The University of Manchester · FACULTY OF LAW

LAWS70271 Chap.6 Inventive Step and Mosaicking Prior Art

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters3-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 6 of 9 · LAWS70271

Inventive Step and Mosaicking Prior Art

Inventive Step and Mosaicking Prior Art picks up where novelty ends. Lord Hoffmann in Synthon, citing General Tire, explains that prior art which would not itself infringe, but which would make an infringing adaptation obvious to the skilled person, defeats a patent for lack of inventive step rather than lack of novelty.

The chapter introduces the EPO problem and solution approach, which requires a technical problem the skilled person might be asked to solve at the priority date and, after COMVIK, counts only technical features.

It then takes the questions set in Seminar 2: what it means to mosaic documents, whether mosaicking is permissible for novelty and for inventive step, which approaches to inventive step the Supreme Court approved in Actavis v ICOS, and how to advise Samaria against Drydon's attack based on the Dirrige patent and its optional third cyclone stage.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    The Synthon boundary between novelty and inventive step

  • 02

    The EPO problem and solution approach

  • 03

    Technical features only after COMVIK

  • 04

    Mosaicking documents for novelty and for obviousness

  • 05

    Optional wording and clear directions in prior art

  • 06

    The Samaria and Drydon cyclone problem

Worked example · free

Route an attack to novelty or inventive step

Q [5 marks]. A patent claims a kettle with a whistle in the lid. Document A shows the same kettle without a whistle. Document B, from another field, shows a whistle on a pressure valve. The challenger argues lack of novelty. Advise the patentee.
Samaria claim compared with the Dirrige disclosureThe first two features match; the third cyclone is required by the claim but only optional in Dirrige.SamariaDirrigeCyclonic dust separatoryesyesFirst and second stagesyesyesThird cyclone stagerequiredif desired
Each row checks one claim feature against the earlier Dirrige patent, and the highlighted third row shows the only gap: Samaria requires a third cyclone stage that Dirrige mentions merely as an option.
  • 2Test novelty against each document separately: neither A nor B alone discloses a kettle with a whistle in the lid, so performing either would not necessarily infringe. The mark allocation used here is not an official university marking scheme.
  • 1Explain why combining A and B does not help the challenger on novelty, because the combination is something no single disclosure taught.
  • 1Redirect the argument: following Synthon at [25], art that makes an adaptation obvious goes to inventive step, so the challenger's real case is that putting B's whistle on A's kettle was obvious.
  • 1Advise the patentee to answer that case on its merits, for example by showing why the skilled person would not look to pressure valves when designing a kettle lid.
The novelty attack should fail because no single document discloses the claimed kettle; the patentee should prepare for an obviousness attack based on combining the two documents. This allocation is an original learning aid, not a university marking scheme.
Sia tip — List each document with its date on a separate line and test it alone for novelty before you allow yourself to combine anything.
Glossary

Key terms

Mosaicking
Reading several prior documents together as if they were a single disclosure.
Technical effect
The technical result a claimed feature produces, which helps frame the problem the invention solves.
Obviousness
Lack of inventive step, where the invention would have been obvious to the skilled person at the priority date.
Optional disclosure
Prior art wording that mentions a feature only as a possibility, such as a step that may be added if desired.
FAQ

Inventive Step and Mosaicking Prior Art FAQ

What is the difference between lack of novelty and obviousness?

Lack of novelty requires prior art that would necessarily infringe if performed. Obviousness covers art that would not itself infringe but would make it obvious to the skilled person how to adapt it into something that does. Synthon at [25] uses exactly that line, citing General Tire v Firestone.

What does it mean to mosaic documents?

To mosaic is to read several prior documents together as one combined disclosure. Seminar 2 asks whether that is permissible for novelty and for inventive step, so build your reasons from each test: novelty looks at what a disclosure teaches, while inventive step asks what the skilled person would find obvious.

How should I approach the Samaria cyclone problem?

Take novelty first, asking whether Dirrige's optional third stage gives clear and unmistakable directions to the claimed apparatus. Then address Drydon's inventive step argument that a third cyclone has no additional technical effect, and test Drydon's own vacuum cleaners separately before considering any combination of prior art.

Study strategy

Exam move

Inventive step is easiest to learn as a contrast with novelty. Write the Synthon passage at [25] in your own words and keep it at the top of your notes, then build a two-column table showing what each test asks and what the skilled person is assumed to know.

Read Bently pages 562 to 570 and the Actavis v ICOS judgment for the approaches the seminar asks about, and summarise each approach in one sentence with its paragraph reference. Practise the problem and solution approach on simple claims, always stating the closest prior art, the technical difference and the problem it solves, and remember that only technical features count.

For Seminar 2, outline the Samaria answer in four headings, novelty over Dirrige, other prior art, inventive step and technical effect, and advice, then rewrite it with fresh facts of your own to check that the method transfers.

Working through Inventive Step and Mosaicking Prior Art in LAWS70271? Sia is AskSia’s AI Law tutor — ask any LAWS70271 Inventive Step and Mosaicking Prior Art question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how LAWS70271 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 41 of your subjects at The University of Manchester, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your LAWS70271 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 3-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works