The University of Manchester · FACULTY OF SOCIOLOGY

SOCS15001 Chap.5 Corporate Social Responsibility and Stakeholders

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters5-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 5 of 9 · SOCS15001

Corporate Social Responsibility and Stakeholders

Corporate Social Responsibility and Stakeholders covers the second half of the lecture, where the question becomes whether firms act on values beyond profit. It begins with the defence of corporations as social institutions whose roles include innovation, meeting social expectations and handling regulation and politics.

CSR is defined as attention to issues beyond a firm's narrow economic, technical and legal duties, pursued for social and environmental benefit alongside economic gain, and it may involve new production methods, triple bottom line reporting, transparency, philanthropy or inclusive governance. Milton Friedman's 1970 objection is set against it: executives serve the owners, whose wish is usually profit within law and custom.

The stakeholder approach answers by mapping primary and secondary groups, sorting them by salience, legitimacy and power, and arguing with Freeman and colleagues that business is a cooperative system of value creation. The chapter trains you to test whether CSR is a genuine change of values or a defence of reputation, using cost as the clearest signal of commitment and the lecture's own doubts as a model of critical reading.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    The defence of corporations as social institutions

  • 02

    Defining CSR and what it may involve in practice

  • 03

    Friedman's shareholder objection and its boundary clause

  • 04

    Primary and secondary stakeholders on the two-tier map

  • 05

    Salience, legitimacy and power as tests of who counts

  • 06

    Judging whether CSR reflects new values or reputation management

Worked example · free

Decide whether a CSR initiative shows non-economic values

Q [4 marks]. A clothing firm switches to a more expensive supplier with better labour standards, publishes a triple bottom line report and advertises both changes heavily. Using the lecture's ideas, decide how far this shows values beyond profit. The marks shown are this guide's own practice weighting, not a University allocation.
The inner ring holds the five primary stakeholders and the outer ring the five secondary groups around one firm, so the reader should notice that communities siThe inner ring holds the five primary stakeholders and the outer ring the five secondary groups around one firm, so the reader should notice that communities sit in the inner tier beside financiers, not outside it.FirmFinanciersEmployeesCustomersSuppliersCommunitiesCompetitorsGovernmentConsumer groupsInterest groupsMedia
The inner ring holds the five primary stakeholders and the outer ring the five secondary groups around one firm, so the reader should notice that communities sit in the inner tier beside financiers, not outside it.
  • 1Classify the actions using the lecture's list of what CSR may involve: a change in production methods, triple bottom line reporting and greater transparency.
  • 1Apply the profit test: heavy advertising suggests a reputational gain, which the lecture lists as one way CSR can improve a firm's finances.
  • 1Apply the cost test: paying more for labour standards is a real economic cost, so this element is harder to explain by profit alone.
  • 1Reach a qualified judgement: the supplier switch points to non-economic values, while the publicity shows the firm also protecting its brand.
The initiative is mixed. The costly supplier change is the strongest sign of values beyond profit, but the reporting and advertising also serve reputation, so the honest verdict is partial: some genuine commitment, wrapped in a strategy that defends the brand.
Sia tip — Separate what the firm did from why it did it; judge motive only after asking which action cost the firm something.
Glossary

Key terms

Triple bottom line
A reporting approach that accounts for social and environmental results alongside financial performance.
Shareholder primacy
The view that a firm's managers should run it chiefly in the owners' interest, usually by pursuing profit.
Corporate philanthropy
Charitable giving of money, goods or staff time by a company to causes outside its business.
Primary stakeholders
The groups closest to a firm's purpose, such as financiers, employees, customers, suppliers and communities.
Stakeholder salience
The degree of urgency and visibility that makes a group's claim press on a firm at a given moment.
FAQ

Corporate Social Responsibility and Stakeholders FAQ

What did Friedman argue about social responsibility?

Friedman held that an executive is employed by the owners and should run the business as they wish, which usually means making as much money as possible within law and ethical custom. He argued that executives who claimed a social conscience believed they were defending free enterprise while in fact preaching socialism.

How is a stakeholder different from a shareholder?

Shareholders own the company as investors. A stakeholder is any group or person whose actions can shape the firm's objectives or who feels the effects of the firm pursuing them, so the category includes employees, customers, suppliers, communities and, in the outer tier, government, media and campaign groups. Shareholders are one kind of financier among many claimants.

Who counts as a primary stakeholder?

On the two-tier map, financiers, employees, customers, suppliers and communities form the inner group. Freeman and colleagues insist that community belongs there in an open society, and they note that maps differ by firm, so a defence company may treat government as primary and a toxic-waste firm may need to treat environmental campaigners the same way.

Can CSR be good for profits?

Yes, according to the lecture. CSR can reduce waste, improve products and strengthen reputation, all of which help a firm's finances. The slides also warn that significant changes may carry economic costs. That double possibility is why profitable CSR alone cannot prove that a company has adopted new values.

Why does the lecture question Freeman's claims?

It marks the claim that shareholder-first management cannot last with a query, and calls the idea of no inherent conflict between financiers and other groups idealistic. Elsewhere the slides stress that stakeholder interests often collide, so the lecture invites you to test the cooperative picture against real cases.

Study strategy

Assessment move

Learn this chapter as a debate with three voices. Write Friedman's argument as three linked steps, then the stakeholder reply in three steps, and practise saying where each would draw the line on a concrete decision such as paying a living wage. Memorise the inner and outer tiers of the stakeholder map and the three attributes of salience, legitimacy and power, because these suit quick recall.

For the portfolio, prepare one example where CSR clearly costs a firm something and one where it clearly pays, and decide which better describes the firms you studied in Chapter 4. Close your notes with your own answer to whether CSR allows a genuine focus on non-economic values.

Working through Corporate Social Responsibility and Stakeholders in SOCS15001? Sia is AskSia’s AI Sociology tutor — ask any SOCS15001 Corporate Social Responsibility and Stakeholders question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how SOCS15001 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 41 of your subjects at The University of Manchester, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your SOCS15001 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 5-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works