The University of Manchester · FACULTY OF LAW

LAWS70271 Chap.7 Medical Method and Morality Exceptions

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters3-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 7 of 9 · LAWS70271

Medical Method and Morality Exceptions

Medical Method and Morality Exceptions covers subject matter that may be a technical invention and yet be refused protection. The teaching schedule gives three lectures to medical and veterinary methods and a further lecture to morality, and Seminar 3 tests both through a problem and an essay.

The course outline explains the stakes: how morality shapes the patenting of inventions made of human, animal or plant biological material, and how fundamental rights affect patents. The chapter locates the exceptions in the Patents Act, including Schedule A2 on biotechnological inventions implementing Directive 98/44, and in Art 53(a) EPC.

It then explains how exceptions are raised in practice, through EPO opposition open to anyone within nine months, which is how faith groups, ethicists and other non-commercial parties intervene, and works through the L'Orelia problem on a non-therapeutic skin method and a dental impression method.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Medical and veterinary methods in the teaching schedule

  • 02

    Claim wording such as non-therapeutic and its limits

  • 03

    Art 53(a) EPC, morality and ordre public

  • 04

    Schedule A2 and Directive 98/44 on biotechnology

  • 05

    Opposition as the route for third-party intervention

  • 06

    Faith groups and ethicists as opponents

Worked example · free

Plan an attack on a cosmetic method patent

Q [4 marks]. A European patent granted seven months ago claims a non-therapeutic method of reducing skin redness by applying a plant extract and waiting two minutes. A competitor wants it revoked. Plan the attack.
The opposition window after grantOpposition at the EPO is open for nine months from the mention of grant; at six months three months remain.mention of granttodaydeadline0 m3 m6 m9 m3 months left
The bar runs from the mention of grant to the nine-month opposition deadline, and the orange segment shows that a client advising six months after grant still has three months to file a central attack.
  • 1Check timing: the Art 99 opposition window runs for nine months from the mention of grant, so two months remain for a central attack. The mark allocation used here is not an official university marking scheme.
  • 1Choose the ground: Art 100 lets an opponent argue that the claimed matter is unpatentable under Arts 52 to 57, which takes in the exceptions.
  • 1Test the label: argue that reducing skin redness cannot be separated from a therapeutic effect, so calling the method non-therapeutic does not take it outside the medical methods exception.
  • 1Add fallback grounds of novelty and inventive step in case the exception argument fails.
Oppose at the EPO within the remaining two months, arguing the exception and, in the alternative, lack of novelty or inventive step. The weighting shown is an original learning aid, not a university marking scheme.
Sia tip — Quote the claim's own wording and show which step acts on the body, rather than arguing in general terms that the method sounds medical.
Glossary

Key terms

Ordre public
The public policy ground, paired with morality in Art 53(a) EPC, on which an invention can be refused protection.
Non-therapeutic method
A claim label used to present a treatment of the body as cosmetic or hygienic rather than medical.
Biotechnological invention
An invention involving biological material, governed in the UK by Schedule A2 implementing Directive 98/44.
Non-commercial opponent
A party such as a faith group or ethicist that opposes a patent for reasons other than business interest.
Medical methods exception
The exception for medical and veterinary methods taught in Week 7 and tested in Seminar 3.
FAQ

Medical Method and Morality Exceptions FAQ

Why can a valid invention still be refused a patent?

Some subject matter is excepted for policy reasons even if it is technical, new and inventive. The module covers medical and veterinary methods and the morality and ordre public exclusion in Art 53(a) EPC, together with the special rules for biotechnological inventions in Schedule A2 of the Patents Act.

How can people outside industry challenge a patent on moral grounds?

Opposition at the EPO is open to anyone within nine months of the mention of grant, and non-patentability under Arts 52 to 57 is a ground. Seminar 3 reading by Rennie-Smith examines non-commercial parties as opponents, which is the procedural route faith groups and ethicists use.

Does calling a method non-therapeutic avoid the medical exception?

The label is the drafter's argument, not a decision. Seminar 3 asks you to advise on a claim that describes itself as non-therapeutic, so analyse what the claimed steps do to the body and whether the effect is inseparable from therapy, then prepare the patentee's counterargument.

Study strategy

Exam move

This chapter rewards close reading of claim wording, so collect the two Seminar 3 claims and annotate every step: what is applied, to which part of the body, and with what effect. Read the exceptions handout and lecture slides for the governing provisions and copy the exact wording into your notes, because the seminar facts do not supply it.

For morality, prepare a one-page brief on Art 53(a) EPC with the three set readings, Rennie-Smith, Pila, and Liddell and Ravenscroft, each reduced to a thesis and one supporting point. Then rehearse the procedural answer: who may oppose, within what time, on which Art 100 ground, and what a successful opposition achieves.

Finally, write one essay paragraph that takes a position on whether faith groups and ethicists improve patent decisions, with a counterargument and a reply.

Working through Medical Method and Morality Exceptions in LAWS70271? Sia is AskSia’s AI Law tutor — ask any LAWS70271 Medical Method and Morality Exceptions question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how LAWS70271 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 41 of your subjects at The University of Manchester, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your LAWS70271 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 3-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works