mitigation, and proportionality favours targeted measures. Chapter 07 · The Precautionary Principle and Its Costs
What is the difference between the timing problem and the pacing problem?
The timing problem concerns when in a technology's life to intervene: early gives more power to shape it but less knowledge, later gives more knowledge but less power. The pacing problem concerns the gap between how fast technology changes and how fast regulation can respond. Chapter 08 · Timing, Pacing and Lessons from Regulatory History
What is the Collingridge dilemma?
It is the problem, associated with David Collingridge's 1980 book The Social Control of Technology, that early on we lack information about a technology's effects, while later, when we know more, the technology is embedded and powerful interests resist change. It is a structural tension to be lived with. Chapter 09 · The Collingridge Dilemma and Adaptive Regulation
Can I use generative AI when writing the essay?
Only in limited ways. The module permits it for brainstorming, research and explanations, visual materials and feedback on your own writing, but not for drafting any part of the answer, developing or changing arguments, or cutting the text to the word limit. Any use requires a declaration and a full record. Chapter 10 · Writing the Module Essay on Technology Regulation
Study strategy

How to prepare for the assessments

Work through the chapters in teaching order, but treat each one as material for the essay rather than a topic to memorise. After the definitions chapter, write a paragraph stating which sense of regulation you find most useful and why. For each theory of regulation, prepare one example where it explains a technology rule well and one where it struggles.

When you reach the uncertainty chapters, practise the seminar exercises in writing: rate risks with stated reasons, choose a regulatory form for a fictional invention, and design a regime that names each harm, its monitoring and its trigger. Bring a draft argument to each Writing Lab, since those three sessions are the only feedback before the single summative essay.

Shortlist two candidate essay questions early, read the essential readings with page notes, and keep a record of any generative AI use from the first day so the declaration is straightforward at submission.

Study 18389 with AI

Your AI Law tutor for 18389

Stuck on a hard 18389 question? Sia is AskSia’s AI Law tutor — ask any 18389 Regulation of IT and Intellectual Property Law question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how the course is actually taught and assessed. Read this whole study guide free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 17 of your subjects at University of Birmingham, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your 18389 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 36-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works