University College London · FACULTY OF EDUCATION

EDPS0004 Chap.9 Archives, Evidence and Cross-Cutting Concepts

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
7 Chapters3-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 9 of 9 · EDPS0004

Archives, Evidence and Cross-Cutting Concepts

Archives, Evidence and Cross-Cutting Concepts combines the museum and archives session with the module's closing review. It introduces the IOE archives and the range of primary sources they hold, from minute books and letters to photographs, oral histories and websites, and the proforma students use to identify, understand and evaluate a source.

It then draws the six themes together, social class, gender, race, sexuality, learner identities and teacher identities, around the two central questions and the concepts of structure, agency and discourse.

The chapter also gathers the module's evidence habits: the difference between common and contested knowledge, why contested claims need references, how to cite a source read second hand, and why a review essay should treat any article as evidence to be questioned.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    The Museum of London Docklands visit

  • 02

    What the IOE archives hold

  • 03

    Identifying, understanding and evaluating a primary source

  • 04

    The six themes of the module

  • 05

    Discourse as a cross-cutting concept

  • 06

    Common and contested knowledge

  • 07

    Citing primary and secondary sources

Worked example · free

Evaluate an archival photograph

Q [4 marks]. In an archive you find a staged photograph of a 1930s classroom produced for a school's annual report. Using the primary source proforma, assess what it can and cannot tell you about schooling at the time. The mark allocation shown is AskSia's own practice weighting, not a published university scheme.
The primary source proforma as three steps.The primary source proforma as three steps. The proforma has two sections, identifying and understanding the source, and its last question on reliability is drawn here as a third step. Each rung sits above the one it depends on: you cannot judge reliability until you know who produced a document and why, and what argument and values it carries.1 identifytype, creator, date, purpose2 understandargument, values, context, audience3 evaluatehow reliable is it?
The primary source proforma as three steps. The proforma has two sections, identifying and understanding the source, and its last question on reliability is drawn here as a third step. Each rung sits above the one it depends on: you cannot judge reliability until you know who produced a document and why, and what argument and values it carries.
  • 1Identify the source: a photograph, produced by or for the school, for a public annual report.
  • 1Understand its values: it presents the order and achievement the school wished to display.
  • 1Relate it to context and audience, such as parents or funders reading the report.
  • 1Evaluate reliability: strong evidence of the school's self-image, weak evidence of ordinary daily practice.
The photograph is good evidence of how the school wanted to be seen and weak evidence of everyday classroom life, because it was staged for a persuasive public document. Its value depends on asking who made it, why and for whom.
Sia tip — Judge reliability against the question you are asking; a biased source can still be excellent evidence of the bias.
Glossary

Key terms

Primary source
Original material produced at the time studied, such as letters, minutes, photographs or reports.
Contested knowledge
A claim or definition on which people disagree, which must be supported with references.
FAQ

Archives, Evidence and Cross-Cutting Concepts FAQ

Why does a sociology module include an archives session?

Archives let students handle primary sources, such as reports, letters, photographs and minute books, and practise asking who produced a document, why, for whom and how reliable it is. Those questions are the same ones a review essay should ask of a journal article, so the session trains the evidence habits the assessment rewards.

What are the six main themes of the module?

The closing session lists social class, gender, race, sexuality, learner identities and teacher identities. It ties them together through the two central questions about educational inequality and through cross-cutting concepts such as structure and agency, discourse and intersectionality, which is why an exam article on one theme can often be read with tools from another.

When do I need to reference a claim?

The module distinguishes common knowledge, which needs no justification, from contested knowledge, which must be referenced. A definition of equal opportunities is contested, while the existence of free school meals may be common knowledge though exact figures still need a source. Avoid sweeping generalisations without supporting evidence.

How can the museum and archive visits help my essay?

Treat them as practice in reading evidence. The museum trail and the primary source proforma train you to ask who produced a source, why, for whom, what values it carries and how reliable it is. Applying the same questions to the article you review shows the critical engagement with method and assumptions that the essay feedback asks for.

Study strategy

Exam move

Use this chapter as the final stage of revision. First, copy the proforma's questions onto a card and practise applying them to two very different sources: a journal article from the reading list and a document such as a school prospectus or a policy speech. Notice how the same questions about creator, purpose, values, context, audience and reliability work for both.

Second, build a cross-theme grid with the six themes as rows and the module's key concepts as columns, and tick every cell where a concept can be used, adding a study for each tick. That grid shows you, for example, that habitus appears in the class and teacher sessions and discourse in the gender, learner and teacher sessions.

Third, review your referencing: choose three claims from your draft essay and decide whether each is common or contested knowledge, then check that every contested claim has a citation and that any secondary citation names the original and the source you read. Finish by writing a one-paragraph synthesis linking two themes through one concept, and time yourself doing it.

Working through Archives, Evidence and Cross-Cutting Concepts in EDPS0004? Sia is AskSia’s AI Education tutor — ask any EDPS0004 Archives, Evidence and Cross-Cutting Concepts question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how EDPS0004 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 32 of your subjects at University College London, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your EDPS0004 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 3-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works