EDPS0004 Chap.8 Teacher Identity, Emotional Labour and Professionalism
Teacher Identity, Emotional Labour and Professionalism
Teacher Identity, Emotional Labour and Professionalism turns from pupils to the people who teach them. It begins with the profile of the workforce in England, largely female and largely White British, with sharp differences between primary and secondary schools and among head teachers, and with research on why minority ethnic teachers leave at higher rates.
The chapter examines the long history of feminisation, simplistic role model debates and the critique of the feminised primary school. It then explores professional discourses of the good teacher, Colley's vocational habitus, the idea of detached attachment and Hochschild's emotional labour.
Finally it tests teaching against the characteristics of a profession and reads Braun's biographical study of trainee teachers, where class and gender shape the status of teaching.
What this chapter covers
- 01
The gender and ethnic profile of the teaching workforce
- 02
Minority ethnic teacher retention
- 03
The history of feminised teaching
- 04
Role models and the feminised primary school
- 05
Discourses of the good teacher
- 06
Vocational habitus and detached attachment
- 07
Emotional labour and professional status
Worked example · free
Analyse a recruitment slogan
- 1Define vocational habitus as the idealised dispositions trainees must adopt to be judged right for the job.
- 1Show that the slogan invites trainees to embody teaching as a calling rather than perform it as work.
- 1Apply emotional labour: a calling implies sustained management of feeling, such as caring for every pupil equally.
- 1Note the cost: framing teaching as vocation can obscure workload and weaken claims to professional status.
Key terms
- Vocational habitus
- Colley's term for the idealised dispositions a trainee must adopt to be seen as right for the job.
- Detached attachment
- A professional self that combines care with control, read in the lecture as a kind of emotional labour.
- Semi-profession
- Etzioni's label for occupations such as teaching that lack the full status of established professions.
Teacher Identity, Emotional Labour and Professionalism FAQ
Is teaching a feminised profession?
The lecture's Department for Education figures show women as nearly three-quarters of teachers in 2016, a much larger majority in primary than secondary schools, and a minority of secondary head teachers in 2015. Women have outnumbered men among state school teachers since around 1870, so the feminisation is long-standing rather than new.
What is emotional labour in teaching?
Hochschild used the term for managing one's own feelings to produce a required display at work, first studying flight attendants. She argues that long-term feigning is exhausting, so many workers turn to deep acting, and she names the teacher who likes every student equally as an example. Detached attachment is read as one form of it.
Do male teachers act as better role models for boys?
Simple role model arguments assume that men teach differently, that pupils respond better to teachers of their own sex and that male teachers share one masculinity. Feminist research cited in the session finds that the evidence does not support these assumptions, though the debate remains very visible in popular media and public debate.
Why is teaching called a semi-profession?
Etzioni's 1969 label reflects teaching's ambivalent status. The lecture lists reasons often given: many women in the occupation, teaching seen as less glamorous than medicine or law, public familiarity with teachers from everyone's own schooling, lower qualifications than some professions, and the belief that anyone can teach. Each reason is itself a discourse worth questioning.
Exam move
Learn the workforce figures accurately, since a reversed or inflated number would weaken any essay that uses them: the overall share of women teachers in 2016, the primary and secondary split, the share of female secondary head teachers in 2015 and the ethnic profile of teachers and heads.
Then build a concept chain from Moore's three discourses of the good teacher, to Colley's vocational habitus, to detached attachment and Hochschild's emotional labour, writing one sentence on how each leads to the next. Read Braun's article with its reading questions and summarise each of the three cases in a sentence that names both class and gender.
Practise testing an occupation against the lecture's characteristics of a profession, and write a short paragraph on where teaching fits and where it departs. Finally, connect the session to earlier themes: link the feminised workforce to the failing boys debate, the retention research to institutional racism, and vocational habitus to Bourdieu, so you can write cross-theme paragraphs if the exam article concerns teachers.
Working through Teacher Identity, Emotional Labour and Professionalism in EDPS0004? Sia is AskSia’s AI Education tutor — ask any EDPS0004 Teacher Identity, Emotional Labour and Professionalism question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how EDPS0004 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.