The University of Manchester · FACULTY OF MARKETING

FBTE61411 Chap.10 Reference Groups, Tribes and Consumption Communities

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters3-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 10 of 11 · FBTE61411

Reference Groups, Tribes and Consumption Communities

Reference Groups, Tribes and Consumption Communities turns from the individual self to the groups people consume with, drawing on the Week 10 symbolic consumption slides. A reference group is any person or group that significantly influences behaviour, and the chapter explains three forms of that influence: informational, utilitarian and value-expressive.

It uses Bearden and Etzel's matrix to show when influence is strongest, crossing public against private consumption with necessities against luxuries, and links social influence to involvement. It then compares the collectives consumer research has named, consumer tribes, brand communities and subcultures of consumption, with newer forms such as brand publics, audiences and word-of-mouth networks.

Group decision making completes the picture, from agreed and imposed priorities to parallel and partitioned activity, alongside subconscious effects such as herding and the risky shift. Because the brief lists market segmentation and consumer tribes as a topic area, the chapter shows how the typology can sharpen a review of fashion segmentation.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Three forms of reference group influence

  • 02

    Public and private, necessity and luxury

  • 03

    Involvement and social influence

  • 04

    Tribes, brand communities and subcultures

  • 05

    Brand publics and word-of-mouth networks

  • 06

    Group decisions and herding

Worked example · free

Place a fashion purchase in the reference group matrix

Q [4 marks]. A student buys a branded puffer jacket mainly worn on campus and a set of plain thermal base layers worn underneath it. Use the public and private, necessity and luxury matrix to explain how strongly reference groups shape each purchase. The step weighting below is an AskSia practice allocation, not a university marking scheme.
The grid crosses reference-group influence on the product category, weak for necessities and strong for luxuries, with influence on brand choice, strong for iteThe grid crosses reference-group influence on the product category, weak for necessities and strong for luxuries, with influence on brand choice, strong for items seen in public and weak for items used in private; the examples are illustrative fashion goods.Public necessityEveryday trainersPublic luxuryDesigner handbagPrivate necessityBasic underwearPrivate luxurySilk pyjamasWeakStrongProduct category influenceBrand choice influence
The grid crosses reference-group influence on the product category, weak for necessities and strong for luxuries, with influence on brand choice, strong for items seen in public and weak for items used in private; the examples are illustrative fashion goods.
  • 1Classify the jacket: worn in public and widely owned in winter, it is closest to a public necessity.
  • 1Predict influence: weak on whether to buy a warm jacket, strong on which brand, because the label is visible.
  • 1Classify the base layers: used in private and needed for warmth, they are a private necessity.
  • 1Predict influence: weak on both the category and the brand, since no one sees them.
Reference groups shape the jacket's brand strongly but not the decision to own a jacket, while the hidden base layers escape group influence almost entirely.
Sia tip — Decide visibility first, then necessity or luxury. Visibility drives brand influence; optionality drives category influence.
Glossary

Key terms

Value-expressive influence
Group influence that works through the wish to gain acceptance and approval from others.
Informational influence
Group influence that reduces uncertainty by drawing on sources seen as credible.
Brand community
A consumption community centred on a single brand, one of the types in Canniford's typology of consumption communities.
Brand public
A collective, in Arvidsson and Caliandro's term, linked mainly by shared media attention to a brand.
Herding
A subconscious group behaviour in which people follow what others do rather than their own judgement.
FAQ

Reference Groups, Tribes and Consumption Communities FAQ

What are the three forms of reference group influence?

Informational influence reduces uncertainty when the source is credible. Utilitarian influence works through rewards and punishments, such as praise or ridicule. Value-expressive influence rests on the wish for acceptance and approval. One fashion purchase can involve all three, so identify which one a study actually measured.

When are reference groups most influential?

Bearden and Etzel suggest influence on the brand is strongest when a product is consumed in public, and influence on the product category is strongest when it is a luxury rather than a necessity. A visible luxury item attracts both kinds of influence.

What is the difference between a consumer tribe and a brand community?

Canniford's typology separates a brand community, centred on a single brand, from a consumer tribe, which Cova describes as a looser collective held together by a shared passion that may span many brands. The distinction changes what loyalty a marketer can expect.

Is consumer tribes a suitable topic for the research review?

Yes. The brief lists market segmentation and consumer tribes as a topic area. A strong paper narrows it, for example to fashion fandoms online, and evaluates whether collectives explain behaviour better than traditional segmentation by stable traits. That makes it a debate the literature review can evaluate.

Do group effects always operate consciously?

No. The lecture links high involvement to conscious social influence and low involvement to subconscious influence, and lists herding, the risky shift, de-individuation and social loafing as group behaviours people may not notice in themselves. A review can ask which of these a study could detect.

Study strategy

Assessment move

Use the symbolic consumption slides as a checklist. First learn the three forms of influence and the matrix, and practise placing ten items from your own wardrobe in the four cells, noting where the brand matters and where it does not. Next build a short comparison of tribes, brand communities, subcultures and brand publics, with one fashion example of each that you have researched yourself.

Then read about group decision making and subconscious group effects, and note which ones existing studies ignore. If segmentation and tribes is your paper topic, find a recent review of consumption collectives and use its typology to organise your literature review by debate rather than by author.

Working through Reference Groups, Tribes and Consumption Communities in FBTE61411? Sia is AskSia’s AI Marketing tutor — ask any FBTE61411 Reference Groups, Tribes and Consumption Communities question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how FBTE61411 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 41 of your subjects at The University of Manchester, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your FBTE61411 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 3-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works