University of Birmingham · FACULTY OF MANAGEMENT

38010 Chap.3 Theories of the Transnational Corporation

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
8 Chapters4-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 3 of 13 · 38010

Theories of the Transnational Corporation

What a TNC is

Lecture 3 shows that definitions of the transnational corporation differ by emphasis: location of headquarters, control of plants abroad, power over operations it may not own, or a single centre of strategic decisions. Common to all is a firm that coordinates and controls production across borders.

Such firms have a long history, from Italian banking houses of 1400 to the chartered companies, and their modern form grew rapidly between the 1950s and 1970s under American leadership.

Why firms go abroad

The theory begins with Coase's explanation of why firms exist, then Hymer's insight that a foreign firm must hold firm-specific advantages to overcome the disadvantage of being foreign.

Internalisation theory explains why firms keep those advantages in-house, and Vernon's product life cycle adds a sequence of locations.

Dunning's eclectic paradigm combines ownership, location and internalisation advantages into one test.

Alternative views

Cowling and Sugden define the TNC by where strategic decisions are made, using Benetton's plants and subcontractors, while Mathews' dragon multinationals explain latecomer firms that grew abroad through linkage, leverage and learning.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Competing definitions of the TNC

  • 02

    TNC versus MNC

  • 03

    Hymer and the M-form corporation

  • 04

    Coase and transaction costs

  • 05

    Firm-specific advantages

  • 06

    Internalisation and the product life cycle

  • 07

    Dunning's eclectic paradigm

  • 08

    Dragon multinationals and LLL

Worked example · free

Walk a firm through the ownership, location and internalisation questions

Q [4 marks]. AskSia-authored practice. A food company owns a famous sauce recipe and brand. A large overseas market has strong demand for it, but local partners are reliable and the recipe is protected by trademark, so licensing carries little risk. Use the eclectic paradigm to predict how it will serve the market. Marks shown are an AskSia study weighting, not a University mark allocation.
The eclectic paradigm read as three questions in a row.The eclectic paradigm read as three questions in a row. Read left to right: when all three answers are yes, the paradigm predicts production abroad, and each red exit shows the alternative the theory implies when one condition fails. Ownership advantage? Location advantage? Internalisation advantage? Produce abroad No basis abroad Exploit at home Sell or lease Green arrows mean yes
The eclectic paradigm read as three questions in a row. Read left to right: when all three answers are yes, the paradigm predicts production abroad, and each red exit shows the alternative the theory implies when one condition fails.
  • 1Ownership: the recipe and brand are advantages local rivals lack, so the first question is answered yes.
  • 1Location: strong demand abroad gives a reason to use the asset in that market, so the second question is yes.
  • 1Internalisation: with reliable partners and a protected trademark, the firm gains little by keeping production in-house, so the third question is no.
  • 1Conclusion: the path exits at sell or lease, so the paradigm predicts licensing rather than its own plant.
The firm passes the ownership and location questions but fails the internalisation question, so the eclectic paradigm predicts it will license the recipe and brand to a local producer rather than invest in production abroad. If licensing became risky, the prediction would switch to a plant of its own.
Sia tip — Answer all three eclectic paradigm questions in order and name the evidence for each before predicting an entry mode.
Glossary

Key terms

Firm-Specific Advantage
A firm-specific advantage is an asset such as scale, market power, marketing skill or cheap finance that lets a foreign firm compete against better-informed local rivals.
Transaction Costs
Transaction costs are the costs of organising exchange through markets, which Coase argued firms reduce by coordinating transactions internally.
Product Life Cycle
Vernon's product life cycle links a product's maturity to its location, with new products made at home and production moving abroad as the product becomes established.
Multidivisional Structure
The multidivisional or M-form structure separates a head office from operating divisions, a design adopted at General Motors and Du Pont that made adding foreign divisions easy.
Dragon Multinational
Mathews uses this term for latecomer multinationals from emerging economies that internationalised fast through linkage, leverage and learning rather than existing advantages.
FAQ

Theories of the Transnational Corporation FAQ

Is there a difference between a TNC and an MNC?

The lecture treats the choice as largely personal, since scholars use both. Multinational suggests a firm rooted in each country where it operates, while transnational suggests one operating across borders. In practice both refer to a firm that coordinates and controls production in more than one country.

Why did Hymer think firms need special advantages to operate abroad?

A firm entering a foreign market is at a disadvantage against local firms that know the customers, rules and suppliers. To compete it must possess firm-specific advantages such as scale, market power, marketing skills or cheaper finance, and it must have a reason not to sell those advantages to local firms.

What does Dunning's eclectic paradigm add to earlier theories?

It combines partial explanations into one test. A firm will produce abroad when it holds ownership advantages, finds location advantages in using them abroad, and gains more from exploiting them itself than from selling or leasing them, the internalisation advantage.

How does the strategic decision-making approach define a TNC differently?

Cowling and Sugden define the TNC by where strategic decisions are made rather than by ownership. That widens the definition to include subcontractors a firm directs, as with Benetton's main plants and its many subcontractors, and changes how the impacts of TNCs are assessed.

Why do dragon multinationals challenge older theory?

Older theory expects a firm to go abroad to exploit advantages it already holds. Mathews observed latecomer firms that grew rapidly abroad despite dominant incumbents, internationalising early to link with partners, leverage their resources and learn, which his LLL framework captures.

Study strategy

Assessment move

Build a one-page comparison table of the theories with three columns: the question each answers, its key idea and its main limitation, then test yourself by covering one column. Practise the eclectic paradigm as three questions asked in order and apply it to two firms you read about in the news, one that invested abroad and one that licensed. Learn the four definitions of a TNC by their emphasis rather than by heart.

When an article describes an emerging-market multinational, note which of Mathews' three Ls the evidence supports. Keep the table beside you when reading the seminar cases, so each case adds one example to a theory.

Working through Theories of the Transnational Corporation in 38010? Sia is AskSia’s AI Management tutor — ask any 38010 Theories of the Transnational Corporation question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how 38010 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 17 of your subjects at University of Birmingham, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your 38010 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 4-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works
38010 · Strategically Understanding the Business Environment - independent study guide on the AskSia Library. More University of Birmingham subjects · Microeconomics across all universities