The University of Manchester · FACULTY OF LAW

LAWS70271 Chap.4 Novelty, the State of the Art and Priority

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters3-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 4 of 9 · LAWS70271

Novelty, the State of the Art and Priority

Novelty, the State of the Art and Priority explains what counts against an invention and from which date. Section 2(1) PA 77 and Art 54 EPC treat an invention as new unless it already belongs to the state of the art, and s 2(2) defines that state as everything made available to the public anywhere before the priority date, by description, use or any other way.

The chapter covers the skilled reader's common general knowledge as described in Idenix v Gilead, the meaning of made available in EPO decisions on emails, web pages and analysable products, and the first-to-file priority system under s 5 and Art 87 EPC, including the time-zone point in Unwired Planet v Huawei.

It also separates three provisions that are easily confused: s 2(2) for published art, s 2(3) for earlier applications published later, and s 2(4) for disclosures made in breach of confidence within six months before filing.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Section 2(1) and (2) PA 77 and Art 54 EPC

  • 02

    Common general knowledge in Idenix v Gilead and Regen Lab

  • 03

    Made available: emails, web pages and analysable products

  • 04

    First to file, s 5(1) and the twelve-month priority right

  • 05

    Unwired Planet v Huawei and the time zone of filing

  • 06

    Earlier applications under s 2(3) and disregarded disclosures under s 2(4)

Worked example · free

Decide whether a same-day publication destroys novelty

Q [4 marks]. An application is filed at the UK office on 3 May at 15:00. A rival published the same invention online at 09:00 on 3 May, UK time. Can the publication be cited against the application?
Months that matter for novelty and priorityA six-month window before filing, the twelve-month priority year, publication at eighteen months and PCT national phase at thirty to thirty-one months.s 2(4) windowpriority filing0 mpriority year ends12 mpublication18 mPCT national phase30/31 m
Months run left to right from a six-month band before filing to national phase entry at thirty to thirty-one months, showing when a disclosure is disregarded, when priority can be claimed and when the application itself becomes public.
  • 1Fix the priority date: under s 5(1), with no earlier filing, it is the filing date of 3 May. The mark allocation used here is not an official university marking scheme.
  • 1Apply the rule that novelty is judged at the beginning of the priority date, so a disclosure made on that day does not anticipate, even if it precedes the filing by some hours.
  • 1Apply Unwired Planet v Huawei: the priority date is the 24-hour day in the time zone of the office of filing, and the publication occurred within that same day.
  • 1Conclude that the publication cannot be cited against this application, though it may matter for later filings.
The online publication does not destroy novelty, because it was made on the priority date itself, measured in the time zone of the UK office. The step weighting here is an original learning aid, not a university marking scheme.
Sia tip — Convert every disclosure time into the time zone of the office where the priority document was filed before comparing dates.
Glossary

Key terms

Made available
Communicated to at least one person outside any duty of secrecy who could acquire and understand the information.
First to file
The priority system under which the earliest filing date, not the earliest invention, decides who may obtain protection.
Priority right
The twelve-month period from a first filing in a Paris Convention state or WTO Member within which a later application can claim that date.
Breach of confidence disclosure
A disclosure made unlawfully or in breach of confidence within six months before filing, which s 2(4) requires to be disregarded.
FAQ

Novelty, the State of the Art and Priority FAQ

What date is novelty judged at?

Novelty is judged at the priority date, which s 5(1) makes the filing date unless an earlier application is validly claimed. The assessment is made at the beginning of that day, so a disclosure on the priority date itself does not anticipate the invention.

Does an unpublished earlier application count as prior art?

Under s 2(3), matter in another application published on or after your priority date counts if it was contained in that application both as filed and as published and has an earlier priority date. The handout notes that UKIPO and EPO practice differ on which earlier applications are included.

Is an email to one person a public disclosure?

Merely transmitting an email over the internet did not make it available to the public in T 2/09 Philips. What matters is whether every element reached at least one recipient who owed no obligation of secrecy, which T 381/87 treats as a question of fact.

Is common general knowledge the same everywhere?

No. Regen Lab v Estar Medical holds that common general knowledge is territorial in scope. It is what the bulk of people working in the field would treat as a reliable basis for further work, including material they would look up as a matter of course.

Study strategy

Exam move

Novelty problems reward discipline about dates, so start every practice answer by drawing a short timeline with the priority date marked and each item of prior art placed before or after it. Learn the three subsections, s 2(2), s 2(3) and s 2(4), as a comparison table with their conditions and effects, and practise sorting mixed sets of disclosures into the right row.

Memorise the s 5 rules on priority, including the twelve-month period under Art 87 EPC and the start-of-day rule, and rehearse the Unwired Planet time-zone point with an example that crosses midnight. For made available, make a short list of the EPO decisions on emails, web pages and analysable products, with one line on what each decided.

Finally, write a paragraph explaining why an inventor should use a non-disclosure agreement before showing an invention to anyone, linking it to the s 2(4) exception and its limits.

Working through Novelty, the State of the Art and Priority in LAWS70271? Sia is AskSia’s AI Law tutor — ask any LAWS70271 Novelty, the State of the Art and Priority question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how LAWS70271 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 41 of your subjects at The University of Manchester, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your LAWS70271 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 3-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works