University of Birmingham · FACULTY OF MANAGEMENT

38010 Chap.8 Global Institutions and the Rules of Trade

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
7 Chapters4-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 8 of 13 · 38010

Global Institutions and the Rules of Trade

A club with a binding referee

The GATT, founded in 1948, became the World Trade Organization in 1995. What set the WTO apart was a disputes system whose rulings bound members, so a country harmed by rule-breaking could win redress and large economies lost the freedom to ignore the damage they caused.

China joined in 2001 amid Western hopes of convergence.

Rules giving way to power

Since 2017 the United States has blocked appointments to the appellate body, and the Biden administration has kept the block in place. Appeals now go nowhere, so disputes stall, move to an alternative arrangement joined by 25 members, or end in unilateral retaliation.

China's tariffs of more than 200% on Australian wine show how political quarrels now drive trade measures.

New defences and regional tracks

Governments are adding investment screening, anti-coercion tools and tariff powers of their own, while regional deals such as RCEP and the African Continental Free Trade Area keep liberalisation moving outside a gridlocked WTO of 164 members.

Critics add that WTO rules narrow the policy space poorer countries need for infant industries.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    GATT to the WTO

  • 02

    Binding dispute settlement

  • 03

    Non-discrimination principle

  • 04

    Appellate body blockage

  • 05

    Rules versus power

  • 06

    Investment screening and anti-coercion

  • 07

    Regional trade blocs

Worked example · free

Read the route of a blocked WTO appeal

Q [4 marks]. AskSia-authored practice. With the appellate body blocked since 2017, 25 WTO members set up an alternative appeal system, and by June it handled 7 of 60 active disputes. The WTO has 164 members. Work out what share of members joined the alternative system and what share of active disputes it covers, then say what the two figures together imply for an exporter. Marks shown here are an AskSia study allocation and are not an official University scheme.
The route of a WTO dispute after appointments were blocked.The route of a WTO dispute after appointments were blocked. Blue arrows show the normal sequence from a complaint filed to an appeal; red arrows show that, with the appellate body blocked since 2017, a case now ends in legal limbo, an alternative appeal system or unilateral retaliation. Complaint filed WTO ruling Appeal lodged Appellate body Blocked since 2017 Legal limbo Alternative appeal system Unilateral retaliation
The route of a WTO dispute after appointments were blocked. Blue arrows show the normal sequence from a complaint filed to an appeal; red arrows show that, with the appellate body blocked since 2017, a case now ends in legal limbo, an alternative appeal system or unilateral retaliation.
  • 1Share of members: 25 / 164 = 0.152, so about 15% of WTO members joined.
  • 1Share of active disputes: 7 / 60 = 0.117, so about 12% of active disputes use the system.
  • 1Interpret: because big traders such as Britain, Japan and India stayed out, the arrangement is used in only a small minority of active disputes, so most cases still lack a working appeal.
  • 1Implication: an exporter cannot count on a binding ruling, so it should plan for stalled cases or unilateral retaliation.
About 15% of members joined the alternative system and it covers about 12% of active disputes. Most cases therefore still lack a working appeal, so an exporter should treat a first ruling in its favour as uncertain and plan for delay or retaliation.
Sia tip — When you cite the appellate body crisis, say which exit a dispute actually takes: legal limbo, the alternative appeal system or unilateral retaliation.
Glossary

Key terms

Binding Dispute Settlement
Binding dispute settlement is a procedure whose rulings members must accept, letting a country harmed by rule-breaking obtain redress against a larger partner.
Non-Discrimination Principle
The non-discrimination principle is the core WTO rule the reading names; in practice it means a member treating its trading partners alike instead of favouring allies or punishing rivals.
Investment Screening
Investment screening means a government reviewing foreign purchases of domestic firms or assets, increasingly on national-security grounds.
Anti-Coercion Tool
An anti-coercion tool, under study in the EU, would let the bloc respond quickly when a foreign power uses trade pressure against one member state.
Regional Trade Agreement
A regional trade agreement liberalises trade among a group of neighbouring countries, such as RCEP in Asia-Pacific or the African Continental Free Trade Area.
FAQ

Global Institutions and the Rules of Trade FAQ

What made the WTO different from the GATT?

The GATT, founded in 1948, became the WTO in 1995, and the new body added a binding disputes system. A member harmed by rule-breaking could win redress, which meant large economies could no longer assume that harm they did to smaller partners would carry no consequences.

Why can WTO appeals no longer be heard?

In 2017 the Trump administration began blocking appointments to the appellate body, and the Biden administration has continued the block. With no new appointments the appeal court has stopped working, so a losing party can appeal and leave the case in legal limbo instead of accepting the ruling.

What have WTO members done about the blocked appeal court?

Twenty-five members, including China and the EU, set up their own appeal arrangement, but large traders such as Britain, Japan, India, Russia and South Korea stayed out, and it covered only seven of 60 active disputes as of June. Around 121 members ask the United States monthly to restore appointments.

How do regional trade blocs fit alongside the WTO?

Blocs such as RCEP, signed by 15 Asia-Pacific economies in November 2020, and the African Continental Free Trade Area keep liberalisation going when the WTO cannot agree new rules. Lecture 2 adds that Global South blocs leave more room for supporting infant industries than WTO rules do.

Why are governments screening more foreign investment?

Security concerns now overlap with economic ones. Since the start of 2020 at least 25 countries and the EU have strengthened or created screening regimes, and as many as 34 countries, which together account for half of global direct investment flows, now review foreign investment.

Study strategy

Assessment move

Sketch the dispute route from memory: complaint, ruling, appeal, appellate body, then the three exits that now follow a blocked appeal. Next to each exit write one example from the readings, such as the case China brought against American tariffs, the 25-member appeal arrangement or Britain's new tariff powers.

Practise the four-step test in this chapter on a trade measure from the news, asking about its stated ground, timing, forum and targets. For a policy argument, decide whether your case depends on the WTO being able to enforce rules; if it does, say how the policy would work while appeals cannot be heard. Finally, keep the WTO critics' point about infant-industry policy space ready as a counter-argument.

Working through Global Institutions and the Rules of Trade in 38010? Sia is AskSia’s AI Management tutor — ask any 38010 Global Institutions and the Rules of Trade question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how 38010 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 17 of your subjects at University of Birmingham, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your 38010 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 4-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works
38010 · Strategically Understanding the Business Environment - independent study guide on the AskSia Library. More University of Birmingham subjects · Microeconomics across all universities