GLAS7999 Chap.9 Design an Ethical Research Project
Design an Ethical Research Project
Start with the human relationship
Research ethics begins when the method is designed, especially where a project involves participants or data about people. This chapter maps recruitment, consent, confidentiality, storage, withdrawal and publication risk onto the actual research relationship.
It distinguishes formal approval from ethical judgment, treats public availability as insufficient by itself, and shows how translation, gatekeepers and re-identification can change the method and timeline.
Map participation and human data
Identify direct participation through interviews, observation or surveys, then identify indirect use of records, images, online traces and datasets about people.
Public access does not settle responsible use. Consider the context in which information was shared, whether combinations can identify a person, and whether research publication creates a new audience or harm. Where participants or human-subject data may be involved, the course materials emphasise early consultation.
Uncertainty should therefore change the schedule and prompt advice before recruitment or collection, not after the method has been fixed.
Separate review from judgment
An institutional process determines whether formal review applies and under what conditions work may proceed. Ethical judgment asks broader questions about necessity, proportionality, consent, burden, confidentiality and benefit.
A project can sit outside a formal pathway and still expose a community or reproduce an extractive relationship. Conversely, approval does not remove the researcher’s duty to respond when risk changes.
The prospectus should document the reasoning, the advice sought and the design choices made, rather than treating approval status as a substitute for an account of the human relationship.
Design consent around actual use
Participants need to understand the real project, what they will do, foreseeable risks, intended quotation, data access, withdrawal and publication.
A general description of culture cannot support later use of identifiable political speech or workplace-harassment accounts. Translation is part of consent because wording can alter scope, risk and withdrawal conditions. Plan who will check translated materials and resolve differences.
Consent also continues beyond a signature: new uses, unexpected sensitivity or a change from anonymous analysis to distinctive quotation may require another choice rather than reliance on the original form.
Examine recruitment power
Teachers, employers, community leaders and platform administrators can make refusal visible or costly even when participation is formally voluntary.
Ask who delivers the invitation, who knows who accepted, and what benefit or penalty a person might perceive. Reduce dependence by separating recruitment from authority, using an independent contact route, delaying access to identities or avoiding employer-mediated selection. Design for the least powerful participant, not the researcher’s idealised volunteer.
This may change the sample or access plan, but that change is part of making the evidence ethically obtainable.
Trace the complete data journey
Follow information from initial contact through collection, transfer, storage, analysis, quotation, sharing and deletion. At each stage, record identifiers, access, copies, location and retention.
Risks frequently arise between stages: a pseudonym can fail when combined with a detailed career history, and a contact list stored separately can become identifying when joined with a schedule. Collect only what answers the question. If sensitive detail is necessary, explain its analytical role and how a participant can decline it.
Data minimisation is therefore a scholarly design test as well as a security practice.
Write risks as mechanisms
A useful ethics statement names the group, possible harm, research action producing it, mitigation and residual limit. Generic promises of confidentiality hide the mechanism.
Quoting a public protest post, for example, may expose an account to a new searchable audience; paraphrase, aggregation or omitted handles may reduce but not eliminate re-identification. Connect safeguards to the specific method and keep them feasible within resources.
Ethical planning is complete only when it can change what is collected, who is approached, what is published and which claim the project is entitled to make.
What this chapter covers
- 01
Human-subject trigger
- 02
Early consultation
- 03
Recruitment power
- 04
Consent fit
- 05
Data minimisation
- 06
Withdrawal and publication
Worked example · free
Redesign risky recruitment
- 3Identify coercion and exposure risks.
- 3Change recruitment and collection.
- 2Control publication risk.
Key terms
- Informed Consent
- Voluntary agreement based on an accurate explanation of participation, use, risk and withdrawal.
- Data Minimisation
- Collecting and retaining only information necessary for the research question.
- Re-identification
- Recognition of a person through combined details despite removed direct identifiers.
Design an Ethical Research Project FAQ
Do public online posts remove ethics concerns?
No. Searchability, political sensitivity, platform expectations and re-identification can create harm when material is quoted or moved to a new audience. Assess whether paraphrase, aggregation or omission is needed.
When should I seek ethics advice?
Seek advice early when a project involves people or data about people, or when review status is uncertain. Approval and access timelines can change the question, recruitment and evidence plan.
What should an ethics section include?
Connect participants or human data to recruitment, consent where relevant, confidentiality, storage, withdrawal, publication risk, mitigation and approval status. Generic policy wording does not show that safeguards fit this project.
Assessment move
Draw the flow of people and data from recruitment through collection, storage, analysis and publication. At each stage name who has power, what harm can occur, which information is necessary and what design choice reduces risk.