University of Birmingham · FACULTY OF MANAGEMENT

38004 Chap.6 Supply Chain Design, Supplier Selection and Risk

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters4-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 6 of 12 · 38004

Supply Chain Design, Supplier Selection and Risk

Managing the chain, not just the firm

Week 4 defines supply chain management as integrating key business processes from end users back to original suppliers, so that products, services and information add value.

Materials flow downstream and information flows both ways, and many problems a firm feels, such as long lead times, poor quality or excess stock, begin several tiers upstream.

Designing the supply base

The first design decision is what to make and what to buy, judged on strategic importance, specialised knowledge, current performance and the likelihood of significant improvement, where a yes to any one favours keeping the work in-house.

Six sourcing strategies follow, from many competing suppliers to vertical integration, joint ventures, keiretsu coalitions and virtual companies.

Suppliers are chosen by scoring them on criteria such as quality, dependability, flexibility and total cost, alongside longer-term factors like innovation and willingness to share risk.

Variability, power and risk

The bullwhip effect shows how small changes in consumer demand swell as orders move upstream, with four causes and matching remedies.

The chapter then covers buyer and supplier power, how collaboration enlarges value while relative power still decides how it is split, and the main supply risks with tactics to reduce them, from multiple suppliers and penalty contracts to insurance and sourcing spread across regions.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Supply chain tiers and the two flows

  • 02

    The bullwhip effect, its causes and remedies

  • 03

    Make or buy and outsourcing logic

  • 04

    Six sourcing strategies

  • 05

    Weighted supplier scoring with qualifying thresholds

  • 06

    Buyer-supplier power and supply risk

Worked example · free

Trace the bullwhip effect through four tiers of weekly orders

Q [6 marks]. AskSia-authored practice. Consumer sales are 100 units a week, then rise to 110 from week 4 and stay there. Each tier orders what it received that week plus the change from the week before. Work out the week 4 and week 5 orders of the retailer, wholesaler and manufacturer, and explain the pattern. Marks shown here are AskSia practice marks, not marks published by the University.
Figure 6.1.Figure 6.1. Weekly units at four tiers after consumer sales rise once from 100 to 110: each tier orders what it received plus the latest change, so the peak rise above 100 grows from 10 at the shelf to 20, 40 and finally 80 in manufacturer orders.18010060148weekunits per weekmanufacturer orderswholesaler ordersretailer ordersconsumer sales
Figure 6.1. Weekly units at four tiers after consumer sales rise once from 100 to 110: each tier orders what it received plus the latest change, so the peak rise above 100 grows from 10 at the shelf to 20, 40 and finally 80 in manufacturer orders.
  • 2Retailer: week 4 order 110 + 10 = 120, week 5 order 110 + 0 = 110.
  • 2Wholesaler sees 100 then 120: week 4 order 120 + 20 = 140, week 5 order 110 minus 10 = 100.
  • 2Manufacturer sees 100 then 140: week 4 order 140 + 40 = 180, week 5 order 100 minus 40 = 60; peak rises above 100 of 10, 20, 40 and 80.
A lasting rise of ten units at the shelf becomes an 80-unit peak rise and then a drop to 60 at the manufacturer. Each tier reacts to the orders below it rather than to consumer sales, so the peak rise doubles at every tier. Sharing point-of-sale data with every tier is the lecture's remedy for this cause.
Sia tip — Write each tier's incoming demand in a row before computing its order, so you never mix up what a tier saw with what it sent.
Glossary

Key terms

First-Tier Supplier
A company that supplies the focal operation directly, as opposed to one that supplies those suppliers.
Supply Base Rationalisation
Reducing the number of suppliers so that the buyer can work more closely with fewer of them.
Vertical Integration
Taking over activities previously bought in, either backwards towards suppliers or forwards towards customers.
Zone of Agreement
The price range between a supplier's production cost and the product's value to the buyer, inside which a deal can be struck.
Keiretsu Network
A supplier coalition between few suppliers and full integration, often tied together by ownership or loans.
FAQ

Supply Chain Design, Supplier Selection and Risk FAQ

What causes the bullwhip effect?

The lecture lists four causes. Forecasting errors accumulate as each tier forecasts from orders instead of real demand. Order batching produces large, infrequent orders. Price fluctuations encourage buying ahead of need, and shortage gaming inflates orders when supply is rationed. Each cause has a matching remedy, starting with sharing demand information.

How should a firm decide what to outsource?

Ask whether the activity is strategically important, whether the firm holds specialised knowledge for it, whether its performance is already superior and whether significant improvement is likely. The questions work as a chain: a yes to any one of them points towards keeping the activity in-house, and only when all four answers are no is outsourcing worth exploring.

Why combine weighted scores with minimum thresholds?

A weighted total lets strength on one criterion offset weakness on another, which is acceptable only within limits. A threshold removes any supplier that fails a must-have requirement, such as reliable delivery, before ranking begins, so a cheap but unreliable supplier cannot win on its total alone.

What is the difference between few and many suppliers?

Many suppliers compete mainly on price and carry responsibility for their own technology and quality. A few long-term suppliers allow economies of scale, learning and joint design work, and they cooperate more readily with just-in-time supply, but switching becomes costly and trade secrets are more exposed.

How can a buyer reduce supply chain risk?

Research likely disruptions and plan responses in advance, then match tactics to the risk: multiple suppliers and penalty contracts for delivery failure, certification and monitoring for quality, alternative routes for logistics, secure systems for information, insurance and cross-country spread for political, economic and natural hazards.

Study strategy

Exam move

Start by drawing a supply chain you know with two tiers on each side of a focal firm, and mark which way materials and information travel. Then rehearse the bullwhip arithmetic with your own small demand change and a simple ordering rule, and name the cause and remedy that apply.

For supplier selection, build a five-criterion scoring table for three invented suppliers, compute weighted totals, and then add one minimum threshold to see whether the winner changes; practise writing two sentences explaining why. Finally, list the six sourcing strategies from fewest to most integrated and attach one benefit and one risk to each.

Being able to move from a calculation to a short, reasoned recommendation is the skill the decision-making outcomes ask for, and the frameworks give essay arguments their structure.

Working through Supply Chain Design, Supplier Selection and Risk in 38004? Sia is AskSia’s AI Management tutor — ask any 38004 Supply Chain Design, Supplier Selection and Risk question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how 38004 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 17 of your subjects at University of Birmingham, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your 38004 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 4-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works
38004 · Organisational Decision Making and Operations Management - independent study guide on the AskSia Library. More University of Birmingham subjects · Microeconomics across all universities