University College London · FACULTY OF ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE

BENV0090 Chap.4 Environmental Impacts and Multi-Criteria Analysis

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters5-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 4 of 10 · BENV0090

Environmental Impacts and Multi-Criteria Analysis

Environmental Impacts and Multi-Criteria Analysis treats energy as an environmental system that draws on resources and returns wastes. It explains boundaries and indicators, limits to resource use, externalities and public goods, and shows on a diagram why a market ignoring damage produces too much of it.

Multi-criteria analysis is developed step by step with an original clean-air ranking, a stacked score chart and a sensitivity test that shows how weights can change the winner. The policy instruments page compares standards, taxes, permits and subsidies, and links them to the commons problem and to the air-quality briefing tutorial.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    System boundaries and indicators

  • 02

    Limits to resource use

  • 03

    Externalities and public goods

  • 04

    Pigouvian taxes and standards

  • 05

    Multi-criteria analysis steps

  • 06

    Weight sensitivity and equity

Worked example · free

Find the optimal output when pollution is priced

Q [6 marks]. Demand is P = 100 - Q and private marginal cost is P = 20 + Q. Each unit causes 20 of external damage. Find the market output, the optimal output, the corrective tax and the welfare loss the market creates. The marks shown are an original study allocation, not an official UCL marking scheme.
The marginal social cost line sits 20 above the private cost line because each unit of output imposes 20 of external damage.The marginal social cost line sits 20 above the private cost line because each unit of output imposes 20 of external damage. The market settles at Q = 40, the social optimum is Q = 30, and the shaded triangle of 100 is the welfare lost by ignoring the damage.Output QPriceDemandMPCMSC30406070
The marginal social cost line sits 20 above the private cost line because each unit of output imposes 20 of external damage. The market settles at Q = 40, the social optimum is Q = 30, and the shaded triangle of 100 is the welfare lost by ignoring the damage.
  • 2Market: 100 - Q = 20 + Q, so Q = 40 and P = 60.
  • 2Social cost = 40 + Q; optimum: 100 - Q = 40 + Q, so Q = 30.
  • 1A tax of 20 per unit, the marginal external cost, moves the market to Q = 30.
  • 1Deadweight loss = 0.5 x (40 - 30) x 20 = 100.
The market overproduces by 10 units and loses 100 in welfare. A tax of 20 per unit corrects it. The optimum is not zero output, because beyond Q = 30 the benefit of each unit exceeds its full social cost. The marks are an original practice allocation.
Sia tip — Set the corrective tax equal to the marginal external damage at the optimum, and check that the tax base matches the source of the damage.
Glossary

Key terms

Public good
A good that no one can be excluded from and that one person's use does not diminish, such as clean air.
Pigouvian tax
A charge per unit equal to the marginal external damage, which aligns private and social cost.
Criterion weight
The share of importance given to one criterion when scores are combined in multi-criteria analysis.
Sensitivity test
A rerun of an analysis with changed inputs to see whether the result holds.
Deadweight loss
The welfare lost when output differs from the level that balances full social benefit and cost.
FAQ

Environmental Impacts and Multi-Criteria Analysis FAQ

Why is the optimal level of pollution not zero?

Cutting damage has a cost. Beyond the social optimum, the benefit of the last unit of output still exceeds its full social cost, so cutting further would make society worse off. The aim is the right level, not none at all.

When should I use multi-criteria analysis instead of cost-benefit analysis?

Use it when impacts such as health, fairness and feasibility cannot sensibly be expressed in money. Its value is transparency about weights, so always report the weights and test whether the ranking changes when they move.

What should the air pollution briefing include?

Set the system boundary for the drivers of the crisis, outline an action plan and make data central. The class discussion also asks whether to limit resource use or back new technology, whether to regulate or use incentives, and whether to prioritise efficiency or equity.

What is the difference between a standard and a tax?

A standard sets a limit or bans a technology, giving a certain outcome but ignoring differences in abatement cost between firms. A tax prices each unit of damage, so the cheapest cuts happen first, but the final level of pollution is uncertain and the cost can fall heavily on poorer households.

How does the commons reading relate to energy?

It describes how a shared resource open to all is overused, because each user gains the full benefit of using more while bearing only part of the cost. Pollution is the reverse case: each polluter saves the cost of cleaning up while the damage is shared. Collective rules a society agrees to impose are the remedy.

Study strategy

Assessment move

Draw the externality diagram from memory with your own numbers until you can find the market and optimal outputs quickly, then explain the tax in one sentence. For multi-criteria analysis, practise the full routine on a small decision you know well: list options, choose non-overlapping criteria, score with evidence, weight and sum, then rerun with different weights.

Keep a table of the four policy instruments with a real energy example of each. Before the briefing tutorial, gather two or three data points on health impacts and pollution levels, decide your weights openly, and prepare to defend them when another group asks why equity counts for more or less than cost.

Use the required reading on energy and the Sustainable Development Goals as a reminder that an energy action can support one goal while setting back another. When you build an MCA, include at least one criterion that captures such a side effect.

In the essay, an environmental lens works best when it is tied to an indicator with good data, such as emissions, air quality or land use, and when you state the boundary of the impacts you count.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 32 of your subjects at University College London, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your BENV0090 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 5-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works