The University of Hong Kong · FACULTY OF PHYSICS

PHYS2261 Chap.7 Equilibrium and Stability

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters3-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 7 of 10 · PHYS2261

Equilibrium and Stability

Constraint-specific extrema

An isolated system approaches maximum entropy, while systems under other controls minimise the appropriate thermodynamic potential. A zero first variation locates a stationary state; the second variation distinguishes a stable maximum or minimum from an unstable one.

Exchange between subsystems then derives equality of temperature, pressure or chemical potential.

Calculation pattern

Use whole-system conservation to determine the numerical equilibrium and the variational condition to identify what becomes equal. Neither step replaces the other.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Entropy maximum

  • 02

    Energy minimum

  • 03

    Helmholtz minimum

  • 04

    Gibbs minimum

  • 05

    Second variation

  • 06

    Exchange equilibrium

Worked example · free

Find a common equilibrium temperature

Q [8 marks]. Marks shown indicate revision steps only and are not a university assessment scheme. Bodies with heat capacities 200 and 300 J/K begin at 360 and 300 K inside an insulated boundary. Find Tf.
The red point is stable because it is the bottom of the allowed Gibbs-energy well.The red point is stable because it is the bottom of the allowed Gibbs-energy well. Zero slope locates equilibrium, while positive curvature supplies stability.Stable equilibrium is a constrained minimumdG=0d²G>0allowed coordinateG at fixed T,p
The red point is stable because it is the bottom of the allowed Gibbs-energy well. Zero slope locates equilibrium, while positive curvature supplies stability.
  • 3Write the outer-boundary energy balance.
  • 3Use the common final temperature.
  • 2Check the result against the initial range.
Solving 200(Tf-360)+300(Tf-300)=0 gives Tf=324 K.
Sia tip — Conservation gives the value; entropy maximisation gives the equality condition.
Glossary

Key terms

Stationary State
A state where the first variation of the controlling function is zero.
Stable Equilibrium
A stationary state that resists small allowed fluctuations.
Second Variation
The curvature test that classifies a stationary point.
Exchange Variable
An extensive quantity allowed to move between coupled subsystems.
FAQ

Equilibrium and Stability FAQ

Is every stationary thermodynamic state stable?

No. A zero first derivative can describe a maximum, minimum or saddle point. Stability requires the correct curvature: a maximum for entropy under isolation or a minimum for the appropriate potential under its controlled variables.

Why do temperatures equalise at thermal equilibrium?

An infinitesimal energy transfer changes total entropy by a coefficient involving the difference of inverse temperatures. Entropy is stationary only when those coefficients match, which gives equal temperatures.

How do conservation and equilibrium conditions differ?

The equilibrium condition states which intensive variables become equal when an exchange is allowed. Conservation fixes the total extensive quantity and therefore determines the numerical common state once material relations are supplied.

How do I prove that a candidate equilibrium is stable?

First identify the outer boundary, conserved totals and exchanges allowed by the internal walls. Choose the controlling total entropy or thermodynamic potential that matches those constraints. Vary one independent exchange at a time: energy transfer leads to a temperature condition, volume transfer to pressure equality and particle transfer to chemical-potential equality.

A vanishing first derivative establishes only stationarity. Examine the second variation or curvature in every allowed direction to decide whether total entropy has a maximum or the relevant potential has a minimum. Positive local curvature of a potential supports local stability but does not exclude a deeper minimum beyond a barrier; such a state is metastable rather than globally stable.

Use conservation equations to calculate the numerical common state and check that it lies within physical bounds set by the initial conditions. Finally perturb the candidate slightly and ask whether the controlling function moves back toward its optimum. State whether the conclusion is local, global or merely constrained by a wall that blocks another exchange.

Study strategy

Exam move

For each constraint set, name the potential and whether it is minimised or maximised. Sketch a stable and unstable stationary point, then derive one exchange equality from an additive total function. In numerical problems, write conservation before applying the common final temperature or pressure.

Build a four-row stability chart that pairs isolation with maximum entropy, fixed entropy with minimum energy, fixed temperature and volume with minimum Helmholtz free energy, and fixed temperature and pressure with minimum Gibbs free energy. For each row, draw a curve with both a stable and unstable stationary point. Mark the first derivative as zero at both and use the curvature sign to distinguish them.

Add a second, deeper minimum separated by a barrier to represent metastability, and explain why local curvature does not establish global equilibrium. Next, derive equilibrium conditions from permitted exchanges. Begin with two subsystems inside an isolated outer boundary. Allow only energy transfer and vary total entropy under fixed total energy to obtain equal temperature.

Add a movable wall and repeat for volume transfer to obtain equal pressure. Add particle permeability and identify chemical-potential equality. Then remove one permeability and state which equality no longer follows. In numerical work, separate the value problem from the equilibrium condition. The common final temperature or pressure describes equilibrium, while conservation of total energy or volume determines its value.

Solve a two-body heat-capacity problem and verify that the final temperature lies between the initial values and closer to the body with larger heat capacity. Give an entropy sign argument for the same direction so the check does not repeat the energy algebra. Practise classifying a stationary point from second derivatives and identifying when an allowed fluctuation lowers the controlling potential.

Use words such as local minimum, constrained direction and permitted exchange precisely. Finish by taking an unfamiliar composite system and listing the outer boundary, additive total property, conserved quantities, independent exchanges and conjugate intensive variables. That sequence should produce the equilibrium equations before any material-specific equation of state is used.

Working through Equilibrium and Stability in PHYS2261? Sia is AskSia’s AI Physics tutor — ask any PHYS2261 Equilibrium and Stability question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how PHYS2261 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 52 of your subjects at The University of Hong Kong, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your PHYS2261 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 3-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works