University College London · FACULTY OF EDUCATION

EDPS0004 Chap.4 Gender, Feminism and the Failing Boys Debate

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
7 Chapters4-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 4 of 9 · EDPS0004

Gender, Feminism and the Failing Boys Debate

Gender, Feminism and the Failing Boys Debate traces how sociologists moved from a biological view of sex to gender as social, relational and performed. Oakley's distinction between sex and gender, Butler's idea of doing gender and the plural language of masculinities and femininities form the conceptual base.

Foucault's discourse and Connell's hegemonic masculinity explain how gendered norms are produced and how power is distributed. The chapter then follows changing concerns in English education, from feminist worries about girls in the 1970s to the visibility of girls' success after the 1988 National Curriculum and the moral panic over failing boys.

It closes with the argument that a neoliberal focus on measurable attainment sidelines other gender issues, and with intersectional approaches that refuse to read gender alone.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Sex and gender as distinct concepts

  • 02

    Doing gender and performativity

  • 03

    Masculinities and femininities in the plural

  • 04

    Discourse, discursive formations and critique

  • 05

    Patriarchy and hegemonic masculinity

  • 06

    Girls' achievement and the moral panic over boys

  • 07

    Neoliberal accountability and intersectionality

Worked example · free

Question a gender gap statistic

Q [4 marks]. A newspaper reports that girls outperform boys at sixteen and calls for a national boys' strategy. Write a short critical response using the module's account of the failing boys debate. The mark allocation shown is AskSia's own practice weighting, not a published university scheme.
How the gender question in English schooling moved.How the gender question in English schooling moved. Points are placed in date order along one line, from the arrival of the term in 1972, through the 1970s concern for girls and the 1988 National Curriculum, to the panic over boys and the current attainment debate.1972term gender taken up1970sgirls seen as held back1988National Curriculum1995panic over failing boys2019attainment gap debate
How the gender question in English schooling moved. Points are placed in date order along one line, from the arrival of the term in 1972, through the 1970s concern for girls and the 1988 National Curriculum, to the panic over boys and the current attainment debate.
  • 1Acknowledge the pattern: girls' results improved markedly and became visible through league tables.
  • 1Name the framing as a moral panic that turned girls' success into boys' failure.
  • 1Point out what categorical comparison hides: class, poverty, race and special educational need within each group.
  • 1Note what the framing sidelines, such as harassment, homophobia and gendered subject choice.
The statistic is real, but treating it as a crisis of boys reproduces a discourse that hides differences within each gender group and sidelines other gender inequalities. A better strategy would examine which boys and which girls are disadvantaged, and why.
Sia tip — Ask which boys before accepting any claim about boys; the class and ethnicity gaps inside each group are wider than the gap between them.
Glossary

Key terms

Gender performativity
Butler's idea that gender is produced through repeated acts rather than expressing a fixed inner identity.
Moral panic
A wave of public alarm that frames a group or trend as a threat, as with failing boys.
Intersectionality
The idea that identities such as gender, class and race interlock and mutually shape inequality.
FAQ

Gender, Feminism and the Failing Boys Debate FAQ

What is the difference between sex and gender?

In the module's account, sex refers to biological differences between male and female, while gender refers to the socio-cultural rules of masculinity and femininity built on them. Gender is relational, since each is defined against the other. The idea of doing gender then questions a strict split, because gendered identities are produced through repeated embodied actions.

Why do sociologists call the failing boys debate a moral panic?

From the mid-1990s, girls' rising results were reframed in public debate as boys' failure, which Epstein and colleagues called a moral panic. Sociologists criticise the framing because it compares gender groups without considering class, poverty, race or special educational need, and because it diverts attention and funding from other gender issues in schools.

What does hegemonic masculinity mean?

Connell developed the idea from patriarchy, a system in which power is held mainly by men, into a theory of gender relations. Hegemonic masculinity is the dominant form of masculinity in a setting, and gender inequality works as an organised field of practice through which women and subordinated masculinities are held below the dominant form.

Which readings support the gender session?

The key reading is Wingrave's article on perceptions of gender in the early years, published in Gender and Education, read alongside the gender section of Bartlett and Burton's chapter on social factors, gender, ethnicity and achievement. Students write their own abstract of each, answer the reading questions and bring their notes to the seminar discussion.

Study strategy

Exam move

Make a timeline of gender concerns in English education with four markers: feminist concern for girls in the 1970s and early 1980s, the 1988 National Curriculum and league tables, the moral panic over boys from the mid-1990s, and the continuing attainment debate. Beside each marker, write which concept helps explain it.

Then practise defining the core vocabulary without notes: sex, gender, doing gender, masculinities, discourse, discursive formation and hegemonic masculinity. For each, write a sentence that shows the concept working on a school example, because definitions alone earn little.

Read Wingrave's study with the reading questions and identify which concept the author leans on and what evidence supports it, then read the gender section of Bartlett and Burton for the wider achievement debate. Finally, practise the intersectional move: take any statement about boys or girls and rewrite it to name the class or ethnic group the evidence actually concerns.

That single habit protects you from the most common weakness in gender essays, which is treating each sex as one undivided group.

Working through Gender, Feminism and the Failing Boys Debate in EDPS0004? Sia is AskSia’s AI Education tutor — ask any EDPS0004 Gender, Feminism and the Failing Boys Debate question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how EDPS0004 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 32 of your subjects at University College London, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your EDPS0004 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 4-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works