EDPS0004 Chap.7 Learner Identities and the Good Learner
Learner Identities and the Good Learner
Learner Identities and the Good Learner uses poststructural theories of identity to explain how children are constituted as particular types of learner. Learner identities are subject positions framed by dominant discourses, deployed by teachers to define pupils as successful or not, well behaved or not, teachable or not.
Assessment supplies a model of the good learner, close to the neoliberal subject who is industrious, self-regulating and reflective. Classroom ethnography shows these identities shaped by race, class and gender: Connolly's study of inner-city Year 1 classrooms and Bradbury's study of two inner London Reception classes, where the statutory early years assessment measured children against an idealised White middle-class norm.
The chapter closes with Bradbury's conclusions on the precarity of identities and the power of the intersection of gender and race.
What this chapter covers
- 01
Learner identities as subject positions
- 02
Discourse and the production of truth
- 03
Poststructural theories of identity
- 04
The neoliberal good learner
- 05
Assessment as a model of the ideal pupil
- 06
Connolly's inner-city classrooms
- 07
Bradbury's Reception classrooms and four conclusions
Worked example · free
Rewrite a teacher comment as a learner identity
- 1Define learner identity as a subject position produced through dominant discourses of learning.
- 1Show that the comments constitute the children as good and bad learners rather than describing fixed traits.
- 1Ask which discourses, such as class, gender or race, may inform the judgements.
- 1Note that written reports and assessments can turn these positions into lasting facts.
Key terms
- Subject position
- A recognisable identity made available by a discourse, which people take up or are placed in.
- Neoliberal subject
- An ideal self that is industrious, self-regulating, flexible and responsible for its own improvement.
- Ethnography
- Research based on extended observation of everyday life in a setting such as a classroom.
Learner Identities and the Good Learner FAQ
What is a learner identity?
In the module, a learner identity is a subject position shaped by dominant discourses about what a good learner should be. Teachers position pupils as succeeding or failing, as well or badly behaved, and as teachable or not, and these positions are often linked to other markers such as gender, class and race.
How does assessment create a good learner?
Bradbury's research shows that the statutory early years assessment provides a model of the good learner, involved, independent, motivated and well behaved. Teachers then judge children against that model, which tends to match an idealised White middle-class child, and the assessment records those judgements as outcomes that can follow children through school.
Why use poststructural theory rather than personality?
Poststructural theory treats identity as constituted through discourse rather than as a fixed inner trait. That lets researchers ask why certain groups are repeatedly read as good or bad learners, and it leaves room for resistance, since Foucault argues that discourse can also expose and undermine power.
Why does early years assessment matter so much?
The session argues that early identities form the basis for later recognition as successful or failing in school. Assessment solidifies a model of the good learner and then turns judgements made against that model into recorded facts, and links between school, home and parents are especially strong with young children, so early labels can travel a long way.
Exam move
Begin with definitions, writing learner identity, discourse, subject position and neoliberal subject in your own words, each with a classroom example. Then summarise the two ethnographies side by side: Connolly's three Year 1 classrooms and Bradbury's two Reception classrooms, noting the setting, the method and how race, class and gender shaped which children were read as good or bad learners.
Learn Bradbury's four conclusions well enough to state each in one sentence. Practise the grammar of identity writing by rewriting statements about children so that they describe positioning rather than traits; this habit makes your analysis sound sociological and protects you from repeating stereotypes.
Watch the short introduction to Foucault's discourse recommended for the session, then explain discourse aloud using one example from the module's review lecture. Finally, connect this session to earlier ones: link the neoliberal good learner to the gender session's focus on measurable attainment and to Bourdieu's cultural capital, so you can build cross-theme paragraphs in the exam.
Working through Learner Identities and the Good Learner in EDPS0004? Sia is AskSia’s AI Education tutor — ask any EDPS0004 Learner Identities and the Good Learner question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how EDPS0004 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.