The University of Manchester · FACULTY OF LAW

LAWS10160 Chap.8 Social Responsibility and Critical Argument

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters4-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 8 of 9 · LAWS10160

Social Responsibility and Critical Argument

Social Responsibility and Critical Argument prepares the portfolio essay by turning a broad concern into a supported legal position. The published task structure identifies a social responsibility essay, while the marking criteria reward issue identification, relevance, logical organisation, examples, wider reading, counterargument and evaluation.

A strong essay therefore defines an answerable question, establishes the legal framework, selects reliable evidence and states a defensible thesis. Each paragraph should make a claim, support it, explain significance, address a competing view and reconnect the result to the thesis. Counterargument is not a token sentence; it should present the strongest alternative fairly.

Evaluation requires an explicit criterion and a reasoned weighing of legal and practical consequences. The conclusion answers the narrowed question and states the conditions or uncertainties affecting the recommendation.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Narrowing the issue

  • 02

    Thesis and legal framework

  • 03

    Authority and evidence

  • 04

    Paragraph structure

  • 05

    Counterargument

  • 06

    Evaluation and conclusion

Worked example · free

Plan an access-to-justice argument

Q [6 marks]. How could an essay evaluate whether a fictional online-only tribunal service advances access to justice? The weighting used for this practice is not an official university assessment scheme.
The branches place authority, counterargument and response beneath one thesis, while the return arrow shows evaluation reconnecting every strand to the essay's The branches place authority, counterargument and response beneath one thesis, while the return arrow shows evaluation reconnecting every strand to the essay's central answer.answerable thesisauthority andevidencecounterargumenttested fairlyreasonedresponseevaluation returns evidence to the thesis
The branches place authority, counterargument and response beneath one thesis, while the return arrow shows evaluation reconnecting every strand to the essay's central answer.
  • 3Define effective access, identify affected users and build a thesis that recognises both reduced barriers and possible digital exclusion.
  • 3Compare evidence, present the strongest resource counterargument and evaluate a digital-first alternative against the stated criterion.
The essay should reach a conditional conclusion grounded in legal duties and evidence, rather than treating technology as inherently inclusive or exclusionary. The weighting is original.
Sia tip — Make the counterargument strong enough that responding to it changes or sharpens the thesis.
Glossary

Key terms

Thesis
The central answer that the essay develops and defends through its reasoning.
Evaluation
A reasoned judgment that weighs evidence against an explicit legal or normative criterion.
Counterargument
A supported competing position addressed fairly within the argument.
FAQ

Social Responsibility and Critical Argument FAQ

How narrow should the essay question be?

Define the legal setting, affected group, institutional decision and evaluative standard. A topic such as justice is too broad by itself. The scope should allow meaningful disagreement while remaining narrow enough for sources to be compared and for the conclusion to answer one sustained question.

What counts as critical evaluation?

Evaluation identifies a criterion, compares competing authority or evidence and explains why one conclusion follows despite limitations. Listing advantages and disadvantages remains descriptive until their relative significance is assessed. A careful answer may qualify the thesis when evidence supports only a conditional or limited claim.

How should counterargument appear?

Present the strongest competing position with its own rationale and support, then identify the premise, evidence or legal interpretation that weakens it. Avoid dismissing the opposition through labels. A fair counterargument can reveal a necessary exception or implementation condition and thereby improve the final thesis.

What does wider reading add?

Wider reading matters when it introduces authority, evidence, method or a competing interpretation that changes the analysis. Source count alone does not demonstrate depth. Assign each reading a proposition and explain its contribution, limitations and relationship with other material instead of collecting quotations that never affect the thesis.

How should examples be used?

Use an example to test, qualify or challenge a general claim. Provide enough context to show why it is relevant, then explain the inference. One striking instance rarely proves a universal proposition, so state its boundary and compare broader evidence where the essay makes a claim about systematic effects.

What belongs in a strong conclusion?

Return directly to the narrowed question, resolve the principal counterargument and state the judgment at the level supported by the evidence. Identify conditions, uncertainties or implementation limits that could change the recommendation. Avoid introducing a new authority or making a broader claim than the body has established.

How can I spot descriptive writing?

A descriptive paragraph reports what sources say but never explains what follows for the thesis. Highlight the claim, support, counterpoint and evaluation separately. If the final sentence merely repeats content, add a reasoned consequence or remove the material. Evaluation should compare evidence through an explicit legal or normative criterion.

Study strategy

Exam move

Begin by turning the selected topic into an answerable question with a defined legal setting, affected group and criterion. Draft a one-sentence thesis that could be challenged. Build a source table separating primary legal authority, scholarship and evidence about effects. Assign each source a specific proposition rather than gathering quotations without a role.

Outline paragraphs as claim, support, explanation, counterpoint, evaluation and thesis link. Write the strongest opposing argument before composing the response. Test whether each example genuinely changes the reasoning and remove material that is merely interesting. Use OSCOLA while drafting and check that legal claims and empirical claims rely on appropriate sources.

Highlight description, analysis and evaluation in different colours; revise sections dominated by description. Keep a limitation ledger so the conclusion states the conditions under which the recommendation holds. Review the marking criteria as questions about issue identification, organisation, examples, wider reading, counterargument and evaluation, not as an invented points schedule.

Working through Social Responsibility and Critical Argument in LAWS10160? Sia is AskSia’s AI Law tutor — ask any LAWS10160 Social Responsibility and Critical Argument question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how LAWS10160 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 41 of your subjects at The University of Manchester, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your LAWS10160 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 4-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works