The University of Manchester · FACULTY OF ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE

EART60071 Chap.8 Single-Column Models, Warm Rain and Ice

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters3-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 8 of 10 · EART60071

Single-Column Models, Warm Rain and Ice

Single-Column Models, Warm Rain and Ice explains the Week 4 model of moist air lifted over a hill. The model stacks parcels at fixed levels and alternates two steps: the process equations are solved at every level, then vapour, aerosol, cloud, rain and ice are moved between levels by the advection equation, the time-splitting method used in weather and climate models.

Potential temperature is advected because it is conserved when air changes pressure. Each species moves at the vertical wind minus its fall speed. The chapter then covers why condensation alone is too slow for rain, how collision and coalescence make rain in about twenty minutes, why more aerosol can suppress it, and how rare ice-nucleating particles such as desert dust open the cold rain pathway.

Its checkpoint questions focus on interpreting experiments, so the chapter explains each mechanism in terms you can attach to a plot.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Time splitting between process and transport steps

  • 02

    Conserved variables and potential temperature

  • 03

    Transport at wind speed minus fall speed

  • 04

    Collision and coalescence in warm rain

  • 05

    Ice-nucleating particles and desert dust

  • 06

    Orographic cloud and deeper clouds

Worked example · free

Net transport speeds in an updraft

Q [5 marks]. In a 1.5 m s−1 updraft, snow falls through the air at about 1 m s−1 and rain at about 6 m s−1. With levels 50 m apart and an 8 s step, find each species' net vertical speed, the Courant number for rain, and how long rain takes to fall 1500 m. The marks shown are AskSia practice weighting, not a University of Manchester scheme.
A single-column model solves its process equations at every fixed level, then moves each species between levels at the vertical wind minus its fall speed.A single-column model solves its process equations at every fixed level, then moves each species between levels at the vertical wind minus its fall speed. In a 1.5 m/s updraft, vapour and cloud rise at 1.5 m/s, snow falling at 1 m/s still rises at 0.5 m/s, and rain falling at 6 m/s descends at 4.5 m/s.ODEs at each levellevels 50 m apartvapour and cloud+1.5 m/ssnow+0.5 m/srain-4.5 m/sw minus fall speed
A single-column model solves its process equations at every fixed level, then moves each species between levels at the vertical wind minus its fall speed. In a 1.5 m/s updraft, vapour and cloud rise at 1.5 m/s, snow falling at 1 m/s still rises at 0.5 m/s, and rain falling at 6 m/s descends at 4.5 m/s.
  • 1Vapour and cloud move with the air: +1.5 m s−1. Snow: 1.5 − 1 = +0.5 m s−1, so it is still carried upward.
  • 1Rain: 1.5 − 6 = −4.5 m s−1, descending.
  • 2Rain Courant number: 4.5 × 8/50 = 0.72, within the stability limit.
  • 1Time to fall 1500 m: 1500/4.5 = 333 s, about five and a half minutes.
Vapour and cloud rise at 1.5, snow rises at 0.5 and rain falls at 4.5 m s−1; the rain transport has C = 0.72 and the rain needs about 333 s to fall 1500 m. AskSia practice weighting.
Sia tip — Write w minus the fall speed with its sign for each species before deciding which way anything moves.
Glossary

Key terms

Time splitting
Solving the process equations and the transport equation in separate alternating steps within each time-step.
Potential temperature
A combination of temperature and pressure that stays constant when air moves without condensation.
Collision and coalescence
Growth of a falling drop by colliding with and merging with smaller drops in its path.
Ice-nucleating particle
A rare aerosol particle, such as desert dust, on which ice can form in a supercooled cloud.
FAQ

Single-Column Models, Warm Rain and Ice FAQ

Why can't condensation alone make rain?

Maxwell's growth equation predicts that growing an aerosol particle to raindrop size by condensation would take tens of days, yet rain forms in about twenty minutes. Collision and coalescence fill the gap: slightly larger drops fall slightly faster, collect smaller drops in their path and grow rapidly, more efficiently the larger they become.

Why does more aerosol suppress warm rain?

A cloud with more droplets shares its condensed water among them, so each droplet is smaller. Smaller drops fall more slowly and sweep up less, so collision and coalescence start later. Polluted clouds can therefore rain less and persist longer, which the module links to more overall cloudiness and to implications for weather and climate.

Why does the model advect potential temperature instead of temperature?

Temperature changes whenever air moves to a different pressure, so it is not conserved during transport. Potential temperature is, changing only through latent heating handled in the process step. The model advects potential temperature between levels and then rearranges its definition to recover the new temperature at each level.

Why do mountains increase rainfall in the column model?

Moist air forced up and over a hill is lifted and cooled, so cloud forms and deepens on the windward side. Deeper cloud gives drops more time and depth to grow by collision and coalescence or through the ice phase, so more precipitation reaches the surface there, and the air that descends beyond the hill carries less water.

Study strategy

Exam move

Revise the column model as two alternating steps and keep the processes in their places. Draw a stack of levels, mark the process step at each level and the transport step between levels, and label each species with its net speed, the updraft minus its fall speed. Practise the sign logic with several updraft speeds, and check the Courant number for the fastest-moving species, because the column is an Eulerian grid.

For microphysics, write the warm rain and cold rain pathways side by side: what each needs, how fast it acts and how aerosol changes it. Use the drop-radius calculation at fixed liquid water to show why fewer droplets grow larger. Finally, review your column experiments and the Week 4 checkpoint questions, explaining each in terms of droplet size, ice pathways or the deliberate separation of one change from another.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 41 of your subjects at The University of Manchester, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your EART60071 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 3-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works