The University of Manchester · FACULTY OF ECONOMICS

ECON60101 Chap.3 Expenditure Minimisation and Duality

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters4-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 3 of 8 · ECON60101

Expenditure Minimisation and Duality

Expenditure Minimisation and Duality fixes a utility target and searches for the cheapest bundle at current prices. This dual problem produces Hicksian demand and the expenditure function. Hicksian demand isolates compensated substitution because utility is held constant, while Marshallian demand fixes money income. Shephard's lemma recovers compensated quantities by differentiating expenditure with respect to prices.

Duality links the two problems: minimum expenditure can reproduce a Marshallian bundle at the corresponding utility, and maximum utility can reproduce a Hicksian bundle at the corresponding income.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Expenditure minimisation

  • 02

    Hicksian demand

  • 03

    Expenditure function

  • 04

    Shephard's lemma

  • 05

    Envelope theorem

  • 06

    Consumer duality

Worked example · free

Find the least-cost compensated bundle

Q [6 marks]. For u=sqrt(x1x2), prices (4,1) and utility target 6, find Hicksian demand and expenditure. Marks shown in this exercise are an independent study aid, not a University marking scheme.
The upper arrow inserts maximised utility into the expenditure problem, while the lower arrow restores income from minimum expenditure to recover the same bundlThe upper arrow inserts maximised utility into the expenditure problem, while the lower arrow restores income from minimum expenditure to recover the same bundle.utility maximisationfix income yobtain x*(p,y), V(p,y)expenditure minimisationfix utility uobtain xʰ(p,u), E(p,u)u = V(p,y)y = E(p,u)
The upper arrow inserts maximised utility into the expenditure problem, while the lower arrow restores income from minimum expenditure to recover the same bundle.
  • 2Tangency gives x2/x1=4 and the utility target gives x1x2=36.
  • 2Solve to obtain x1=3 and x2=12.
  • 2Minimum expenditure is 4(3)+12=24 and the target check gives sqrt(36)=6.
The compensated bundle is (3,12) and minimum expenditure is 24. Substitution confirms that it reaches the target utility, while the tangency fixes the least-cost input ratio at the stated prices. The practice weights are not an official University allocation.
Sia tip — Label the utility target explicitly so it is not mistaken for money income during substitution.
Glossary

Key terms

Hicksian demand
Hicksian demand minimises spending while attaining a fixed utility target.
Expenditure function
The expenditure function reports the least cost of attaining a utility target.
Shephard's lemma
Shephard's lemma recovers compensated input quantities from price derivatives of expenditure.
FAQ

Expenditure Minimisation and Duality FAQ

How does compensated demand differ?

Compensated demand adjusts purchasing power so the consumer remains on a fixed utility level after prices change. Marshallian demand instead keeps money income fixed, allowing purchasing power and attained utility to change.

What does Shephard's lemma mean?

The price derivative of minimum expenditure equals the compensated quantity of that good under regularity. A small price increase therefore raises the cost of maintaining utility approximately by quantity times the price change.

Why is duality useful?

Duality lets one optimisation problem recover the objects of the other. It also supplies value-function properties and derivatives that make comparative statics, welfare measures and the Slutsky decomposition easier to organise and verify.

Study strategy

Exam move

Pair every utility-maximisation problem with its expenditure-minimisation counterpart. Write the fixed object at the top of the page: money income for Marshallian demand and utility for Hicksian demand. In the expenditure problem, minimise the price dot product subject to the target utility, interpret the multiplier as marginal expenditure and verify both tangency and target attainment.

Derive the expenditure function and test its economic properties: nondecreasing in prices, homogeneous of degree one in prices and concave in prices. Differentiate it to recover Hicksian demand and explain the envelope-theorem interpretation rather than treating the derivative as a trick. Check degree-zero homogeneity of compensated quantities when all prices scale.

Practise both duality substitutions, x-star at income E and x-h at utility V, until the arguments remain in the correct order. Use one numerical problem to compute the same bundle from both programmes. Record errors caused by confusing income and utility, reversing a Lagrangian sign or differentiating before substituting the optimum.

Finish each answer by stating what was held fixed and whether the reported object is a bundle, a minimum cost or a marginal compensation measure. Make an argument ledger with separate rows for the value function and the policy function. For expenditure, the value is money and the policy is a compensated bundle; for indirect utility, the value is utility and the policy is an uncompensated bundle.

Fill in each function's arguments, units, homogeneity degree and monotonicity direction. This prevents a derivative of one object from being interpreted as another. Use a paired numerical exercise to establish the inversion identities rather than merely copying them: first maximise utility at an assigned income, record the attained utility, then minimise expenditure at that utility and verify that the original income returns.

Reverse the sequence with an assigned target and compare bundles. Next, vary one price while keeping the utility target unchanged. Predict the sign of the expenditure change and calculate Hicksian quantities on both sides; the change is a movement along a constant-welfare requirement, not an ordinary demand response with purchasing power allowed to move.

For Shephard's lemma, differentiate only after obtaining a legitimate expenditure function and explain why the derivative measures the cost of a marginal price increase through the chosen quantity. Check concavity with a verbal argument about choosing a cost-minimising bundle at averaged prices, then connect that shape to the compensated substitution matrix.

When a target lies on a kink or boundary, replace a smooth tangency with direct cost comparison. A timed duality solution should display the fixed utility level, feasibility at the target, the minimum expenditure, and one envelope or homogeneity check. If the answer contains both income and utility, circle which is data and which is generated.

That single annotation prevents the common error of feeding the value function its own output in the wrong argument position.

Working through Expenditure Minimisation and Duality in ECON60101? Sia is AskSia’s AI Economics tutor — ask any ECON60101 Expenditure Minimisation and Duality question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how ECON60101 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 41 of your subjects at The University of Manchester, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your ECON60101 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 4-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works