University College London · FACULTY OF EDUCATION

EDPS0004 Chap.3 Reproduction, Setting and Symbolic Violence

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
7 Chapters4-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 3 of 9 · EDPS0004

Reproduction, Setting and Symbolic Violence

Reproduction, Setting and Symbolic Violence asks how schools can maintain inequality while appearing fair. It opens with Jencks's five answers to whom a teacher must treat equally, distinguishing equality from equity, and with funding tools such as the Pupil Premium and SEND support. Bourdieu's account of social reproduction explains how schools reward capitals that families pass on unequally.

Research on attainment grouping then shows disadvantaged students concentrated in low sets, no overall attainment benefit and systematic misallocation by ethnicity and gender.

Symbolic violence names the mechanism by which an arbitrary culture is imposed and accepted as natural, illustrated by guest research on students who narrowly missed grammar school places and by Archer and colleagues' analysis of students' views of setting.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Jencks and the meaning of equal opportunity

  • 02

    Equality, equity and the Pupil Premium

  • 03

    Bourdieu's theory of social reproduction

  • 04

    Setting, streaming and tracking

  • 05

    Misallocation to sets by ethnicity and gender

  • 06

    Self-fulfilling prophecy and student confidence

  • 07

    Symbolic violence in selective education

Worked example · free

Use symbolic violence on a selective test

Q [4 marks]. A student who narrowly missed the mark for a grammar school place says she should simply have worked harder. Explain her response using symbolic violence. The mark allocation shown is AskSia's own practice weighting, not a published university scheme.
Symbolic violence as a closed loop.Symbolic violence as a closed loop. Start at the top box: one group's culture is imposed as the standard, it comes to look natural, those who fall short blame themselves, and that acceptance keeps the original arrangement in place.cultural arbitrary imposedseen as naturalblame taken personallyorder reproduced
Symbolic violence as a closed loop. Start at the top box: one group's culture is imposed as the standard, it comes to look natural, those who fall short blame themselves, and that acceptance keeps the original arrangement in place.
  • 1Define symbolic violence as an arbitrary culture imposed as the standard and misrecognised as natural.
  • 1Identify the arbitrary element: one test is treated as the measure of academic worth.
  • 1Explain her self-blame as misrecognition, accepting individual responsibility for a structural outcome.
  • 1State the consequence: acceptance keeps the selective system unquestioned and in place.
Her response shows symbolic violence at work. The test is an arbitrary measure presented as natural, and by blaming herself she accepts that arrangement, which helps it continue without challenge.
Sia tip — Name what is arbitrary before you name the violence; without the arbitrary element the concept has nothing to explain.
Glossary

Key terms

Social reproduction
The process by which education passes on existing class positions from one generation to the next.
Misallocation
Placement of a student in a set higher or lower than their prior attainment would predict.
Pupil Premium
Additional school funding for pupils eligible for free school meals or in local authority care.
FAQ

Reproduction, Setting and Symbolic Violence FAQ

Does setting by ability raise attainment?

The research presented in the module finds no significant overall benefit for attainment grouping. Students in lower sets make poorer progress, and disadvantaged students are concentrated there, so segregation by ability within schools can widen wider social inequalities. The researchers recommend minimising between-class grouping and supporting good practice in mixed attainment teaching.

What is the difference between equality and equity?

Equality treats everyone the same, as when a teacher gives each pupil equal time. Equity directs extra resources to those who have received less, as when funding follows disadvantaged pupils. Jencks shows that several competing definitions of fairness can all sound reasonable, so an essay must state which one it is using.

Why do students accept setting if it harms them?

Archer and colleagues report that most students accept setting as legitimate. Symbolic violence explains this: the practice is presented as a neutral reflection of ability, so its arbitrary basis is misrecognised as natural. Students then read low placement as a verdict on themselves, which protects the practice from challenge.

What does misallocation to sets mean?

Misallocation means a student is placed in a set higher or lower than their prior attainment would predict. The grouping research found Black students 2.54 times as likely as White students to be placed in a lower maths set than warranted, and girls 1.55 times as likely as boys, which suggests that placement reflects more than measured ability.

Study strategy

Exam move

Start by writing Jencks's five positions on a single card, each with one sentence on what it would mean for a real classroom decision, and practise identifying which position a policy such as the Pupil Premium most resembles. Next, learn the grouping evidence precisely: the four background findings, the misallocation odds for Black students, Asian students and girls in maths, and the study's implications.

Precision matters because the review essay rewards accurate description, and a reversed direction, such as saying White students were more often misallocated downward, would undermine the paragraph. Then connect the evidence to theory by writing one paragraph that uses social reproduction and one that uses symbolic violence on the same finding, and compare what each adds.

For the key reading by Archer and colleagues, answer the questions on critical theory, mixed methods and why students accept setting, and note which method produced which finding. Finally, reflect on your own schooling as the last reading question asks, but practise turning that reflection into an argument supported by the study rather than leaving it as anecdote.

Working through Reproduction, Setting and Symbolic Violence in EDPS0004? Sia is AskSia’s AI Education tutor — ask any EDPS0004 Reproduction, Setting and Symbolic Violence question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how EDPS0004 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 32 of your subjects at University College London, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your EDPS0004 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 4-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works