PHYS7470 Chap.8 Economic Evaluation of Energy Measures
Economic Evaluation of Energy Measures
The timeline is the calculation specification
Engineering economics places project costs, savings, maintenance and salvage on a common time basis. Draw the initial investment at time zero, place recurring flows at the periods when they occur and show terminal value only at the project end. Direction records whether each amount is a cost or benefit.
An annuity factor assumes equal flows at a stated timing, so the cash-flow diagram must be fixed before a factor is selected. Moving a saving by one period changes its present value.
Dollar basis and rate must agree
Current-dollar cash flows include inflation and pair with a market interest rate, while constant-dollar cash flows exclude general inflation and pair with a real rate.
Mixing the bases distorts value even when every individual formula is typed correctly. Record the price basis, study period and rate beside the timeline.
When the question supplies a convention connecting market, inflation and real rates, use that relationship rather than substituting an informal subtraction.
Each method answers a different question
Simple payback screens how quickly initial cost is recovered but ignores time value, later flows and salvage. Net present value tests value at a required rate on a common study basis.
Internal rate of return expresses a return percentage but can mislead comparisons. Equivalent annual annuity helps compare repeatable alternatives with different lives.
Benefit-cost ratio depends on a clear numerator and denominator, while life-cycle cost selects the lowest comparable present cost for equal-service options.
Economics follows verified technical savings
A positive spreadsheet result cannot repair a saving estimate without a measured baseline, operating condition or service requirement.
Define equal service, establish the technical change and then build the cash flow. Capital, maintenance, incentives, taxes, depreciation and salvage enter only when supplied or supported. Finish every calculation with the decision rule in words and one limitation, such as dependence on the stated life, rate, timing or repeatability assumption.
What this chapter covers
- 01
Cash-flow diagram
- 02
Time value
- 03
Simple payback
- 04
Net present value
- 05
Equivalent annual annuity
- 06
Life-cycle cost
Worked example · free
Discount annual savings
- 4Find present worth of the saving annuity.
- 3Subtract cost and apply the NPV rule.
Key terms
- Net Present Value
- Present benefits minus present costs at a stated rate.
- Equivalent Annual Annuity
- An annualised value used to compare different project lives.
- Life-cycle Cost
- The present value of capital, operation, maintenance, replacement and terminal cash flows over a common study basis, used to select the lowest comparable cost among alternatives delivering the same required service under stated operating conditions.
Economic Evaluation of Energy Measures FAQ
Why is payback only a screen?
It ignores time value, cash flows after payback, project life and salvage. It can rank recovery speed as a screen, but it cannot replace a full economic comparison. A shorter payback can still accompany a lower NPV. State the omitted cash-flow features whenever the screen is reported.
When is EAA useful?
Equivalent annual annuity helps compare alternatives with different lives when their cash flows use a consistent rate, service requirement and repeatable basis. It converts present value to an annual equivalent. The repeatability assumption should be stated rather than left implicit.
How does life-cycle cost choose?
For alternatives delivering the same service on the same study period and rate basis, the lowest comparable present life-cycle cost is preferred. Unequal service must be corrected before applying that rule. Record maintenance, replacement and terminal value on their actual dates.
Exam move
Draw time zero, annual flows and terminal value before choosing any factor. Label signs, timing, current or constant dollars, study life and discount rate. Select the method that matches the alternatives, then recompute the present values independently. Finish with the decision rule in words and one limitation.
If the projects have different lives, test whether EAA or a common repeatable period is required before comparing them. Build a method table that links payback to recovery speed, NPV to value at the required rate, EAA to unequal lives and life-cycle cost to equal-service cost alternatives. Work one case in which the shorter payback has the lower NPV so the screen and decision do not become synonyms.
Check whether savings occur immediately or at each period end before using an annuity factor. Keep salvage at the terminal date and maintenance as its own cost stream. Where tax, depreciation or incentives are absent, do not invent them. A complete final sentence states the chosen alternative, the rule that supports it and the assumptions on service, life, rate and timing that could change the result.
Working through Economic Evaluation of Energy Measures in PHYS7470? Sia is AskSia’s AI Physics tutor — ask any PHYS7470 Economic Evaluation of Energy Measures question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how PHYS7470 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.