GLAS7999 Capstone Seminar: East Asia
GLAS7999 Overview
- The University of Hong Kong
- First Semester 2026-27
- Postgraduate
- Year-long capstone
- Prospectus first semester
What the capstone asks you to build
GLAS7999 is organised around a year-long independent research project in East Asian studies. The first-semester schedule moves toward a prospectus, while the second-semester goal is the final thesis. That structure means the early work is not preliminary in the sense of being disposable.
- Assessed by Participation, two oral presentations, scheduled assignments, a prospectus and the final project.
- Semester goal Turn an answerable East Asia research question into a coherent and defensible prospectus.
- Hardest step Keeping question, evidence, method, spatial frame and ethical limits aligned after each revision.
- Where to confirm Submission settings and task details are controlled by the course Moodle page.
What you get in the full GLAS7999 Study & Assessment Guide
- 10 chapters, 45 pages — every assessed topic
- 26 original practice questions, each with a model answer
- 10 worked examples, solved the way GLAS7999 marks
- 15 computed figures, redrawn from the course’s own numbers
- Before-you-submit checklist for the Project (35%) — what markers reward, what costs marks
Free on this page: assessment table, chapter map, one worked example, key terms, FAQ. The rest is in the full study & assessment guide.
How GLAS7999 is assessed
| Component | Weight | Format |
|---|---|---|
| Participation | 25% | In-class participation, discussion and group-writing sessions |
| Presentation | 30% | Two oral presentations, one per semester, 15% each |
| Assignment | 10% | Assignments listed in the semester schedule |
| Project | 35% | Prospectus 10%; final project 25% |
The published syllabus assigns 25% to participation, 30% to two oral presentations, 10% to assignments and 35% to the project, split into a 10% prospectus and 25% final project. The four top-level rows total 100%; confirm submission settings and the allocation of the scheduled exercises on Moodle.
Assessment structure
Segment widths reproduce the published component weights and total 100%.
What other students are asking about GLAS7999
- Where can I find lecture notes or study guides for GLAS7999 at HKU?
- The GLAS7999 study guide in AskSia Library covers Capstone Seminar: East Asia in 10 chapters, with the assessment table, a chapter-by-chapter topic map, key terms and a worked example, free to read on this page.
- Is there a final exam in GLAS7999?
- No final exam is listed in the offering this AskSia Library guide is built from; GLAS7999 is assessed by Participation 25%, Presentation 30%, Assignment 10%, Project 35%.
- What does GLAS7999 cover on diagnose scope and hidden assumptions?
- In AskSia Library's GLAS7999 guide, the Diagnose Scope and Hidden Assumptions chapter explains collective nouns and causal verbs · contrary findings · access and inference limits.
- What does GLAS7999 cover on build a search and source strategy?
- In AskSia Library's GLAS7999 guide, the Build a Search and Source Strategy chapter explains concept combinations · citation trails · direct, theoretical, contextual and methodological roles.
- What does GLAS7999 cover on read arguments, evidence and method?
- In AskSia Library's GLAS7999 guide, the Read Arguments, Evidence and Method chapter explains question, claim, evidence and method · humanities and social-science reading routes · consequential limits.
Current GLAS7999 dates
| Date | Item | Control |
|---|---|---|
| 16 September 2026 | Gordon and Weisenfeld essay | Due at 2pm in the published semester schedule. |
| 23 September 2026 | Annotated bibliography preparation | Upload by 2pm in the published semester schedule. |
| 30 September 2026 | State-of-the-field essay | Upload by 2pm in the published semester schedule. |
| 16 October 2026 | Research topic, questions and bibliography | Final version due at 5pm in the published semester schedule. |
| 4 November 2026 | Prospectus | Due in class and on Moodle by 2pm in the published semester schedule. |
Dates are as published in the published 2026 semester schedule. Confirm exact deadlines and submission settings in the live LMS.
What GLAS7999 covers
Ten chapters follow the first-semester research pathway from question design and source strategy through field mapping, transwar and transnational analysis, ethics, prospectus assembly and oral defence.
From Topic to Researchable Question
relevance, originality and rigour · non-binary wording · scope and method alignmentTurn interest into an answerable relation
A topic identifies an area; a research question identifies an object, relation and boundary that evidence can address. This chapter joins relevance, originality and rigour to practical scope.
