The University of Hong Kong · FACULTY OF PHYSICS

PHYS2261 Chap.5 Entropy and the Second Law

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters4-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 5 of 10 · PHYS2261

Entropy and the Second Law

Reversibility is a system-plus-surroundings claim

A reversible path is quasistatic and free of dissipation, so both system and surroundings can be restored. Entropy is a state function, while entropy production diagnoses irreversible processes.

Carnot analysis supplies the reversible efficiency ceiling and fixes the relationship between reservoir heat transfers and absolute temperatures.

The key comparison

A cycle has zero system entropy change, yet friction or finite temperature differences may still create positive entropy in the universe. Those statements are compatible.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Reversible processes

  • 02

    Entropy change

  • 03

    Entropy production

  • 04

    Carnot cycle

  • 05

    Heat engines

  • 06

    Reservoir accounting

Worked example · free

Calculate entropy production

Q [8 marks]. This mark allocation supports self-checking and is not a published university assessment scheme. Two kilojoules move from 400 K to 300 K. Find the universe entropy change.
Heat enters from the hot reservoir and leaves to the cold reservoir.Heat enters from the hot reservoir and leaves to the cold reservoir. Their difference becomes work, while the temperature ratio limits reversible efficiency.A heat engine cannot turn all absorbed heat into workhot reservoir THworking substancecold reservoir TCwork WQH inQC out
Heat enters from the hot reservoir and leaves to the cold reservoir. Their difference becomes work, while the temperature ratio limits reversible efficiency.
  • 3Calculate the hot-reservoir change.
  • 3Calculate the cold-reservoir change.
  • 2Add and classify the process.
The changes are -5.00 J/K and +6.67 J/K, giving +1.67 J/K and an irreversible transfer.
Sia tip — Give each reservoir its own sign before adding.
Glossary

Key terms

Reversible Process
An ideal process that restores system and surroundings with no net change.
Entropy
A state function whose differential is heat divided by temperature on a reversible path.
Entropy Production
Positive entropy generated by irreversible change in the combined universe.
Carnot Efficiency
The reversible efficiency ceiling set by reservoir temperatures.
FAQ

Entropy and the Second Law FAQ

Does a cyclic process have zero entropy change?

The working system returns to its starting entropy because entropy is a state function. The surroundings may still gain entropy, so the cycle is not necessarily reversible and the universe entropy change need not be zero.

Why must Carnot temperatures be in Kelvin?

The efficiency and heat ratios use absolute thermodynamic temperature. Celsius intervals equal Kelvin intervals, but Celsius ratios do not express the required absolute scale and can produce impossible efficiencies.

How do I calculate entropy change for a reservoir?

A reservoir remains at constant temperature, so its entropy change is Q/T with Q signed positive into that reservoir. Include both the source and receiver before judging whether entropy was produced.

How do I distinguish entropy change, transfer and production?

Entropy is a state function, so a system's change depends only on its equilibrium endpoints and may be evaluated along a convenient reversible reference path. Entropy transfer accompanies heat at a boundary, while entropy production records irreversibility inside the complete process. Build paired ledgers: energy must balance by conservation, whereas the entropy of the combined isolated universe must be nonnegative.

Include every reservoir, frictional element and mixing body inside that universe boundary before drawing a conclusion. A cyclic device has zero net system entropy change but may still produce entropy in its surroundings. An adiabatic process has no entropy transfer through heat but can produce entropy through free expansion, viscosity or friction. Use Kelvin in every temperature denominator and ratio.

For ideal-gas changes, keep logarithm arguments dimensionless and check extensivity. A negative universe total signals a missing subsystem or sign error; zero identifies the reversible limit only after the boundary is complete.

Study strategy

Exam move

Practise paired ledgers: energy for the system and entropy for system plus surroundings. Work one hot-to-cold transfer, one heating problem and one cyclic-engine judgement. For every answer, state whether the reported entropy is a state change or entropy production, and convert all temperatures to Kelvin before using ratios.

Begin by separating three ideas on paper: entropy of a state, entropy transferred with reversible heat, and entropy produced by irreversibility. Use a closed cycle to show why the system entropy can return to its initial value while the universe entropy increases. Then take a finite hot-to-cold transfer and calculate the two reservoir changes with signs before adding them.

Change the temperature gap and observe how production tends toward zero as the reservoirs approach equal temperature. Follow with a sensible-heating calculation using an integral of heat capacity divided by temperature. If a phase transition is crossed, insert the latent-heat contribution at its transition temperature rather than smoothing it into the heat-capacity integral.

Recompute the same endpoint entropy along a convenient reversible reference path and explain why that does not make the actual process reversible. For heat engines, draw arrows for hot-side heat, cold-side rejection and work output. Derive the Carnot efficiency from absolute reservoir temperatures and state that it is a ceiling.

Compare an irreversible engine operating between the same reservoirs and explain which entropy production prevents it from reaching the ceiling. Add a refrigerator problem and keep coefficient of performance distinct from efficiency; a value above one is possible because the numerator is heat moved, not work produced. Make Kelvin conversion the first line whenever a ratio or entropy denominator appears.

Check an answer by asking whether the combined isolated universe entropy is nonnegative. A negative result should trigger a search for a missing reservoir, reversed heat sign or incomplete boundary. Keep a misconception list with short corrections: quasistatic is not automatically reversible, zero system entropy change is not zero production, and a cyclic process is not necessarily reversible.

Finish by writing a one-paragraph explanation of why an engine must reject heat. If that explanation uses only energy conservation, revisit the second-law constraint until the entropy argument is explicit.

Working through Entropy and the Second Law in PHYS2261? Sia is AskSia’s AI Physics tutor — ask any PHYS2261 Entropy and the Second Law question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how PHYS2261 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 52 of your subjects at The University of Hong Kong, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your PHYS2261 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 4-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works