The University of Manchester · FACULTY OF SOCIOLOGY

SOCS15001 Chap.4 Transnational Corporations and Their Critics

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters4-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 4 of 9 · SOCS15001

Transnational Corporations and Their Critics

Transnational Corporations and Their Critics covers the first half of the corporate social responsibility lecture: what large cross-border firms are, why critics object to them, and what evidence the lecture offers.

A transnational corporation is defined by its ability to direct activity in several countries even without owning it, to exploit differences between places and their rules, and to shift operations between locations. The lecture compares company revenues with national economies, noting that Amazon would rank 22nd of 193 if counted as a country.

Three charges recur: corporations are too powerful beside democratic institutions, the drive for profit causes harm, and marketing breeds a consumer culture in which other values fade. A timeline of cases, including Bhopal, Deepwater Horizon, the Volkswagen emissions deception and the Grenfell Tower fire, gives material for testing those charges.

The chapter closes with brands as carriers of values and with Adbusters as organised resistance. Throughout, the aim is to use one case at a time to test one critique, so that a portfolio paragraph argues from evidence instead of listing scandals.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Defining the transnational corporation and its three abilities

  • 02

    Comparing company revenue with national GDP, and the limits of that comparison

  • 03

    Three recurring critiques of corporate power

  • 04

    Anti-corporate versus anti-capitalist positions

  • 05

    Using one misconduct case to test one critique

  • 06

    Brands, lifestyle and organised resistance to consumerism

Worked example · free

Test the profit critique against the Deepwater Horizon spill

Q [4 marks]. Using the lecture's account of the 2010 Deepwater Horizon spill, assess in four steps whether the case supports the claim that pursuing profit above all generates negative impacts. The marks shown are this guide's own practice weighting, not a University allocation.
Each bar is drawn to the same scale in billions of US dollars, with national GDP in dark bars and company revenue in violet, using the lecture's own table; notiEach bar is drawn to the same scale in billions of US dollars, with national GDP in dark bars and company revenue in violet, using the lecture's own table; notice that the largest firms reach roughly a sixth of UK output.United Kingdom GDP4,260.0Australia GDP2,120.0South Korea GDP1,930.0Amazon revenue716.9Walmart revenue713.2Apple revenue416.2
Each bar is drawn to the same scale in billions of US dollars, with national GDP in dark bars and company revenue in violet, using the lecture's own table; notice that the largest firms reach roughly a sixth of UK output.
  • 1State the case facts precisely: 4.9 million barrels entered the Gulf of Mexico from a leak left unfixed for 87 days, damaging the environment and coastal fishing.
  • 1Link to the critique: the lecture records that BP was widely blamed for poor construction and maintenance and was convicted of gross negligence and recklessness.
  • 1Add a complication: negligence shows cost-cutting can cause harm, but a court finding also shows that legal limits were eventually applied.
  • 1Conclude with your own judgement, for example that the case supports the critique when oversight is weak, and say what changed in your view.
The spill offers strong support for the critique, since negligence in building and maintaining the rig produced vast environmental and economic damage. A balanced answer adds that the guilty finding shows law can respond, so the case points to weak oversight as much as to profit itself.
Sia tip — Quote one number from the case exactly, then spend the rest of the paragraph on what it shows; a pile of figures is description, not analysis.
Glossary

Key terms

Negative externality
A harm that an activity imposes on third parties who are not part of the transaction, such as pollution.
Market capitalisation
The total market value of a company's shares, which reflects investors' expectations rather than current sales.
Consumer culture
A way of life in which buying goods and brands becomes central to identity and to what people value.
Subvertising
Altering a brand's own advertising images so that they criticise the company or consumerism itself.
Anti-corporate position
Opposition to the power and conduct of large corporations that need not reject capitalism as a whole.
FAQ

Transnational Corporations and Their Critics FAQ

Why compare company revenue with national GDP?

The comparison dramatises scale. In the lecture's table Amazon and Walmart each report revenue above 700 billion dollars, more than many national economies. The comparison is imperfect, because GDP measures value added within a territory while revenue counts total sales, so use it to discuss influence rather than to claim a firm equals a state.

What are the three main critiques of corporations?

First, corporations have grown too large and powerful compared with democratic institutions. Second, putting profit above everything produces harmful effects on people and the environment. Third, corporate marketing builds a consumer culture in which non-economic values fade. The lecture treats these as arguments about corporations specifically, not about capitalism in general.

Do I have to be against capitalism to criticise corporations?

No. The lecture separates the two positions explicitly. Some activists hold broad anti-capitalist views, but many campaigners target the size, conduct or culture of particular firms while accepting markets. Naming which position a movement takes makes your description of it more precise, and it stops a portfolio from attributing views to campaigners that they do not hold.

Which cases does the lecture use as evidence?

It lists Union Carbide at Bhopal in 1984, Nestle's baby milk marketing, Shell and the Ogoni protests, Coca-Cola and trade unions, BP's Deepwater Horizon spill in 2010, Volkswagen's defeat devices found in 2015, and harassment by eBay executives reported in 2022, then examines the 2017 Grenfell Tower fire.

How do brands connect to power and value?

Klein argued that brands sell a lifestyle and a set of values rather than a product, and Bourdieu linked lifestyle to a stylised pattern of choices. If brands shape what people value, corporate power reaches into culture, which is why groups such as Adbusters resist through subvertising and Buy Nothing Day.

Study strategy

Assessment move

Build a one-page evidence bank for this chapter. Write the definition of a transnational corporation in your own words with its three abilities underneath. Then draw a three-column table headed with the three critiques and place each lecture case in the column it tests best, adding one exact fact per case.

For the quiz, rehearse the distinction between anti-corporate and anti-capitalist positions and the main figures in the scale comparison. For the portfolio, pick the single case that most changed your view and write two sentences: what it shows and what complicates it. Finish by noting whether you think firms change under criticism or do just enough to quieten it.

Working through Transnational Corporations and Their Critics in SOCS15001? Sia is AskSia’s AI Sociology tutor — ask any SOCS15001 Transnational Corporations and Their Critics question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how SOCS15001 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 41 of your subjects at The University of Manchester, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your SOCS15001 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 4-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works