BIOL10521 Chap.6 Fitness and Sexual Selection
Fitness and Sexual Selection
Fitness is relative genetic contribution in a stated environment, not strength, health or longevity alone. Heterozygote advantage can maintain an allele that is harmful in another genotype, as in sickle-cell and malaria. Sexual selection explains traits that reduce survival yet increase mating success.
The relevant balance is total reproductive outcome, and apparent spread does not by itself prove that an allele's own phenotype was selected because linkage and drift also matter. Context enters through genotype, environment and the comparison group. The same allele may lower fitness in one combination while increasing it in another, so labels such as good gene hide the actual relationship.
Costly ornaments demonstrate why survival cannot serve as the sole denominator: an individual may face greater predation yet leave more descendants through mating success. Conversely, long life without reproduction supplies no direct genetic contribution. Linkage provides another caution because a neutral or harmful variant can rise beside a selected allele.
The chapter therefore asks students to identify the phenotype exposed to selection, measure all routes to reproduction and state the relative outcome rather than assigning an absolute fitness score.
What this chapter covers
- 01
Relative fitness
- 02
Environmental context
- 03
Heterozygote advantage
- 04
Phenotype-level selection
- 05
Sexual selection
- 06
Genetic hitchhiking
Worked example · free
Evaluate a costly mating trait
- 1Identify the tail's negative contribution to survival.
- 1Identify its positive contribution through additional matings.
- 1Compare total surviving descendant contribution among phenotypes.
- 1Predict spread when reproductive benefit exceeds survival cost.
Key terms
- Relative fitness
- Reproductive contribution compared with alternative genotypes.
- Heterozygote advantage
- Higher fitness of a heterozygote than either homozygote.
- Sexual selection
- Evolutionary filtering produced by unequal success in obtaining mates.
- Hitchhiking
- Frequency change caused by linkage to a selected allele.
Fitness and Sexual Selection FAQ
Why is fitness context dependent?
The same genotype can produce different outcomes across environments or genetic backgrounds. An allele associated with disease in homozygotes may persist where heterozygotes receive malaria protection, so fitness cannot be assigned without naming context.
Can a trait lower survival and still spread?
Yes. Survival is one pathway to reproduction, not the final denominator. If a costly ornament produces enough additional successful matings, its bearers may leave more descendants and the trait can increase through sexual selection.
Does an increasing allele prove adaptation?
Not necessarily. Neutral drift or linkage to another selected variant can change frequency. Establish the expressed phenotype and its effect on survival or reproduction before attributing the allele's trajectory to direct selection.
Why is fitness relative?
Fitness compares genetic contribution among alternatives in one context. A raw offspring count is informative only against competitors and survival conditions. Changing environment or genotype frequencies can change the ranking, so the comparison must be named.
What limits an ornament?
Mating benefit may initially exceed survival cost, allowing exaggeration. As the trait becomes more costly, further mating gains may no longer compensate. The observed form reflects that balance rather than unlimited movement toward maximum conspicuousness.
Exam move
Rewrite vague fitness statements into comparative ones: genotype A leaves more descendants than genotype B under environment E. Practise heterozygote advantage by listing both genotype and environment rather than treating an allele as universally good or bad. For sexual traits, draw a balance between survival cost and mating benefit, then decide from total reproduction.
Add one counterexample involving hitchhiking so that frequency increase is not automatically equated with adaptation. During revision, ban the words strongest and healthiest unless they are explicitly connected to reproduction. Finish every answer with the comparison group and context that make the fitness claim meaningful. Construct genotype-by-environment tables in which the ranking changes when malaria is present or absent.
Explain why an allele cannot be labelled beneficial without specifying homozygous, heterozygous or alternative genetic backgrounds. For ornaments, list energetic cost, predation exposure, mating gain and offspring produced, then ask which terms affect total genetic contribution. Contrast mate choice with competition among rivals and state how both can generate sexual selection.
Add a neutral substitution and a linked harmful allele to practise alternatives to direct adaptation. When an allele rises, demand evidence connecting its phenotype to the fitness difference before declaring it selected. Use relative language consistently: a genotype has higher fitness than another within the measured context, not a universal amount of fitness.
Create short distractors equating longevity, body size or health with fitness and correct them using reproduction. Finish with a transfer example in which the same visible trait changes value across seasons. This forces the environment into the explanation and prevents fitness from becoming a fixed property of the organism.
Working through Fitness and Sexual Selection in BIOL10521? Sia is AskSia’s AI Biology tutor — ask any BIOL10521 Fitness and Sexual Selection question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how BIOL10521 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.