7SSGN223 Chap.6 Cost-Benefit and Ecosystem Valuation
Cost-Benefit and Ecosystem Valuation
Start with a counterfactual
Cost-benefit analysis compares the social costs and benefits of a project, programme or policy as far as practicable in monetary terms.
A do-nothing baseline and one or more intervention options are essential because benefits are changes relative to what would otherwise happen, not every favourable outcome observed after a project begins.
Track who experiences each effect
Capital, operating, environmental and social effects fall on different groups and times.
A positive aggregate can conceal a concentrated loss, so distribution should be reported alongside the total. Transfers need careful treatment because one actor's payment can be another actor's receipt without becoming a net social cost.
Choose a valuation route that fits
Alternative-use value, travel-cost behaviour, stated preference and hedonic pricing observe different relationships.
Travel cost uses accepted money and time for visits, stated preference depends on designed choices or questions, and hedonic pricing infers attribute value from market differences. Each method has its own population and bias.
Keep non-market limits visible
An unavailable monetary estimate does not make an ecological or cultural effect worthless.
Report effects in physical or qualitative terms, test whether plausible values change the ranking and resist false precision. Conclude with the preferred option, distribution, omitted effects and sensitivity rather than one unqualified net number.
Align units and populations
Journey and time costs must be expressed per trip before multiplication by annual trips.
Other streams need a currency year, reporting period and consistent inflation treatment. Explain discounting rather than hiding it in a total. Travel behaviour represents observed visitors, not non-visitors or people unable to travel; stated preference and hedonic methods also represent particular samples or markets.
Name whose choices enter and whose interests remain outside each estimate.
Test whether the ranking is robust
Vary visitor counts, time values, project life, maintenance costs and other influential assumptions over plausible ranges. Identify the point at which the preferred option reverses. A fragile result may justify better evidence, a staged project or a reversible design.
Present transfers separately from real resource costs, report group-level effects and explain why the recommendation remains proportionate when major ecological or cultural effects cannot be monetised reliably.
What this chapter covers
- 01
Do-Nothing Baseline
- 02
Social Costs
- 03
Social Benefits
- 04
Distribution
- 05
Valuation Methods
- 06
Sensitivity Analysis
Worked example · free
Calculate observed travel cost
- 2Calculate the per-trip observed cost.
- 2Multiply by annual trips with units.
- 4Identify values outside the estimate.
Key terms
- Counterfactual
- A Counterfactual is the estimated condition that would have occurred without the intervention being evaluated.
- Travel Cost
- Travel Cost is a behavioural valuation approach using accepted journey and time costs as evidence of recreational use value.
- Hedonic Pricing
- Hedonic Pricing infers the value of an environmental attribute from differences in market prices where that attribute is traded implicitly.
Cost-Benefit and Ecosystem Valuation FAQ
Why is a do-nothing option necessary?
Benefits and costs are changes relative to what would otherwise happen. Without a baseline, natural trends or other policies can be credited to the intervention. A credible do-nothing case also reveals whether delay, maintenance or existing commitments already carry costs.
Does monetisation capture total environmental value?
Usually not. Each method observes a defined relationship and population. Travel behaviour captures use by visitors, while stated preference or market methods address other components with different assumptions. Report ecological, cultural and distributional effects that remain outside the estimate.
How should distribution be reported in a CBA?
Identify who pays, who benefits and when each effect occurs. Present concentrated losses even when the aggregate is positive, and distinguish resource costs from transfers. A policy recommendation should explain whether compensation, redesign or a constraint is needed.
What makes a valuation result robust?
Its units, currency year, population and counterfactual are explicit, and the ranking survives plausible changes to influential assumptions. Report the switching value when it does not. Robustness also requires non-monetised ecological and cultural effects, transfers and distribution to remain visible beside the aggregate monetary result.
Assessment move
For one intervention, write the do-nothing baseline and two realistic alternatives. Build a table of effects, affected groups, timing and evidence. Calculate the travel-cost example with changed visitor and time values, then explain why the result is not total ecosystem value. Finish by adding one non-monetised effect and one sensitivity that could reverse the option ranking.
Record the currency year and reporting period for every monetary input, then identify any payment that is a transfer rather than a net social resource cost. Recalculate the result with a lower visitor count, different time value and higher maintenance cost. State the switching value at which the preferred option changes.
Finally, add columns for non-visitors, burdened groups and ecological effects outside the monetary total, and write a recommendation that remains valid across the plausible sensitivity range.