BENV0090 Chap.5 Firm Investment, Discounting and LCOE
Firm Investment, Discounting and LCOE
Firm Investment, Discounting and LCOE views energy from inside a firm allocating scarce capital. It shows how discounting turns future revenue into present value, why the cost of capital is contested, and how the short-run decision to operate differs from the long-run decision to invest.
A clinic recomputes the levelised cost of wind and gas at different discount rates to show that financing, not engineering, can move most of the gap, and warns that LCOE does not measure system value. Portfolio theory and real options complete the toolkit for the investment pitch tutorial. Practice items value a solar farm at two discount rates and frame one technology for two investors with different goals.
What this chapter covers
- 01
Cost-benefit analysis and profit
- 02
Short run versus long run
- 03
Discounting and present value
- 04
Cost of capital and hurdle rates
- 05
Levelised cost of electricity
- 06
Portfolio theory and real options
Worked example · free
Recompute wind and gas LCOE at two discount rates
- 1Capital recovery factor over 25 years: 0.0710 at 5% and 0.1102 at 10%.
- 2Wind at 5%: (1,500 x 0.0710 + 40) / 3.504 = £41.79/MWh; at 10%: £58.58/MWh.
- 2Gas at 5%: (600 x 0.0710 + 20) / 5.256 + 60 = £71.90/MWh; at 10%: £76.38/MWh.
- 1Wind rises by 40% and gas by 6%, so the financing rate moves the capital-heavy option most.
Key terms
- Discount rate
- The rate used to convert future cash flows into present value, reflecting time and risk.
- Capital recovery factor
- The annual payment per unit of capital that repays it with interest over a set life.
- Real option
- The right, but not the obligation, to expand, delay or abandon a project as information arrives.
- Net present value
- The present value of a project's benefits minus the present value of its costs.
- Hurdle rate
- The minimum return an investor requires before committing capital to a project.
Firm Investment, Discounting and LCOE FAQ
Why does the discount rate change which technology looks cheapest?
Capital-heavy technologies such as wind or nuclear pay most of their costs upfront, so a higher rate raises their annualised cost sharply. Fuel-heavy plants pay as they go and move much less. Comparing levelised costs is only fair at a stated, common rate.
What does LCOE leave out?
It ignores when the power is produced, the balancing and network costs a technology imposes, and how its output affects the price it receives. Two plants with equal LCOE can therefore have quite different value to the system.
How should the investment pitch be structured?
Compare your technology's levelised cost with competitors using the government estimates, say whether you accept them and why, recommend what to back today and in 2035, and show how other metrics, risk or a wider system view would change the answer.
What is the difference between the short run and the long run for a power plant?
In the short run the plant exists, so it runs whenever the price covers its running cost and the capital is sunk. In the long run nothing is sunk, and a firm invests only if expected prices also repay the capital with a return. Volatile prices widen the gap between the two decisions.
What are real options and why do they matter for energy?
A real option is the right, but not the obligation, to expand, delay or abandon a project later. Modular technologies such as solar can be added step by step, while a large nuclear plant commits everything at once. When prices and policy are uncertain, flexibility has value that a simple net present value misses.
Assessment move
Make discounting fluent: compute present values of single sums and annuities by hand at two rates until you can predict the direction of change before calculating. Then rebuild the levelised cost formula for one renewable and one fuel-based plant and run it at three discount rates, as in the clinic.
Read the government cost estimates for your assigned technology and note every assumption that moves the result most, especially hurdle rates, load factors and fuel prices. For the pitch, prepare one slide that answers the profit-focused investor and one argument for the investor who weighs environment, security and equity, and decide in advance which partner you would approach in the second round.
The required reading is a value-for-money review of a large nuclear project; read its summary with three questions in mind: what discount rate or financing model it assumes, which risks fall on consumers or taxpayers, and how cost overruns would change the result.
For the essay, an economic lens is strongest when it turns a target into a cost or investment requirement and tests it against financing conditions, such as the rate at which developers can borrow.