BIOL10521 Chap.5 Selection in Changing Environments
Selection in Changing Environments
Selection pressures can reverse as environments change. Soot and later cleaner air altered camouflage advantages in peppered moths, while harvesting and poaching changed which phenotypes escaped human detection. Culture can create selection, as dairying did for lactase persistence. When a function stops affecting fitness, relaxed selection can allow disabling mutations to accumulate.
Evidence must be placed across the generation boundary to distinguish selection from evolution. Before-and-after studies are most informative when they combine population sampling, performance tests, inheritance and descendant data. Immediate survivor differences establish filtering, while later generations test whether the change was transmitted.
Human practices can act as environments without deliberately controlling the genetic response. Dairying changes dietary opportunity, harvesting changes visibility costs and poaching changes the survival consequences of tusks. Relaxed selection is a different process: variants damaging a less useful function are removed less efficiently.
The chapter trains temporal reasoning so that pressure, phenotype, survival, reproduction and genetic change remain in the correct order. It also asks what evidence is still missing before a claim can be strengthened.
What this chapter covers
- 01
Reversing selection
- 02
Human selective agents
- 03
Gene-culture coevolution
- 04
Relaxed selection
- 05
Pseudogenisation
- 06
Before-and-after studies
Worked example · free
Analyse a hurricane study
- 1The survivor comparison establishes differential survival.
- 1The wind test links morphology to performance under the pressure.
- 1The descendant shift supports heritability and population change.
- 1Together the sequence supports evolution by natural selection.
Key terms
- Gene-culture coevolution
- Reciprocal evolutionary interaction between cultural practice and genetic selection.
- Relaxed selection
- Reduced removal of variants after a function matters less to fitness.
- Pseudogene
- A sequence that has lost its former protein-coding function.
- Differential survival
- Unequal survival associated with phenotypic differences.
Selection in Changing Environments FAQ
Can selection reverse direction?
Yes. A phenotype favoured under one environment may become costly when the environment changes. The moth example shows camouflage advantage reversing with background colour, demonstrating that fitness belongs to a genotype-environment context rather than a permanent ranking.
How can culture affect genes?
A behaviour can alter diet, exposure or social conditions and thereby create a new selection pressure. Dairying preceded the spread of lactase-persistence variants, so cultural practice changed the fitness consequences of regulatory variation.
Why do unused genes decay?
When a function contributes little to survival or reproduction, mutations disabling that function are removed less efficiently. Their accumulation reflects relaxed selection, not a positive drive toward damage simply because the function is unused.
What proves a pressure reversed?
Compare fitness consequences under earlier and later environments. A phenotype should move from relatively favoured to relatively disfavoured, with population data following that reversal across generations. Environmental change alone does not establish the genetic response.
How can humans impose natural selection?
Harvesting, medicine, habitat change or culture can alter reproductive consequences without conscious breeding. When heritable variants then differ in success, the mechanism remains natural selection even though human behaviour helped construct the environment.
Exam move
Use a three-time-point diagram: population before pressure, survivors after pressure and descendants after reproduction. Place each observation at the correct point and write the conclusion it supports. Compare examples in which direction reverses, humans impose pressure or selection relaxes. For gene-culture cases, ask which came first and how the first change altered the selective environment.
Avoid phrases implying that organisms intentionally respond. Build short contrast cards for selection, evolution and relaxed selection, each with a required observation. During mixed practice, refuse to call a survivor shift evolution unless the stem supplies heritability or generational change. Extend the diagram into rows for phenotype, survival, reproduction and allele frequency.
Fill columns before pressure, immediately afterward and in descendants. This prevents a performance test from being mistaken for a genetic result. Describe why camouflage fitness changes with background instead of assigning permanent advantage to a colour. In harvesting and poaching cases, identify human behaviour as pressure and the escaping phenotype as the fitness difference.
For lactase persistence, order milk use before variant increase and show how culture constructs an environment. For receptor pseudogenes, describe weakened purifying selection rather than positive selection for broken genes. Invent a case where a neutral trait becomes important after a pathogen arrives, then reverse it so a valuable function becomes redundant.
Use favours only when relative reproduction changes, and avoid wording that makes pressure cause a needed mutation. End each example with the strongest missing test, such as parent-offspring resemblance, genotyping or later-generation sampling. Compare evidence from immediate survivors with evidence from inherited descendants until the distinction is automatic.
Working through Selection in Changing Environments in BIOL10521? Sia is AskSia’s AI Biology tutor — ask any BIOL10521 Selection in Changing Environments question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how BIOL10521 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.