ECON60101 Chap.4 Slutsky Decomposition and Demand Slopes
Slutsky Decomposition and Demand Slopes
Slutsky Decomposition and Demand Slopes separates a Marshallian price response into a compensated substitution effect and an income effect. The own-price substitution effect is non-positive under the module's regularity conditions. A normal good has an income effect that reinforces this fall, while an inferior good has an opposing income effect.
Giffen behaviour requires that opposing effect to dominate, so inferiority alone is insufficient. The Slutsky matrix collects compensated derivatives and inherits symmetry and negative semidefiniteness from the expenditure function under differentiability.
What this chapter covers
- 01
Slutsky equation
- 02
Substitution effect
- 03
Income effect
- 04
Normal goods
- 05
Inferior goods
- 06
Slutsky matrix
Worked example · free
Compute a local own-price response
- 1Write the own-price Slutsky equation before inserting values.
- 2The income adjustment is -5(0.08)=-0.40.
- 2Add -1.10 and -0.40 to obtain -1.50, consistent with a normal good.
Key terms
- Substitution effect
- The substitution effect is the compensated response to changed relative prices.
- Income effect
- The income effect is the response caused by changed purchasing power.
- Giffen good
- A Giffen good has an income effect large enough to reverse the own-price substitution effect.
Slutsky Decomposition and Demand Slopes FAQ
Does inferior mean Giffen?
No. An inferior good has demand that falls as income rises, so its own-price income effect opposes substitution. Demand becomes Giffen only when that positive opposing term is larger than the negative compensated effect.
Which demand obeys symmetry?
Symmetry is a restriction on the compensated Slutsky matrix under the differentiability assumptions. Raw Marshallian cross-price derivatives include income effects and need not display the same symmetry pattern.
Why is the substitution effect negative?
Holding utility fixed, a rise in a good's own price makes that good relatively more expensive. Expenditure-function concavity implies the compensated own-price derivative is non-positive under the stated regularity conditions.
Exam move
Write the Slutsky equation with indices before substituting numbers. Identify good i as the demanded quantity and good j as the price that changes, so the income term uses x-j rather than an automatically repeated own quantity. For each own-price problem, make a three-line sign ledger: compensated effect, income adjustment and total Marshallian response. Classify the good only after the income derivative is known.
Practise examples where the good is normal, inferior but ordinary, exactly offsetting and Giffen so the magnitude threshold becomes automatic. On diagrams, label the original bundle, the compensated bundle on the original indifference curve and the final bundle on the new budget.
For matrix questions, distinguish the Hicksian Jacobian from uncompensated derivatives and connect symmetry and negative semidefiniteness to the Hessian of expenditure. Test price homogeneity separately. Keep local derivatives distinct from exact changes over large price intervals. Build an error log for sign reversal, index substitution, confusing compensation schemes and calling every inferior good Giffen.
End each solution with a directional statement explaining whether substitution and income reinforce or oppose one another and what that implies for the demand slope. Construct a sign laboratory with four deliberately different goods. Give each case a compensated own-price derivative, an income derivative and an initial quantity, then compute the uncompensated derivative before attaching the labels normal, inferior or Giffen.
Include one inferior case whose demand still falls with price; it is the best antidote to the false equivalence between inferiority and upward-sloping demand. For cross-price entries, say which demanded good occupies the row and which changing price occupies the column. This index discipline matters because symmetry belongs to compensated cross effects, not generally to Marshallian ones.
Reproduce the decomposition graphically with three budget lines. The original and final lines reflect the actual price-income situations; the compensated line is a constructed comparison that keeps the reference welfare constant. Label the movement from the original bundle to the compensated bundle as substitution and the remaining movement as income.
Then explain how Hicks and Slutsky compensation differ even though both isolate substitution reasoning. For matrix work, test negative semidefiniteness using an arbitrary price-change vector and interpret the resulting quadratic form as compensated demand moving against the price change in aggregate. Derive adding-up and homogeneity restrictions separately so they do not get folded into symmetry by memory.
When using finite data rather than derivatives, avoid claiming that a local formula exactly measures a large discrete movement unless the exercise supplies the appropriate exact index. A final audit should include the sign of every component, the economic class of the good, and the inequality required for a positive total own-price response.
State that rarity condition explicitly: a Giffen outcome needs an inferior income effect strong enough to dominate the nonpositive compensated effect.
Working through Slutsky Decomposition and Demand Slopes in ECON60101? Sia is AskSia’s AI Economics tutor — ask any ECON60101 Slutsky Decomposition and Demand Slopes question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how ECON60101 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.