- Topic against research question
- Relevance, originality and rigour
- Object, relation and boundary
- Binary-question repair
- Method alignment
- Contrary-finding test
Diagnose Scope and Hidden Assumptions
collective nouns and causal verbs · contrary findings · access and inference limitsRead the wording as a chain of commitments
A question can look precise while hiding an impossible causal claim, a collective subject or a value judgment already treated as fact.
- Collective-noun audit
- Causal-verb burden
- Contrary-finding test
- Evidence mismatch
- Feasibility constraints
- Inference boundary
Build a Search and Source Strategy
concept combinations · citation trails · direct, theoretical, contextual and methodological rolesSearch in loops and select by function
The course treats searching as movement between concepts, results, bibliographies and a revised question.
- Concept matrix
- Multilingual search terms
- Database passes
- Citation chaining
- Keep or reject record
- Five source functions
Read Arguments, Evidence and Method
question, claim, evidence and method · humanities and social-science reading routes · consequential limitsRecover the chain before judging it
Capstone reading requires more than topic notes. This chapter reconstructs a source through question, claim, evidence, method, contribution and limit.
- Question and central claim
- Evidence against method
- Humanities reading route
- Social-science reading route
- Contribution as contrast
- Consequential limitation
Write an Annotated Bibliography
summary, evaluation and relevance · source-purpose judgment · project-use statementsSummary, evaluation and relevance perform different jobs
An annotation begins with a checked citation and then reconstructs what the source argues, judges how its evidence and method fit that purpose, and assigns a concrete use in the project.
- Citation accuracy
- Argument summary
- Purpose-based evaluation
- Project relevance
- Independent paraphrase
- Source-role tag
Map a State of the Field
field boundaries and periodisation · cross-source themes and debates · defensible positioningChange the unit from sources to relationships
A state-of-the-field analysis explains how scholarship defines its object, chooses boundaries and organises disagreement.
- Operational field boundary
- Cross-source matrix
- Themes and debates
- Methodological split
- Gap-claim repair
- Project intervention
Compare Transwar Arguments
continuity across rupture · carriers and changing functions · evidence at comparable scalesTest continuity across a historical rupture
The paired transwar readings ask how arguments cross a conventional prewar and postwar boundary.
- Periodisation against chronology
- Continuity carrier
- Changed function
- Comparative hinge
- Evidence-scale match
- Relational conclusion
Choose National or Transnational Frames
national, comparative, imperial and relational frames · mobility, institutions and unequal powerLet the problem decide the spatial frame
National, comparative, imperial and transnational approaches create different objects and evidence requirements.
- National container
- Comparative independence
- Imperial hierarchy
- Relational movement
- Institutional mediation
- Power and local specificity
Design an Ethical Research Project
human participants and human data · consent, risk and withdrawal · early approval planningStart with the human relationship
Research ethics begins when the method is designed, especially where a project involves participants or data about people.
- Human-subject trigger
- Early consultation
- Recruitment power
- Consent fit
- Data minimisation
- Withdrawal and publication
Assemble and Defend the Prospectus
question-to-method coherence · contribution without predicted findings · peer review and oral defenceMake the design a reversible chain
The prospectus connects question, field position, sources, method, ethics, feasibility, limits and contribution.
- Question-to-method chain
- Field intervention
- Evidence and method fit
- Feasibility timeline
- Contribution without prediction
- Oral defence
Research questions, source choices, annotated bibliography entries, field mapping, peer review and presentations all create the logic that the later dissertation will either inherit or have to revise.
This guide follows that first-semester pathway and treats every task as a research decision that should remain visible and open to challenge.
From a topic to an answerable question
The opening chapters separate an area of interest from a question that evidence can answer. A strong question is relevant, original and rigorous, but these qualities are connected rather than decorative labels.
Scope must fit the time, language, access and method available. Binary wording, collective nouns and causal verbs can decide the answer or demand evidence the project cannot gather.
The practical test is whether the object, relation, boundary and possible counter-finding can be stated clearly, and whether the rest of the design changes when the question changes.
Searching and reading by function
The course teaches search as an iterative loop.
Central concepts generate term combinations; results supply new vocabulary; bibliographies reveal earlier work; later citations expose responses; and those discoveries return to revise the question. Sources then need jobs. Some study the same object, some provide theory, some supply historical context, some model a method and some place the project in a larger debate.
Reading by function prevents a bibliography from becoming a stack of similar case studies and makes each citation accountable to a decision in the prospectus.
