The University of Manchester · FACULTY OF LAW

LAWS70271 Chap.3 Computer Programs, AI Inventions and Inventorship

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters4-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 3 of 9 · LAWS70271

Computer Programs, AI Inventions and Inventorship

Computer Programs, AI Inventions and Inventorship applies the invention test to the field where it is most contested. It explains why programs are excluded as such, why TRIPS Art 10 protects them as literary works, and how the EPO's further technical effect test lets some programs count as inventions.

It then shows how claims to computer-implemented methods, storage media and devices pass Art 52 easily, yet often fail Art 56 because COMVIK allows only technical features to support inventive step. The chapter applies this to artificial neural networks through the Supreme Court's reasoning in Emotional Perception, where the network was a program but the claim still had technical character because it ran on hardware.

Finally, it turns to inventorship: section 7 PA 77, Rhone-Poulenc v Yeda, and the Thaler litigation across the UK, the EPO, the US and Australia, with the Seminar 1 readings on whether reform is needed.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Why programs are excluded and TRIPS Art 10

  • 02

    Further technical effect under the EPO Guidelines

  • 03

    Computer-implemented inventions and the any hardware approach

  • 04

    COMVIK and the inventive step filter

  • 05

    Artificial neural networks in Emotional Perception

  • 06

    Section 7 PA 77, Rhone-Poulenc and the Thaler decisions

Worked example · free

Assess a neural network claim after Emotional Perception

Q [6 marks]. A claim covers a method of grading crop images with a trained neural network on a server. A rival says the network is a program for a computer and the claim is excluded. Advise on the invention point and the next hurdle.
Two hurdles for a computer-implemented inventionThe invention hurdle is low because any hardware gives technical character; the inventive step hurdle is high because only technical features count.Art 52 inventionany hardwareArt 56 inventive steptechnical features onlyclaim path
The low bar is the invention test, which any claimed hardware now clears, and the tall bar is inventive step, where only technical features count, so a software claim usually fails on the right.
  • 1State the approach: following Emotional Perception at [67], examine whether the claim amounts to an invention, then exclude non-technical features from novelty and inventive step. The mark allocation used here is not an official university marking scheme.
  • 2Accept the rival's first point: on the Supreme Court's reasoning, a neural network is a set of instructions whether or not its weights can be changed, so the program exclusion is engaged.
  • 1Reject the conclusion: the method needs hardware to run, which gives the claim technical character, so it is not a program as such.
  • 2Move to inventive step: under COMVIK only technical features count, so identify what the image grading contributes technically, for example processing of image data, and test that against the prior art.
The claim is an invention because it runs on technical means, but it must still show an inventive technical contribution once non-technical features are set aside. The weighting in this model is not a published university marking scheme.
Sia tip — Concede what the exclusion catches before explaining why the claim escapes it; the concession shows the marker you have read the judgment, not only its headnote.
Glossary

Key terms

Artificial neural network
A computational model treated in Emotional Perception as a set of instructions, and so a program for a computer.
Any hardware approach
The rule that a claim involving technical means such as a computer has technical character and is not excluded as such.
Natural person inventor
The deviser of the inventive concept under s 7 PA 77 as read in Rhone-Poulenc v Yeda.
Problem and solution approach
The EPO method for assessing inventive step, applied only to the technical features of a claim.
Literary work protection
Protection of programs in source or object code as literary works under TRIPS Art 10 and the Berne Convention.
FAQ

Computer Programs, AI Inventions and Inventorship FAQ

Can software be patented in the UK?

A claim involving a computer now passes the invention test because the hardware gives technical character, so the program is not claimed as such. Patentability then depends on inventive step, where only technical features count. A claim whose only novelty is a business rule or algorithm without technical effect will usually fail there.

What is a further technical effect?

It is an effect of running a program that goes beyond the normal physical interaction between software and hardware, such as electrical current flowing in the machine. The EPO examples include restoring a distorted digital image, encrypting electronic communications and protecting boot integrity, and the test is applied without reference to the prior art.

Can an AI system be named as an inventor?

Not in the UK. Section 7 PA 77 and Rhone-Poulenc v Yeda point to a natural person, and the Supreme Court rejected Dr Thaler's applications in 2023. The EPO and the US Federal Circuit reached the same result, and in Australia the Full Federal Court reversed a first-instance decision that had accepted an AI inventor.

Study strategy

Exam move

Build this chapter around one claim and change it step by step. Start with a claim to a program on a storage medium, then a computer-implemented method, then a claim to an image-processing routine, and for each version record the result at Art 52 and at Art 56 with the authority that decides it: G 3/08, T 424/03, the EPO Guidelines at G II 3.6 and COMVIK.

Next, read paras 66 to 67 and 80 to 96 of Emotional Perception and summarise each in two sentences, because Seminar 1 asks about both. For inventorship, make a table of the Thaler decisions by jurisdiction and year, then prepare two or three bullet points on each Seminar 1 author's main argument, as the seminar sheet suggests.

End by writing a short essay plan that separates the question of who can be named as inventor from the question of whether AI-generated subject matter can be patented.

Working through Computer Programs, AI Inventions and Inventorship in LAWS70271? Sia is AskSia’s AI Law tutor — ask any LAWS70271 Computer Programs, AI Inventions and Inventorship question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how LAWS70271 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 41 of your subjects at The University of Manchester, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your LAWS70271 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 4-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works