18389 Chap.1 Defining Regulation Beyond Command and Control
Defining Regulation Beyond Command and Control
What regulation means
The module starts by refusing a single definition. Law, government, markets, social norms, platforms and design can all steer behaviour, and Morgan and Yeung hold that the word has no one meaning, so an essay must say which sense it relies on.
The chapter sets the narrow sense, deliberate public rules backed by monitoring and enforcement, against the broad sense, any intentional social control including markets and design.
Tools for defining it
It then explains the functional view, which reads any regime as a loop of standards, information gathering and correction, and shows how a content platform fits that loop.
Lodge and Wegrich's definition is tested against new cases, from a building code to an app store's review rules, to show how intention, authority and effect on others separate steering from accident.
Design as regulation
The final page contrasts command and control with decentred regulation, in which companies, standards bodies and civil society act beside the state, and sets rules against power.
Winner's argument that artifacts have politics shows how code and hardware can regulate without a statute.
What this chapter covers
- 01
Narrow and broad meanings of regulation
- 02
Command and control: rule, monitor, sanction
- 03
Rules, markets, norms and design
- 04
Regulation as a control system
- 05
Lodge and Wegrich's three-part test
- 06
Decentred regulation and the politics of artifacts
Worked example · free
Decide whether a ride-hailing rating system is regulation
- 1State the definition: any deliberate use of authority, by public or private actors, to steer how others behave.
- 1Intention and authority: the app designed the threshold to shape driver conduct and controls access to the platform.
- 1Effect on others: drivers change how they behave to avoid removal.
- 1Conclude it is regulation by a non-state actor, then note that the definition does not say whether it is fair.
Key terms
- Functional View
- The Functional View treats regulation as any system that sets standards, gathers information and modifies behaviour, whoever runs it.
- Command and Control
- Command and Control is regulation by which the state lays down a rule, monitors whether it is obeyed and punishes breaches.
- Politics of Artifacts
- The Politics of Artifacts is Winner's claim that technologies can settle questions of power and access much as founding laws do.
Defining Regulation Beyond Command and Control FAQ
Is a platform's own rulebook a form of regulation?
Yes, on Lodge and Wegrich's definition. A platform that writes and enforces rules for users acts intentionally, uses its authority over access, and affects others, so it regulates. The definition describes the rulebook; whether it is legitimate is answered by the theories of why regulation emerges.
Why does the module prefer a broad definition of regulation?
Because technology is steered by much more than statutes. Markets, social norms, design choices and private actors all shape conduct, and Lecture 1 notes that lawyers often begin with a narrow, state-centred view that technology then pushes towards a broader one.
What did Langdon Winner argue about technology?
In his 1980 essay he argued that artifacts can have politics: major technologies can work like founding acts that set a framework for public life outlasting their makers. His example of low overpasses shows a design choice deciding who gets access to a place.
How does the functional view of regulation work?
It reads any regime as a control loop. Someone sets a standard for expected behaviour, information is gathered about what people actually do, and behaviour is then modified to close the gap, after which the loop repeats. Because the view asks what a system does rather than who runs it, a platform's moderation counts as readily as a ministry's rules.
Assessment move
Write one sentence defining regulation in each of the four contrasting senses: narrow, broad, functional and decentred. Then take a technology you use daily and identify one rule, one market pressure, one norm and one design feature that steer how you use it. Run Lodge and Wegrich's three questions on each, and note which fail and why.
Finish by reading Winner's essay with one question in mind: which design choice in your example settles who gets access? Keep a running list of regulators you meet in the readings, public and private, so that by the essay you can name examples of each sense of the word. Before the seminar, test the definition on one example that fails it and explain which element is missing.
Working through Defining Regulation Beyond Command and Control in 18389? Sia is AskSia’s AI Law tutor — ask any 18389 Defining Regulation Beyond Command and Control question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how 18389 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.