Annotations become synthesis
An annotated bibliography entry contains a citation followed by summary, evaluation and relevance. Summary reconstructs the question, argument, evidence and method.
Evaluation judges the design in relation to what the source is trying to do rather than searching mechanically for a fault. Relevance explains what the source can do for the project and where transfer stops.
A state-of-the-field map changes the unit of analysis from one source to relationships across sources: themes, disputes, shared assumptions, methods, boundaries and gaps between conversations.
Transwar and transnational approaches
The semester uses transwar comparison to test period boundaries and asks how continuity operates across political rupture.
The important question is what carries the continuity, how its function changes and what evidence demonstrates the bridge. The transnational unit similarly begins with relationships, movement and institutions rather than treating nations as naturally bounded cases. Critical analysis asks what moves, who makes it move, who cannot move, which institutions control the route and how colonial or market power shapes the exchange.
National, comparative, imperial and transnational frames remain choices with different strengths and blind spots.
Ethics is part of the design
Projects involving people or data about people require early advice and careful planning. Consent, recruitment, confidentiality, storage, withdrawal and publication risk have to match the actual method.
Public availability does not settle ethical use when materials can expose identifiable people or reach a new audience.
Even where formal review is not triggered, the prospectus should show how harm is minimised and why the evidence collected is necessary for the question.
Assembling and defending the prospectus
The finished prospectus is a chain of choices: question, field position, source plan, method, ethics, feasibility, limits and contribution. Read those choices as one paragraph before polishing sections.
An oral presentation should defend why this design fits the problem better than the main alternative and should name what evidence or constraint would trigger revision.
A precise concession about what the project cannot claim is stronger than a vague promise to cover everything later.
How to practise with this guide
Each chapter contains an original worked example and practice cards whose answers sit inside the item. Cover the answer, write your own response and compare decisions rather than sentences.
The final integrated practice repairs one prospectus from an impossible regional project into a feasible comparative design. No practice item is University assessment material, and any study allocation in the guide is authored by AskSia rather than drawn from a University marking scheme.
Worked example · free
Turn a broad East Asia topic into an answerable question
- 2Identify the claims that the current wording cannot support.
- 3Choose an observable object and a defensible comparison.
- 3Write the revised question and its explicit inference limit.
Key terms
- Research Question
- An answerable inquiry that identifies a relation or change, a bounded object and evidence capable of supporting more than one finding.
- Research Problem
- The underlying intellectual concern that connects several questions and explains why answering them matters.
- Scope
- The deliberate boundary placed around object, period, place, evidence and claim so the project remains answerable.
- Primary Source
- Material treated as evidence in relation to a particular research question rather than a permanently fixed class of object.
- Source Function
- The specific job a source performs as direct evidence, theory, context, method or participation in a broader debate.
- Annotation
- A citation followed by concise summary, evaluation and explanation of a source's relevance to the project.
- Literature Review
- A synthesis organised around relationships, themes, debates or problems across sources rather than one source at a time.
- State of the Field
- An account of how scholarship defines its object, organises disagreement and establishes strengths, limits and openings.
- Periodisation
- An explanatory division of time that claims a historical break changes the best account of events or processes.
- Transwar
- An approach that tests continuity and transformation across war and defeat instead of assuming a clean prewar and postwar break.
- Critical Transnationalism
- Relational analysis that tracks movement while keeping institutions, colonial history, inequality and local specificity in view.
- Inference Boundary
- The point beyond which the project's evidence and method do not justify a stronger or broader conclusion.
GLAS7999 FAQ
How is this capstone assessed?
The published syllabus assigns 25% to participation, 30% to two oral presentations, 10% to assignments and 35% to the project. The project row is divided into a 10% prospectus and 25% final project. The early exercises support the first-semester prospectus, while exact submission settings and task-level details should be checked on Moodle.
What makes a research question manageable?
A manageable question names an observable object, a relation or change, and boundaries that fit the available time, language, access and method. It stays open to contrary findings and uses a verb the proposed evidence can support. Adding more place names or dates is not enough if the project still lacks a clear operation or stopping rule.
What belongs in an annotated bibliography entry?
Begin with the full citation, then reconstruct the source's question, argument, evidence and method. Evaluate the fit between its purpose and design, and finish by naming the source's job in your project. Relevance should guide a later decision; saying that a source is interesting, reliable or related to the topic does not perform that work.
How is a literature review different from annotations?
