University of Birmingham · FACULTY OF MANAGEMENT

38010 Chap.4 TNC Operations, Takeovers and Host Economies

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
7 Chapters3-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 4 of 13 · 38010

TNC Operations, Takeovers and Host Economies

Takeovers as a route abroad

Lecture 4 asks how transnational corporations operate and what they do to host and home economies.

The Week 3 seminar reading on takeovers and takeover policy traces six waves of mergers since the 1890s, the later ones increasingly cross-border and including Indian and Chinese acquirers, and shows that bid premiums climb as a wave matures while the evidence on acquirers' returns is poor.

The Kraft bid for Cadbury

Kraft won Cadbury in 2010 through a hostile bid raised from about 10.2 billion to 11.5 billion pounds.

Its assurance on the Somerdale plant was broken soon afterwards, hedge funds profited from a one-way bet, and the government had no power to intervene because public interest powers had been removed in 2002.

Policy choices for host countries

The reading compares the UK with France, Canada, Germany, the US and Japan, uses the Pfizer bid for AstraZeneca to show the stakes, and sets out four sets of reform, from tax incentives for long-term holding to a new public interest test that is not aimed at foreign bids as such.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Six takeover waves

  • 02

    Bid premiums by phase

  • 03

    Evidence on acquisition returns

  • 04

    The Kraft takeover of Cadbury

  • 05

    Assurances and hedge funds

  • 06

    Public interest tests abroad

  • 07

    Four sets of takeover reform

Worked example · free

Place a bid premium on the phases of a takeover wave

Q [4 marks]. AskSia-authored practice. An invented food company's shares trade at 6.00 pounds before a bid. A rival offers 9.00 pounds a share. Calculate the bid premium, place it among the phase premiums reported in the reading, and say what the evidence implies for the bidder. Any marks shown are an AskSia allocation for study purposes, not one published by the University.
Average bid premiums at each phase of a takeover wave.Average bid premiums at each phase of a takeover wave. Bars show the premium ranges reported for the four phases, rising from 10 to 18% to above 100%, and the dashed line marks the 40% premium beyond which the chances of a profitable combination fall significantly; the third and fourth bars are open-ended ranges drawn to the next marker. Phase 1 Phase 2 Phase 3 Phase 4 40% warning 0% 50% 100% Bid premium
Average bid premiums at each phase of a takeover wave. Bars show the premium ranges reported for the four phases, rising from 10 to 18% to above 100%, and the dashed line marks the 40% premium beyond which the chances of a profitable combination fall significantly; the third and fourth bars are open-ended ranges drawn to the next marker.
  • 1Premium = (9.00 - 6.00) / 6.00 = 3.00 / 6.00 = 0.50, a 50% premium.
  • 1Compare with the phases: above the 20 to 35% of the second phase and at the threshold of the third phase's premiums of over 50%.
  • 1Compare with the warning line: 50% is above the 40% premium beyond which the chances of a profitable combination fall significantly.
  • 1Implication: the target's shareholders gain, but the bidder's shareholders face a high risk that the deal destroys value.
The offer carries a 50% premium, which sits at the start of the late-wave range and above the 40% level past which, the reading reports, the chances of a profitable combination fall significantly. Target shareholders would gain, while the evidence suggests the bidder's own shareholders are likely to lose.
Sia tip — Turn any bid into a premium percentage first, then compare it with the 40% warning line before judging the deal.
Glossary

Key terms

Takeover Wave
A takeover wave is a period of clustered merger and acquisition activity; the reading identifies six since the 1890s and a seventh forming since 2013.
Bid Premium
The bid premium is the amount by which an offer price exceeds the target's market price before the bid, usually stated as a percentage.
Hostile Takeover
In a hostile takeover the bidder pursues control against the wishes of the target's board, appealing directly to shareholders.
Public Interest Test
A public interest test lets a government examine a takeover on grounds wider than competition, which the UK largely removed in its Enterprise Act 2002.
White Knight
A white knight is a friendlier alternative bidder found to rescue a target from an unwanted offer, a tactic the reading associates with France.
FAQ

TNC Operations, Takeovers and Host Economies FAQ

What happened when Kraft took over Cadbury?

Kraft won Cadbury in 2010 after a long hostile bid, raising its offer from about 10.2 billion to 11.5 billion pounds. It assured stakeholders the Somerdale plant would stay open, then announced soon after completion that production would move to Poland. The government protested but had no legal power to intervene.

Why could the UK government not stop the Cadbury takeover?

The Enterprise Act 2002 removed the public interest test for takeovers, except in defence, media, water and later financial stability. Without it, the government could act only on competition grounds, so the Business Secretary could object to the deal but had no legal basis to block it.

Do takeovers usually benefit the acquiring firm?

The evidence in the reading is largely negative. Studies found takeovers rarely raise profits, one consultancy found only 23% of 116 acquirers recovered their cost of capital, and event studies show acquirers' share prices falling for six months to three years while targets' shareholders gain.

How do other countries treat foreign takeovers?

France often intervenes and seeks a domestic white knight. Canada blocked BHP Billiton's bid for Potash Corporation in 2010 under a net benefit test. US firms can use poison pills, Germany sets control at 75% rather than the UK's 50.1%, and Japanese cross-shareholdings make hostile bids very difficult.

What reforms does the reading propose for UK takeover policy?

It proposes four sets: tax and financial changes that reward long-term holding; governance changes such as employee board representation; Takeover Code changes including a two-thirds control threshold and votes only for holders of at least a year; and a new public interest test triggered by size thresholds and not targeted at foreign bids.

Study strategy

Assessment move

Read the takeover reading for its argument, not just the Cadbury story: note the waves, the premium evidence and the four reform sets as three separate pieces of evidence you can cite. Then build a short timeline of the Cadbury deal from the hostile bid to the Somerdale announcement and the reviews that followed.

Practise stating the case for and against a public interest test in two balanced sentences each, because any policy argument in this area must answer the charge of protectionism. Compare the UK's rules with one other country from the reading and explain what difference it would have made to the Cadbury outcome.

Finish by listing the questions a host government could ask a bidder, and which of them current UK rules would let it enforce.

Working through TNC Operations, Takeovers and Host Economies in 38010? Sia is AskSia’s AI Management tutor — ask any 38010 TNC Operations, Takeovers and Host Economies question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how 38010 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 17 of your subjects at University of Birmingham, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your 38010 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 3-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works
38010 · Strategically Understanding the Business Environment - independent study guide on the AskSia Library. More University of Birmingham subjects · Microeconomics across all universities