The University of Manchester · FACULTY OF ACCOUNTING

BMAN30030 Chap.3 The New International Financial Architecture

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters4-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 3 of 13 · BMAN30030

The New International Financial Architecture

The New International Financial Architecture explains how accounting and auditing standards became instruments of global financial stability. After the Asian financial crisis of the late 1990s, the G7 rejected the idea of a supranational market supervisor and built a system of standards and codes instead, coordinated by the Financial Stability Forum, later the Financial Stability Board.

International accounting and auditing standards, written by private bodies, were placed on the official list of key standards, while the IMF and World Bank assessed how far countries observed them. The chapter maps these actors and their links, including the regulators of the Monitoring Group, the Public Interest Oversight Board that oversees the International Federation of Accountants, and the large audit networks.

It then evaluates the system. Research for the module finds that it underperformed in its own terms, that oversight of the profession became embedded inside the profession's own structures, and that the legitimacy of the international accounting standard setter is disputed between critics who see politics returning and defenders who argue it never left.

These ideas support essays on convergence, on restoring trust in audit and on the public accountability of the accounting profession.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    The Asian crisis and the G7 choice of standards and codes

  • 02

    Financial Stability Forum, Board and the key standards

  • 03

    Public authority behind private accounting and auditing standards

  • 04

    Surveillance through IMF and World Bank reviews

  • 05

    IFAC, the Monitoring Group and embedded oversight

  • 06

    Legitimacy of the IASB and the return of politics

Worked example · free

Assess how accountable the architecture has made global standard setting

Q [9 marks]. Marks used in this example are an AskSia practice guide and not the University's own allocation. An original prompt: 'By placing international accounting and auditing standards inside a public system of surveillance, the architecture made standard setting accountable to the public interest.' Explain how you would critically assess this claim.
Arrows run from the bodies that create or appoint to the bodies they create, endorse, assess or oversee.Arrows run from the bodies that create or appoint to the bodies they create, endorse, assess or oversee. Notice that the two standard setters in the middle row are private organisations, while the bodies around them are public or governmental.G7 and G20FSF then FSBIASBIFAC and IAASBIMF and World BankIOSCO and BaselLarge audit firmsPIOBMonitoring GroupNational regulators
Arrows run from the bodies that create or appoint to the bodies they create, endorse, assess or oversee. Notice that the two standard setters in the middle row are private organisations, while the bodies around them are public or governmental.
  • 2Describe the mechanism: the G7 created the stability forum, private standards joined the list of key standards, and international financial institutions assessed national observance.
  • 2Give the strongest support for the claim: official endorsement and regulator-nominated oversight introduced public interest checks that did not exist before.
  • 3Challenge it with evidence that oversight of the auditing federation is embedded inside its own structure and that large firms gained influence through expert governance.
  • 2Conclude with a balanced judgement, adding the dispute over whether due process is open to all or mainly to resourced participants.
A strong answer accepts that accountability mechanisms multiplied but argues they remained inside expert and professional networks, so the public interest is represented indirectly rather than directly. The mark allocation shown is an original practice allocation, not a university marking scheme.
Sia tip — For each body you mention, write one word after its name, public, private or hybrid, and let that word drive your point about accountability.
Glossary

Key terms

Financial Stability Board
The international body, formed from the earlier Financial Stability Forum, that coordinates standards and policies for global financial stability.
Embedded Oversight
Oversight exercised by a board whose members are chosen by regulators but which sits inside the organisation it oversees.
Key Standards
The set of international standards and codes, including accounting and auditing standards, identified as essential for financial stability.
Procedural Legitimacy
Authority a standard setter claims from following a transparent due process rather than from a political mandate.
Monitoring Group
A group of international regulators, including securities and banking supervisors, that oversees the public interest framework of the auditing federation.
FAQ

The New International Financial Architecture FAQ

What is the new international financial architecture?

It is the network of governmental, intergovernmental and private bodies built after the late 1990s Asian crisis to promote financial stability through common standards. A stability forum created by the G7 named key standards, including international accounting and auditing standards, and the IMF and World Bank reviewed how far individual countries observed them.

Why does the architecture matter for the accounting profession?

It gave privately written standards public backing and drew professional bodies and large audit firms into global regulatory networks. That raised questions of accountability: who oversees the standard setters, whose interests the oversight serves, and whether the profession gained influence while appearing to accept outside supervision.

Is the IASB politically legitimate?

The module presents both sides. One reading argues that the board relies on procedural and substantive legitimacy, that its due process favours resourced participants, and that the 2008 European intervention showed politics returning. A reply holds that the G20 and the European Commission support the board and that standard setting was always political.

Study strategy

Exam move

Learn this chapter as a map before you learn it as an argument. Draw the main bodies on one page, the G7 and G20, the stability forum and board, the accounting standard setter, the auditing federation and its boards, the IMF and World Bank, the regulators in the Monitoring Group, the oversight board and the large audit networks, and connect them with arrows labelled create, endorse, assess or oversee.

Then mark each body public, private or hybrid. With that map in place, read the paper on the global audit profession and the architecture and note three things: why a supranational regulator was rejected, how the standards, surveillance and compliance cycle was meant to work, and why the authors judge it to have underperformed.

Read the paper on governance at the auditing federation next and summarise in your own words what embedded oversight means and why it matters for the public interest. Finish with the exchange on the legitimacy of the IASB, writing one paragraph for each side and a third that states your own view.

Past papers have used this material in at least two ways, inside an essay on convergence and inside a question on why trust in audit keeps needing to be restored, so practise both framings with the same evidence. Keep each paragraph to one institution, one mechanism and one source so that a full answer fits within the 1,000-word limit stated on recent papers.

Finally, connect forward to the week on crisis-driven oversight, because independent regulation of professional bodies is the national counterpart of the global arrangements studied here.

Working through The New International Financial Architecture in BMAN30030? Sia is AskSia’s AI Accounting tutor — ask any BMAN30030 The New International Financial Architecture question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how BMAN30030 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 41 of your subjects at The University of Manchester, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your BMAN30030 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 4-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works