Annotations help you understand sources one by one through summary, evaluation and relevance. A literature review changes the unit of analysis to relationships across sources. It groups scholarship by themes, debates, methods, periodisations or shared assumptions and uses those relationships to position the project rather than presenting a sequence of separate summaries.
When should I use a transnational frame?
Use it when the object is produced through movement, networks or relationships crossing national boundaries and you can trace the actors and institutions that make those connections possible. Similarity between national cases is not enough. A critical transnational design also asks who controls movement, who benefits, who cannot move and which colonial or market inequalities structure the exchange.
When do I need to think about research ethics?
Think about ethics as soon as the method involves people or data about identifiable people. Recruitment, consent, confidentiality, storage, withdrawal and publication risk must match the actual design. Public availability does not automatically settle ethical use. Seek advice early when review status is uncertain, because approval and access requirements can change the question, timeline and evidence plan.
What should the prospectus prove?
The prospectus should prove that the project is coherent and feasible, not that its final conclusion is already known. It connects an answerable question to a field position, source plan, method, ethics analysis, timeline, limits and expected contribution. A strong contribution remains worthwhile under more than one possible finding and names what the project changes in an existing scholarly conversation.
How should I prepare for the oral presentation?
Prepare to defend decisions rather than recite sections. For each major choice, state what the project needs, why the selected option fits better than the main alternative, and what evidence or constraint would trigger revision. Also practise one precise concession about what the design cannot claim; a controlled boundary is more persuasive than a vague promise to cover everything later.
Questions students ask in each GLAS7999 chapter
- Why avoid yes or no research questions?
- Binary wording pushes a complex inquiry toward a verdict and often hides the mechanism the project should explain. Reframe the question around how, through what relation, or under which conditions a change occurs, while keeping the possibility of more than one finding. Chapter 01 · From Topic to Researchable Question
- How do I find a hidden assumption?
- Write a plausible contrary finding. If the question collapses when the expected relation disappears, its wording has made that relation compulsory. Also replace loaded adjectives with neutral descriptions and inspect whether the research interest survives. Chapter 02 · Diagnose Scope and Hidden Assumptions
- How many search terms should I use at once?
- Combine one term from different concept columns and vary them systematically. Putting every synonym, place and period into one query can produce no results without showing which concept blocked discovery. Chapter 03 · Build a Search and Source Strategy
- What is the difference between evidence and method?
- Evidence names the materials that bear on a claim, while method names the operation used to interpret, compare or analyse them. Archive, interview and film are materials; close reading, thematic coding and comparison are operations. Chapter 04 · Read Arguments, Evidence and Method
- Does evaluation mean finding a weakness?
- No. Evaluation judges a source against what it tries to do. A feature may be a strength for one inference and a limit for another, so explain the consequence rather than searching mechanically for a fault. Chapter 05 · Write an Annotated Bibliography
- How should I define a field?
- Use an operational principle such as object, region, period, method or problem, then explain what the boundary makes central and what it risks excluding. A label alone does not establish the field. Chapter 06 · Map a State of the Field
- Does transwar mean nothing changed after the war?
- No. It tests a clean rupture by tracing continuities through transformation. Institutions, practices or forms can survive while their political roles, audiences and meanings change substantially. Chapter 07 · Compare Transwar Arguments
- Is transnational always better than national?
- No. National institutions may be the correct unit when law, archives or policy operate through the state. Choose the frame that can answer the question and state the relationships it reveals and suppresses. Chapter 08 · Choose National or Transnational Frames
- Do public online posts remove ethics concerns?
- No. Searchability, political sensitivity, platform expectations and re-identification can create harm when material is quoted or moved to a new audience. Assess whether paraphrase, aggregation or omission is needed. Chapter 09 · Design an Ethical Research Project
- What should the prospectus establish?
- It should establish that the project is coherent and feasible, not that the final conclusion is already known. Every section should answer the same research problem and acknowledge its inference limits. Chapter 10 · Assemble and Defend the Prospectus
How to prepare for the assessments
Carry one provisional project through every chapter. Keep a live decision sheet with six headings: question, field relation, sources, method, ethics and limits. After each reading or workshop, update the decision that changed and the evidence that changed it. Practise by covering each model answer and writing your own before comparing the reasoning.
Once a week, read the six headings as one paragraph and look for shifts in the object or main verb. Before the prospectus presentation, rehearse the strongest objection to scope, case selection, evidence and method, then answer with the decision, its boundary and the condition that would make you revise it.