University College London · FACULTY OF LINGUISTICS

CCME0051 Chap.4 Learner Language and Developmental Sequences

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
7 Chapters3-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 4 of 10 · CCME0051

Learner Language and Developmental Sequences

Learner Language and Developmental Sequences treats the language a learner produces as a system in its own right. Interlanguage has regular patterns, changes as new input is processed and shows similar routes across learners from different backgrounds.

The unit names the processes behind that change: restructuring, when a new rule reorganises existing knowledge; U-shaped behaviour, when accuracy dips before it recovers; simplification, when endings are dropped to keep talk moving; and fossilization, when some non-target forms stop developing.

It then reviews developmental sequences such as the stages of negation and question formation, the classic morpheme studies and more recent corpus evidence that both accuracy and order of English grammatical morphemes depend on the first language. Methods matter throughout, because the same learner varies across tasks and two common accuracy measures can disagree.

The unit closes with developmental readiness, the idea that teaching works best when it targets the next stage a learner can reach, which links learner language research directly to classroom decisions and to the design of a small study.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Interlanguage as a rule-governed, changing system

  • 02

    Restructuring, simplification and U-shaped behaviour

  • 03

    Fossilization and the limits of short studies

  • 04

    Second language negation and question stages

  • 05

    Morpheme accuracy orders and first language influence

  • 06

    Suppliance and target-like use as accuracy measures

  • 07

    Developmental readiness and the timing of instruction

Worked example · free

Explain a U-shaped curve in a learner's past forms

Q [5 marks]. A learner is recorded three times over six months telling the same kind of story. In the first recording she uses went, came and saw correctly. In the second she says goed, comed and seed, while also adding -ed correctly to many regular verbs. In the third the irregular forms are correct again. Explain whether the second recording shows decline, and name the process involved. The weighting shown is our own study aid and is not a published UCL marking scheme.
The curve plots accuracy on irregular past forms against time: early rote use is accurate, accuracy dips while restructuring produces forms like goed, and recovThe curve plots accuracy on irregular past forms against time: early rote use is accurate, accuracy dips while restructuring produces forms like goed, and recovery follows once the rule and its exceptions are sorted.accuracytimewentgoedwentearly rote userestructuringrecovery
The curve plots accuracy on irregular past forms against time: early rote use is accurate, accuracy dips while restructuring produces forms like goed, and recovery follows once the rule and its exceptions are sorted.
  • 1Early accuracy on went, came and saw reflects forms stored as whole words before any past tense rule was in place.
  • 2In the second recording the learner has noticed the regular -ed rule and applies it too widely, so the irregular forms are overridden.
  • 1This is restructuring, and the drop then recovery traces a U-shaped curve rather than a loss of knowledge.
  • 1The third recording shows rule and exceptions sorted out, so the dip marked progress in the system.
The second recording is not decline. Overregularisation shows that the learner has extracted a general past tense rule and is restructuring her interlanguage, which produces the temporary dip of a U-shaped curve before accuracy recovers.
Sia tip — Before calling a new error a regression, check whether it shows a newly learned rule applied too widely.
Glossary

Key terms

Restructuring
A reorganisation of a learner's existing knowledge triggered when a new rule or pattern is taken in.
Fossilization
A state in which certain non-target forms stop developing despite continued exposure.
U-shaped behaviour
A developmental pattern where accuracy on a form falls for a time and then rises again.
Developmental readiness
A learner's position just below the next stage, where teaching that stage can take effect.
Target-like use score
An accuracy measure that divides correct uses by required contexts plus places where the form was overused.
FAQ

Learner Language and Developmental Sequences FAQ

Are learner errors just mistakes to be corrected?

Many of them are evidence of a developing system rather than random slips. Forms such as a negator placed after the subject recur across learners with different first languages, which suggests learners pass through shared stages. Treating these forms as data about the current interlanguage helps a teacher choose what to target next.

Can teaching help learners skip a developmental stage?

The Week 1 slides state that learners cannot skip stages or reorder acquisition through instruction. Teaching aimed at the stage a learner is ready for can, however, speed up progress through the sequence, which is the practical message of developmental readiness.

Is there a universal order for English grammatical morphemes?

Early morpheme studies argued for one natural order. The corpus study read in Week 4 analysed writing from learners of seven first languages and found that accuracy and order both vary with the first language, particularly for morphemes like articles whose concepts are missing in some languages.

Why do two accuracy scores give different results for the same learner?

Suppliance in obligatory contexts ignores places where a learner adds a form without need, while target-like use counts them as errors. A learner who overuses an ending will therefore look stronger on the first measure, so a report should state which score it uses and justify the choice.

How long should a study last to show fossilization?

A short project cannot show that a form has permanently stopped changing, because slow development looks the same over a few weeks. In a module report it is safer to describe a form as stable during the study period and discuss fossilization as one possible explanation among several.

Study strategy

Assessment move

Learn the stages of negation and question formation well enough to place an utterance quickly, then practise on your own invented sentences, judging a stage only from a group of utterances. Work through one scoring calculation by hand with suppliance in obligatory contexts and with target-like use, so you can explain why the two differ.

When you read the corpus study, record how many learners, which first languages and which morphemes were analysed, and note what the design can and cannot show about individual development. Finally, write two sentences linking readiness to a teaching decision, because that link is a natural discussion point in an empirical report on grammar development or teaching timing.

Working through Learner Language and Developmental Sequences in CCME0051? Sia is AskSia’s AI Linguistics tutor — ask any CCME0051 Learner Language and Developmental Sequences question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how CCME0051 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 32 of your subjects at University College London, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your CCME0051 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 3-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works