University College London · FACULTY OF EDUCATION

EDPS0004 Chap.5 Race, Racism and Critical Race Theory

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
7 Chapters4-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 5 of 9 · EDPS0004

Race, Racism and Critical Race Theory

Race, Racism and Critical Race Theory treats race as a social construction with no biological basis but very real effects. It traces the history of the idea through colonialism, slavery and scientific racism, compares the terms race, ethnicity, BAME and minoritised, and contrasts the rotten apple view of racism with racism as unconscious, widespread and institutional, using the Macpherson definition.

A short history of race in British education, from Coard's account in 1971 to research on examination tiers, frames current attainment data by ethnicity and free school meal eligibility, including the debate over the White working class.

The chapter introduces Critical Race Theory: the centrality of racism, white privilege, critique of liberal neutrality, the call to context and counter-storytelling, applied in the key reading on identity performance in schools.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Race as a contested and changing idea

  • 02

    Scientific racism and race as a social construction

  • 03

    Ethnicity, BAME and minoritised as terms

  • 04

    The rotten apple and business as usual views of racism

  • 05

    Institutional racism and the Macpherson definition

  • 06

    Attainment by ethnicity and free school meals

  • 07

    Critical Race Theory, white privilege and counter-stories

Worked example · free

Read an attainment table through CRT

Q [4 marks]. A school notices that its minority ethnic pupils are less often entered for advanced courses, though no teacher holds openly racist views. Explain how Critical Race Theory would interpret the pattern. The mark allocation shown is AskSia's own practice weighting, not a published university scheme.
Five explanations offered for attainment gaps.Five explanations offered for attainment gaps. The dark centre is the outcome being explained and each spoke is one candidate cause named in the lecture; a review essay should ask which of them locates the problem in families and which in schools.attainment gapby ethnic grouplanguagecultureclasscurriculumlow expectations
Five explanations offered for attainment gaps. The dark centre is the outcome being explained and each spoke is one candidate cause named in the lecture; a review essay should ask which of them locates the problem in families and which in schools.
  • 1Contrast the traditional view, which looks for intentional individual racism and finds none.
  • 1State CRT's claim that racism is normal, embedded and enacted through colour-blind practice.
  • 1Apply institutional racism: routine entry decisions produce unequal outcomes through unwitting prejudice.
  • 1Identify evidence CRT would seek, such as the decision process and pupils' experiential accounts.
Critical Race Theory would not wait for a prejudiced individual. It would treat the pattern as institutional racism produced by routine decisions applied as if fairly, and would examine the process and the experiences of the pupils affected.
Sia tip — Locate racism in the effect and the process, not the intention; the absence of a bigot is not evidence of a fair system.
Glossary

Key terms

Critical Race Theory
A perspective that treats racism as normal and embedded in institutions, sustained by practices assumed to be fair.
Minoritised
A term stressing that minority status depends on context and is produced rather than inherent.
Model minority
An argument using one minority group's high attainment to deny that structural racism exists.
FAQ

Race, Racism and Critical Race Theory FAQ

Why do sociologists say race is a social construction?

Human populations form a biological continuum, and dividing people by appearance or alleged genetic difference is spurious and politically dangerous. Yet race remains a powerful social category with real daily effects, which is the paradox Guillaumin captures. Sociologists therefore study how racial categories are made and used rather than treating them as natural.

What is institutional racism?

The 1999 Macpherson report treats it as a failure of a whole organisation, rather than of one person, to serve people properly on grounds of colour, culture or ethnic origin. Such racism shows itself in processes, attitudes and behaviour, through prejudice nobody intended, ignorance, carelessness and stereotyping, so racism can exist without anyone meaning it.

Why is the White working-class attainment debate controversial?

Attainment data show White British pupils on free school meals doing less well than other ethnic groups with the same eligibility, and this drew strong policy attention. Critics argue that the focus sets White working-class pupils against minority working-class pupils, ignores wider structural issues and turns a question of class and poverty into one about ethnicity.

What does minoritised mean, and why use it?

Minoritised refers to groups who are not White in a society where the White population is the overall majority, as in the UK. The term stresses that minority status depends on context and is produced rather than being an inherent quality of the group. The key reading uses it, and the lecture invites students to choose and justify their own preferred term.

Study strategy

Exam move

Start with vocabulary, because precise terms are where race essays gain or lose credibility. Write your own definitions of race, ethnicity, racism, minoritised, white privilege, institutional racism and Critical Race Theory, and decide which term you will use for groups in your essay and why. Then learn the Macpherson definition closely enough to paraphrase it accurately.

Build a short chronology of race and British education, from Coard in 1971 and the Swann Report in 1985 to research on examination tiers and on minority achievement, so you can place any article you are given. Practise reading attainment data critically: for any gap by ethnicity, ask what happens when free school meal eligibility and gender are added.

Work through the Bradbury reading questions, especially the ones on the counter-story, the model minority argument and identity performance, and write one paragraph applying each idea to a school practice. Finally, complete McIntosh's reflection exercise honestly; it prepares you for the podcast if you choose race as your focus.

Working through Race, Racism and Critical Race Theory in EDPS0004? Sia is AskSia’s AI Education tutor — ask any EDPS0004 Race, Racism and Critical Race Theory question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how EDPS0004 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 32 of your subjects at University College London, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your EDPS0004 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 4-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works