The University of Manchester · FACULTY OF LAW

LAWS70271 Chap.2 The Requirement for an Invention

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters3-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 2 of 9 · LAWS70271

The Requirement for an Invention

The Requirement for an Invention explains a puzzle at the centre of patent law: neither TRIPS, the EPC nor the Patents Act defines an invention.

Instead, Art 52(2) EPC and s 1(2) PA 77 list things that are not inventions, such as discoveries, mathematical methods, aesthetic creations, business methods, programs for computers and presentations of information, and both provisions limit the exclusion to such matter as such.

The chapter works through the technical character requirement drawn from the Basic Proposal for revising the EPC, and the seven principles set out by the Technical Board in T 154/04 DUNS Licensing.

It then explains why the Supreme Court in Emotional Perception AI v Comptroller [2026] UKSC 3 overruled the four-step Aerotel test and adopted the DUNS approach, so that the UK and the EPO now ask the same question about whether a claim amounts to an invention.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    TRIPS Art 27(1) and the undefined invention

  • 02

    Art 52(1) to (3) EPC 2000 and s 1(1) and (2) PA 77

  • 03

    Technical character and the technical teaching

  • 04

    The DUNS Licensing principles (a) to (g)

  • 05

    Why the Aerotel test was overruled

  • 06

    The approach at [67] of Emotional Perception

Worked example · free

Apply the invention test to a business data claim

Q [4 marks]. A claim covers a method of estimating retail demand by collecting sales figures and applying a statistical weighting, carried out on a networked server. Is it an invention, and which features count afterwards?
Deciding whether a claim is an inventionA claim with any technical character is an invention; only its technical features then count for novelty and inventive step.noyesConstrue the claimAny technical character?Excluded as suchAn inventionAssess technical features
Read the tree from the top: the claim is construed first, a claim with any technical character is an invention, and only after that are its technical features carried forward to the novelty and inventive step tests.
  • 1Construe the claim and identify its technical features, which here are the networked server and the data transmission it performs. The mark allocation used here is not an official university marking scheme.
  • 1Apply DUNS principle (b): an invention implicitly needs technical character, and the server supplies it, so the claim as a whole is not a business method as such.
  • 1Apply principle (f): the statistical weighting and demand estimation are non-technical features that play no part in solving a technical problem with the claimed technical means.
  • 1Conclude that the claim is an invention, but novelty and inventive step will be judged on the server features alone.
The claim passes the invention test because the server gives it technical character, but the commercial weighting is set aside, so the claim is likely to stand or fall on whether the server arrangement itself is new and inventive. The weighting shown is an original learning aid, not a university marking scheme.
Sia tip — Underline every technical feature in the claim before deciding anything, then ask of each remaining feature whether it helps solve a technical problem.
Glossary

Key terms

Technical teaching
An instruction to a skilled person on how to solve a particular technical problem with particular technical means.
As such
The qualifier in Art 52(3) EPC and s 1(2) PA 77 that confines an exclusion to claims relating to the excluded thing itself.
Aerotel test
The former four-step English approach to excluded subject matter, overruled by the Supreme Court in 2026.
Non-technical feature
A claim feature that plays no part in solving a technical problem with the claimed technical means.
FAQ

The Requirement for an Invention FAQ

Why is invention never defined in the statutes?

TRIPS leaves the term open so that new fields such as computer science, biotechnology and nanotechnology can be covered, and Correa reads this as giving Members room to define it in good faith. The EPO likewise relies on a negative list of non-inventions plus the technical character requirement.

Is the Aerotel approach still good law?

No. Emotional Perception overruled it in 2026 after twenty years. The Supreme Court held that the correct approach examines whether a claim amounts to an invention and excludes non-technical features in advance from novelty and inventive step, following the DUNS Licensing principles.

Can a claim mix technical and non-technical features?

Yes. DUNS principle (f) accepts mixed claims, even where non-technical features dominate. The consequence is that only the technical features can establish novelty and inventive step, so the commercial or abstract parts give the claim no help at those later stages.

Is novelty part of the invention requirement?

No. DUNS principle (d) treats invention, novelty, inventive step and industrial application as separate and independent criteria, which can give rise to concurrent objections. An old subject matter can still be an invention; it simply fails the novelty requirement.

Study strategy

Exam move

Learn the statutory texts first, because the analysis depends on their exact words. Write out Art 52(1) to (3) EPC and s 1(1) and (2) PA 77 from memory and underline the words as such. Next, memorise the DUNS principles as short labels, for example four requirements, technicality, as such, independence, construe, mixed claims and technical problem, so that you can cite them by letter in an exam answer.

Then compare Aerotel's four steps with the approach at [67] of Emotional Perception in a two-column table and write one sentence on why the Supreme Court preferred the DUNS route.

Practise with claims of your own invention that combine a business rule, a game rule or a presentation of information with ordinary hardware, and for each one state whether it is an invention and which features survive to the novelty and inventive step stage.

Working through The Requirement for an Invention in LAWS70271? Sia is AskSia’s AI Law tutor — ask any LAWS70271 The Requirement for an Invention question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how LAWS70271 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 41 of your subjects at The University of Manchester, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your LAWS70271 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 3-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works