The University of Manchester · FACULTY OF LAW

LAWS70271 Chap.8 Infringement, Claim Scope, Defences and Remedies

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters4-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 8 of 9 · LAWS70271

Infringement, Claim Scope, Defences and Remedies

Infringement, Claim Scope, Defences and Remedies moves from validity to enforcement. The Seminar 4 tips set out a four-task method: decide what type of activity constitutes infringement under s 60 PA 77, ascertain whether it falls within the scope of the monopoly, consider defences, and choose a remedy.

Scope is decided by the two steps in Actavis UK v Eli Lilly [2017] UKSC 48: first a normal interpretation of the claims, illustrated by IceScape, and then, if the act falls outside it, Lord Neuberger's three questions on infringement by equivalents. The chapter connects these steps to s 125 PA 77, which implements Art 69 EPC and its Protocol, and asks the seminar question of whether the law is now fairer.

It then works through the Chica and Revine problem, separating salon use from the home kit, and closes with advice that ends on defences and an appropriate remedy.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    The four tasks of an infringement answer

  • 02

    Acts that infringe under s 60 PA 77

  • 03

    Normal interpretation and the inventive concept

  • 04

    Infringement by equivalents under Actavis v Eli Lilly

  • 05

    Section 125(3) PA 77, Art 69 EPC and its Protocol

  • 06

    Defences, remedies and the Chica and Revine problem

Worked example · free

Run the four tasks on a variant product

Q [5 marks]. A patent claims a chair whose legs are joined by a steel bar. A competitor sells a chair with an aluminium bar that does the same job. Advise the patentee on infringement.
The four tasks in an infringement answerIdentify the act, decide whether it falls within the claims, consider defences, then choose a remedy.Infringing acts 60 PA 77Within scopeActavis two stepsAny defencehandout p 9Remedyhandout p 10
Each chevron is one task, taken left to right: the act must fit s 60, fall within the claims under the Actavis steps, survive any defence, and only then justify a remedy.
  • 1Classify the act: the competitor makes and sells chairs, so identify the matching category of s 60 PA 77. The mark allocation used here is not an official university marking scheme.
  • 1Apply Actavis step one: on a normal interpretation, ask whether steel in the claim covers an aluminium bar, reading the claim in light of the inventive concept.
  • 2If not, apply step two: work through Lord Neuberger's three questions as set out in the lecture handout, using the fact that the aluminium bar achieves the same result.
  • 1Close the answer by considering any defence and the remedy that fits the patentee's commercial position.
The patentee has a credible case: if the steel requirement is not met literally, the aluminium bar can be argued as an equivalent under the second Actavis step, subject to defences. The weighting in this model is not a published university marking scheme.
Sia tip — Quote the exact claim word in dispute, here steel, before applying either Actavis step, so the reader sees precisely which feature the variant departs from.
Glossary

Key terms

Normal interpretation
The first Actavis question, asking whether a variant falls within the claim as ordinarily read.
Inventive concept
What the invention is really about as defined in the claims, used to guide interpretation.
Protocol on interpretation
The Protocol to Art 69 EPC on how claims determine the extent of protection, implemented by s 125(3) PA 77.
Remedy
The relief a successful patentee seeks after infringement is established and defences are rejected.
FAQ

Infringement, Claim Scope, Defences and Remedies FAQ

How do I structure an infringement answer?

Follow the four tasks in the Seminar 4 tips: identify the type of infringing activity under s 60, decide whether it falls within the scope of the claims, consider defences, and choose a remedy. Run the tasks separately for each activity of the defendant, because different acts can lead to different advice.

What changed in Actavis v Eli Lilly?

The Supreme Court restructured claim scope into two questions. The first asks whether the variant infringes on a normal interpretation of the claim. If it does not, the second asks whether it infringes as an equivalent, using the three questions Lord Neuberger set out, which the lecture handout reproduces.

Is the law on claim scope now fairer?

That is the evaluative question Seminar 4 sets. Argue it against Art 69 EPC and the Protocol, which s 125(3) PA 77 brings into UK law, weighing fair protection for patentees against reasonable certainty for third parties, and reach a clear position rather than describing both sides and stopping.

Do I need the second Actavis step every time?

No. The Seminar 4 tips say that if the act falls within the claim on a normal interpretation, the second step is strictly unnecessary. Use equivalents only when the variant departs from what the claim ordinarily covers.

Study strategy

Exam move

Learn the four tasks as a fixed checklist and use it on every infringement question, writing each task as a heading. Read paras 53 to 66 of Actavis v Eli Lilly yourself and note the two questions and Lord Neuberger's three equivalence questions from the lecture handout in your own words. Pair the first question with IceScape and practise identifying the inventive concept of a claim in one sentence.

Prepare a short paragraph on s 125(3), Art 69 EPC and the Protocol that you can adapt to the fairness essay. For the Chica problem, outline salon use and the home kit separately, noting where the claim wording, simultaneous application, bleaching agent and the form of maleoli, creates the real issues.

Finish by collecting the defences and remedies from the lecture handout into a list you can apply quickly in the open-book examination.

Working through Infringement, Claim Scope, Defences and Remedies in LAWS70271? Sia is AskSia’s AI Law tutor — ask any LAWS70271 Infringement, Claim Scope, Defences and Remedies question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how LAWS70271 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 41 of your subjects at The University of Manchester, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your LAWS70271 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 4-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works