The University of Manchester · FACULTY OF ACCOUNTING

BMAN30030 Chap.2 Constructing the Users of Financial Accounts

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters3-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 2 of 13 · BMAN30030

Constructing the Users of Financial Accounts

Constructing the Users of Financial Accounts questions one of the most familiar sentences in accounting: that financial statements exist to give useful information to investors and creditors. Week 2 traces how that claim was built.

A historical reading shows that the user-oriented objective emerged in the United States in the 1970s, met majority opposition when first consulted on, and was adopted with an openly admitted lack of evidence about what readers of accounts actually need. Standard setters have since tended to speak on behalf of an idealised rational decision-maker rather than study real people. The chapter then compares three responses.

One argues that decision usefulness legitimates standards more than it explains them and proposes accountability instead. Another shows how a framework revision treated decision usefulness as given, leaving stewardship without a separate place. A practitioner reply defends the continuing relevance of audited reports to investors.

These readings prepare you for the seminar debate on how different groups, from lenders and regulators to human rights campaigners, would judge the quality of corporate accounting, and for exam questions that ask whose interests reporting standards serve.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    The 1970s shift to a user-oriented objective

  • 02

    Users as a constructed category rather than real readers

  • 03

    Decision usefulness as a legitimating rationale

  • 04

    Stewardship and the revised conceptual framework

  • 05

    Investor and stakeholder information needs compared

  • 06

    Criteria for judging the quality of corporate accounting

Worked example · free

Evaluate a standard setter's claim that a disclosure meets user needs

Q [8 marks]. This mark allocation is written for revision and is not a published University scheme. An original scenario: a standard setter announces a new disclosure, stating only that 'users have told us this information is useful'. Using the Week 2 readings, set out how you would critically evaluate that justification in an exam answer.
Each band is the user category that standard setters wrote into their objective at a given date, and the narrowing shape shows the category shrinking from a lonEach band is the user category that standard setters wrote into their objective at a given date, and the narrowing shape shows the category shrinking from a long list of possible readers to one idealised rational decision-maker. Long list of users Investors and creditors Rational decision-maker SFAC 1 list SFAC 1 focus Later standards
Each band is the user category that standard setters wrote into their objective at a given date, and the narrowing shape shows the category shrinking from a long list of possible readers to one idealised rational decision-maker.
  • 2Identify the user being invoked and ask whether real readers were consulted or whether the board is speaking for an assumed investor.
  • 2Place the claim in history: the investor and creditor objective was introduced in the 1970s amid opposition and with admitted uncertainty about user needs.
  • 2Apply the critique that decision usefulness works as a legitimating myth, and contrast it with an accountability-based purpose for reporting.
  • 2Reach a judgement on whose interests the disclosure serves and which groups, such as employees or affected communities, the justification ignores.
The justification is weak unless the board shows evidence from actual users; otherwise it repeats the constructed user category that has long been used to justify or reject disclosures. The mark allocation shown is an original practice allocation, not a university marking scheme.
Sia tip — Whenever a reading or standard says 'users need', write in the margin which users, what evidence and who decided, then answer those three in your paragraph.
Glossary

Key terms

Decision Usefulness
The view that financial reporting should be judged by how well it helps users make economic decisions about providing resources.
Stewardship
The use of accounting information to assess how well management has looked after the resources entrusted to it.
Constructed User
An idealised category of financial statement reader that standard setters define and speak for, rather than a group of observed people.
FAQ

Constructing the Users of Financial Accounts FAQ

Who are the users of financial statements according to standard setters?

Current frameworks name present and prospective investors, lenders and other creditors who make decisions about providing resources. Historical work shows this focus is fairly recent: a 1978 concepts statement first listed many possible readers, including employees, customers and the public, then narrowed its attention almost immediately to investors and creditors.

Why do some academics criticise decision usefulness?

Critics argue that it rests on an idealised rational investor whose needs were seldom studied, so it justifies standards rather than explaining them. One reading calls it a legitimating myth and proposes accountability as the central metaphor, which would widen attention to employees, regulators and communities affected by corporate activity.

Is financial reporting still relevant to investors?

Views differ. One academic argues that reported earnings have lost much of their usefulness because intangibles go unrecognised. A practitioner response from a buy-side investor holds that the report and accounts remain the first document examined and questions the evidence offered for declining relevance, so a good answer weighs both sides.

Study strategy

Exam move

Treat this chapter as a history that explains a present-day assumption. Read the paper on making up users first, and build a short timeline of the documents it discusses: the professional definitions of the 1960s, the 1973 Study Group report, the 1974 consultation, the 1978 concepts statement and the later standards that cite users. Beside each entry, note who was named as the user and what evidence of their needs was offered.

Then read the critique of decision usefulness and the study of the framework revision, and for each write one sentence stating what it adds to the historical account: one supplies a normative alternative based on accountability, the other explains why stewardship lost its separate status. Read the practitioner reply last so that you can use it as a counterpoint rather than as background.

Prepare the Week 2 debate by writing a table of the six groups on the debate sheet, from international investors to environmental and human rights campaigners, with one information need and one possible conflict for each. That table becomes a ready source of examples, and the published marking criteria reward integrating such practical applications with theory.

Practise writing one paragraph that challenges a current standard's appeal to user needs, keeping it to about 150 words so that it fits inside a 1,000-word answer. Finally, flag links forward to sustainability materiality and to the intangibles debate, because both reopen the question of whose information needs reporting should meet and reward answers that connect topics across the year.

Working through Constructing the Users of Financial Accounts in BMAN30030? Sia is AskSia’s AI Accounting tutor — ask any BMAN30030 Constructing the Users of Financial Accounts question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how BMAN30030 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 41 of your subjects at The University of Manchester, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your BMAN30030 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 3-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works