University of Birmingham · FACULTY OF MANAGEMENT

38010 Chap.9 Resilience, Industrial Policy and Green Trade

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
7 Chapters5-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 9 of 13 · 38010

Resilience, Industrial Policy and Green Trade

Facts, friends and fortification

After covid exposed fragile supply chains, rich-country governments began gathering facts about dependence, working with allies to friend-shore production and fortifying their economies with defensive trade tools.

A European review found only around 34 of 5,000 imported products both dominated by one supplier and hard to substitute, worth 0.6% of imports by value.

Subsidies and reshoring

Industrial policy has returned: subsidies for semiconductors, batteries and green technology, local-content rules and reshoring for resilience.

A simple cost comparison shows who pays when home assembly is backed by a tariff or by a subsidy, and the report warns that subsidy races create gluts and that reshoring makes future trade barriers cheaper to impose.

Greener trade

Trade and environmental policy, once kept apart, are converging.

Tariff schedules implicitly subsidise carbon, a little under a third of domestic emission cuts can leak abroad, and the EU's carbon border adjustment mechanism aims to spread carbon pricing, while some green measures look like protection for local jobs. The chapter's practice asks you to argue both sides of such a charge.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Supply-chain dependence reviews

  • 02

    Friend-shoring and alliances

  • 03

    Defensive trade tools

  • 04

    Reshoring cost arithmetic

  • 05

    Subsidy races and gluts

  • 06

    Carbon leakage and border adjustment

  • 07

    Green measures as protection

Worked example · free

Measure how few imported products are hard to replace

Q [4 marks]. AskSia-authored practice. A European Commission review of 5,000 imported products found 137 with a dominant foreign supplier, of which around 34 were hard to substitute, worth 0.6% of imports by value. Calculate the share of reviewed products with a dominant supplier, the share of those that were hard to substitute, and the share of all reviewed products that were hard to substitute, then judge what the figures say about resilience policy. The mark allocation is AskSia's own study weighting and is not an official University scheme.
How few imported products are truly hard to replace.How few imported products are truly hard to replace. Bar lengths are drawn to scale: of 5,000 imported products the European Commission reviewed, 137 had a dominant foreign supplier and only around 34 were hard to substitute, worth just 0.6% of imports by value. 5,000 imported products 137 with dominant supplier 34 hard to substitute Only 0.6% by value
How few imported products are truly hard to replace. Bar lengths are drawn to scale: of 5,000 imported products the European Commission reviewed, 137 had a dominant foreign supplier and only around 34 were hard to substitute, worth just 0.6% of imports by value.
  • 1Dominant supplier: 137 / 5,000 = 0.0274, about 2.7% of reviewed products.
  • 1Hard to substitute among those: 34 / 137 = 0.248, about a quarter.
  • 1Hard to substitute among all reviewed: 34 / 5,000 = 0.0068, about 0.7% of products and 0.6% of import value.
  • 1Judge: true dependence is narrow, so broad tariffs or reshoring are poorly targeted, though a cheap single-source part can still halt production.
About 2.7% of reviewed products had a dominant supplier, a quarter of those were hard to replace, and only about 0.7% of all products, 0.6% of import value, were truly exposed. The case for resilience policy is real but narrow, so targeted measures beat broad protection. The review may still understate exposure, as a single-sourced part costing five dollars showed.
Sia tip — Before backing a resilience policy, find the share of inputs that are both single-sourced and hard to substitute, then aim the policy only at that share.
Glossary

Key terms

Strategic Dependence
Strategic dependence is reliance on a foreign supplier for an input that is hard to substitute, so that a cut-off could halt domestic production.
Reshoring
Reshoring brings production that had moved abroad back into the home country, for reasons Lecture 2 lists as resilience, control of intellectual property and faster cycles.
Local-Content Requirement
Local-content requirements oblige buyers, often public bodies, to source a stated share of a product from domestic producers.
Production-Linked Incentive
India's production-linked incentives pay qualifying firms cash equal to a small percentage of the extra sales they achieve in favoured industries.
Carbon Border Adjustment
A carbon border adjustment charges importers for the carbon in their goods, charging less when the exporting country already prices carbon.
FAQ

Resilience, Industrial Policy and Green Trade FAQ

Why did governments start worrying about supply-chain resilience?

The pandemic brought export restrictions on medical products, a slump in Chinese exports and shortages of goods such as masks. Governments concluded that leaving supply security to firms was too risky, and policy in America, Europe, Mexico and Japan began to treat resilience as a goal alongside efficiency.

What does facts, friends and fortification mean?

It is the special report's summary of rich-country responses. Facts means reviewing supply chains to find real dependence; friends means working with allies and friend-shoring production away from rivals; fortification means defensive trade tools, procurement rules, local-content requirements and subsidies at home.

Who pays when a government backs home assembly?

It depends on the tool. In the chapter's invented example, home assembly costs 84 pounds a unit against 48 pounds for an import carrying a 20% tariff. A tariff of 110% closes the gap but makes buyers pay 84 pounds; keeping the 20% tariff and adding a 36-pound subsidy holds the price at 48 pounds and shifts most of the cost, 36 of the 44 pounds, to taxpayers.

What is carbon leakage and why does it matter for trade?

Carbon leakage happens when emission cuts at home are partly offset by higher emissions abroad as production shifts. Modelling in the reading finds a little under a third of cuts can leak, more in steel and aluminium, which is why the EU is designing a carbon border adjustment for importers.

Can green trade measures be protectionist?

Yes. The WTO director-general thinks a carbon border adjustment can avoid protectionism if designed carefully, but measures such as India's planned 40% tariffs on imported solar modules and Buy America conditions on infrastructure look more like attempts to capture jobs, and they can make climate goals dearer to reach.

Study strategy

Assessment move

Build a one-page table with three columns, facts, friends and fortification, and file every resilience policy you meet under one of them with its country and date. Rework the reshoring cost comparison with your own numbers, changing only the lines a policy touches, and always compute the break-even tariff.

For each subsidy programme in the chapter, write one sentence on what could go wrong if allies copy it, using the glut argument. When you read about a green trade measure, ask two questions: does it reduce emissions or leakage, and who pays, domestic buyers or foreign exporters? Answers to those questions give a policy report its balance, and they work equally well in a group video argument.

Working through Resilience, Industrial Policy and Green Trade in 38010? Sia is AskSia’s AI Management tutor — ask any 38010 Resilience, Industrial Policy and Green Trade question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how 38010 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 17 of your subjects at University of Birmingham, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your 38010 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 5-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works
38010 · Strategically Understanding the Business Environment - independent study guide on the AskSia Library. More University of Birmingham subjects · Microeconomics across all universities