The University of Manchester · FACULTY OF MARKETING

FBTE61411 Chap.11 Writing the Conceptual Research Review

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters5-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 11 of 11 · FBTE61411

Writing the Conceptual Research Review

Writing the Conceptual Research Review turns the brief, the rubric and the optional assignment workbook into a working method for the paper that carries the whole module mark. The brief sets four steps: choose one topic, review the relevant theories and research critically, discuss implications for theory, practice and wider society, and conclude with the key issues and directions for future research.

The chapter starts with narrowing, using the workbook's funnel from a broad area such as the self-concept down to one feature of the digitally extended self, and its test for whether a topic is theoretical rather than empirical. It then shows how to read and organise a literature by debate, how to build implications from insight to consequence to response, and how the recommended structure divides the 4,000 words.

Model writing illustrates the synthesis the 40% literature review criterion rewards. Practice covers the annotated bibliography, the word-limit procedure and the AI usage declaration, the compulsory parts that are easiest to leave too late.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    The four steps of the brief

  • 02

    Narrowing to a theoretical topic

  • 03

    Organising the review by debate

  • 04

    Implications from insight to response

  • 05

    Recommended structure and word budget

  • 06

    Annotated bibliography and AI declaration

Worked example · free

Narrow a broad area into a reviewable topic

Q [5 marks]. A student wants to write about social media and fashion identity. Using the workbook's funnel and its test of theoretical versus empirical topics, narrow the idea into a topic suitable for a 4,000-word conceptual review. The step weighting below is an AskSia practice allocation, not a university marking scheme.
Each row turns one insight from the workbook’s notes on the ethical consumption cap into a consequence and then a response, with theory, practice and society frEach row turns one insight from the workbook’s notes on the ethical consumption cap into a consequence and then a response, with theory, practice and society from top to bottom, so every implication traces back to a finding.InsightConsequenceResponseCap challenges gap logicAvoid the gap metaphorNetwork-based researchCoalitions raise moralityRemove low-moralityproductsMeasure moral metricsMorals are collectiveDiscuss morals publiclyMedia and education
Each row turns one insight from the workbook’s notes on the ethical consumption cap into a consequence and then a response, with theory, practice and society from top to bottom, so every implication traces back to a finding.
  • 1Place the idea in one of the six areas in the brief: self-concept and symbolic consumption fits best.
  • 2Test the focus: social media is a setting, so look for a concept found in many settings, such as the extended self.
  • 1Narrow again to one aspect with a manageable literature, for example how digital possessions extend the self.
  • 1Check the result against the formative proposal: a definable construct, five key papers and one governing theory.
The digitally extended self in fashion consumption, reviewed through Belk's extended-self theory, is narrow enough to review thoroughly and theoretical enough to draw on studies beyond any single platform.
Sia tip — Ask whether you can list diverse examples of your topic. If every example comes from one app or channel, you have an empirical setting, not a concept to review.
Glossary

Key terms

Conceptual paper
A paper that advances an argument by reviewing and connecting existing theory rather than collecting new data.
Research gap
A question the existing literature has not yet answered, shown after the reader has seen what it does cover.
Harvard referencing
An author and date citation style with a full alphabetical reference list at the end.
Word-limit grace band
The margin of 10% above the stated limit within which no penalty is applied.
FAQ

Writing the Conceptual Research Review FAQ

How narrow should my topic be?

Narrow enough that you can name the key papers, the central debate and the gap. The workbook's example moves from the self-concept, with over 100,000 papers, to distributed memory in the digitally extended self, with under 500. Stop where five key references and one governing theory are clearly identifiable.

Can my paper focus on one brand or platform?

Use brands as illustrations, not as the topic. The workbook warns that settings such as livestreaming are empirical, while concepts such as nostalgia appear across vintage clothing, films and hotels. Review the concept, then show how it explains behaviour around a brand in the implications.

What makes a literature review critical rather than descriptive?

Organising by question rather than by author. State the debate, weigh competing studies, point out shared assumptions and finish with a defended claim. The rubric's sufficient band describes reviews that remain mainly descriptive; the higher bands ask for gaps and debates identified with insight.

How do I write strong implications?

Link each implication to a specific insight from your review, then give its consequence and a concrete response. Cover theory, practice and wider society, since the brief names all three and the top band asks for them to be integrated rather than listed.

Does the annotated bibliography count towards the word limit?

No. The annotated bibliography and the AI usage declaration sit outside the 4,000 words. The bibliography is not graded on its own but supports the 10% research skills mark, so each entry should explain selection, contribution and how you checked reliability.

Study strategy

Assessment move

Use the formative proposal as the first draft of your introduction. By the Week 7 deadline you should have a defined construct, five key papers and one governing theory; the Week 8 feedback then tells you whether the topic is narrow enough. Between the workshops, build a reading log with claims, assumptions and disagreements for each paper, and sort it into two or three debates.

Draft the literature review first, then the implications using insight, consequence and response, and leave the introduction and conclusion until the argument is settled. In the final week check the count, the Harvard references, the bibliography notes and the AI declaration before submitting.

Working through Writing the Conceptual Research Review in FBTE61411? Sia is AskSia’s AI Marketing tutor — ask any FBTE61411 Writing the Conceptual Research Review question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how FBTE61411 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 41 of your subjects at The University of Manchester, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your FBTE61411 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 5-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works