The University of Manchester · FACULTY OF LAW

LAWS10160 Chap.9 Reflection, Feedback and the Portfolio

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters4-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 9 of 9 · LAWS10160

Reflection, Feedback and the Portfolio

Reflection, Feedback and the Portfolio turns experience into evidence-led analysis of development. The portfolio asks for a reflective essay supported by appendices such as a journal and formative feedback. Description records an event; reflection explains what the evidence reveals, why a choice produced the result, what alternative was available and how future practice will change.

A useful action is observable, such as recording judgment pinpoints while reading, not a vague promise to work harder. Later work can then test whether the change improved performance. Reflection can analyse strengths as well as weaknesses, but every claim needs evidence and a clear mechanism.

The final portfolio should select representative moments across the year, preserve anonymity, interpret appendices in the essay and acknowledge development that remains incomplete.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Experience and evidence

  • 02

    Feedback analysis

  • 03

    Reflective journals

  • 04

    Observable action

  • 05

    Later review

  • 06

    Portfolio selection and synthesis

Worked example · free

Turn feedback into a tested change

Q [6 marks]. Feedback says a legal research answer gives the result but omits the judgment's reasoning. How can this become a reflective paragraph? The marks shown in this model are not a published university allocation.
The cycle moves from a specific experience through evidence and analysis into a concrete action, then uses later review to test change and begin the next reflecThe cycle moves from a specific experience through evidence and analysis into a concrete action, then uses later review to test change and begin the next reflection.experienceevidenceanalysisactionlater review
The cycle moves from a specific experience through evidence and analysis into a concrete action, then uses later review to test change and begin the next reflection.
  • 3Use the feedback and research notes to show that reliance on a headnote left no judgment pinpoints or reasoning in the answer.
  • 3Describe a case-note routine, compare a later answer using judgment passages and identify the next remaining goal.
The reflection links evidence to a causal explanation, an observable change and later review. It avoids claiming complete mastery from one improved task. The weighting is original.
Sia tip — Name the decision you will change and the later evidence that will show whether the change worked.
Glossary

Key terms

Reflective journal
A continuing record of learning experiences, evidence, analysis and planned action.
Formative feedback
Information on performance used to guide development before later summative work.
Action point
A specific and observable change to be tested in future practice.
FAQ

Reflection, Feedback and the Portfolio FAQ

How is reflection different from description?

Description states what happened. Reflection uses evidence to explain why it happened, what it reveals about a skill, which alternative was available and what change will be made. A later example should test that action. The result is an analysis of development rather than a diary-like chronology.

What evidence can support the portfolio?

The published overview identifies a reflective journal, current CV, formative feedback and other evidence of academic, legal and professional development. Select material that supports the specific claim made in the essay. Introduce and interpret each appendix rather than assuming that attachment alone proves progress.

Can reflection discuss strengths?

Yes. A strength can be analysed through evidence showing which decision or habit produced a successful outcome and how it can be transferred. Avoid unsupported self-labels. A balanced reflection can recognise improvement while identifying the boundary of current competence and a concrete next goal.

How often should I write journal entries?

Make entries close enough to significant workshops, tasks and feedback that the decisions and evidence remain specific. Regularity is more useful than a reconstructed narrative near submission. The current module guidance should control required practice, while each entry should still identify learning, evidence, analysis and a future action.

What makes an action point useful?

A useful action names a behaviour, the next context in which it will occur and the evidence that will show its effect. Replace promises to improve with a routine such as recording judgment pinpoints while reading. Later work can then confirm progress, reveal a limitation or require another adjustment.

How should appendices appear in the essay?

Introduce each appendix for a specific claim and explain the feature that matters. Attachment alone does not prove development. Select relevant material, preserve anonymity and follow the live task brief. The analytical prose should show how the evidence supports the account of changed knowledge, skill or professional practice.

What if progress is uneven?

Uneven progress can produce strong reflection when it is analysed accurately. Identify which element improved, which remains difficult and why. Compare evidence from more than one moment, avoid claiming mastery from a single success and set a focused next action. Credibility comes from explanation, not from presenting constant improvement.

Study strategy

Exam move

Maintain the journal throughout the year rather than rebuilding it near submission. After a workshop, research task or feedback event, record the situation, evidence, interpretation, alternative and one action. Make the action observable and attach it to a future task. When that task arrives, review whether the change worked and save a comparison passage or feedback comment.

Organise evidence by skill, including legal research, writing, teamwork, communication and reflection, while avoiding personal or sensitive details that do not belong in the portfolio. Select a varied set of moments showing both progress and continuing difficulty. In the essay, introduce each appendix and explain what it demonstrates. Replace vague claims such as improved confidence with behavioural evidence.

Keep chronology only where sequence matters to development. Before submission, test every paragraph for experience, evidence, analysis, action and later review. Conclude by synthesising patterns across skills and setting priorities for the next stage of legal study rather than claiming development is complete.

Working through Reflection, Feedback and the Portfolio in LAWS10160? Sia is AskSia’s AI Law tutor — ask any LAWS10160 Reflection, Feedback and the Portfolio question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how LAWS10160 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 41 of your subjects at The University of Manchester, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your LAWS10160 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 4-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works