The University of Hong Kong · FACULTY OF PHYSICS

PHYS2261 Chap.2 Systems, Zeroth Law and Temperature

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters4-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 2 of 10 · PHYS2261

Systems, Zeroth Law and Temperature

Start at the wall

A system boundary decides whether energy and matter may cross, which determines the balance terms allowed in a calculation. Isolated, closed and open systems therefore describe different ledgers rather than different-looking containers.

Equilibrium supplies stable state variables, while the zeroth law makes temperature a transitive scalar that can be measured with a third body.

Scaling properties

Intensive variables remain unchanged when equivalent systems are combined; extensive variables scale with system size. Equal temperature never implies equal internal energy.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    System boundaries

  • 02

    Isolated systems

  • 03

    Closed and open systems

  • 04

    Thermal equilibrium

  • 05

    Zeroth law

  • 06

    Intensive and extensive variables

Worked example · free

Compare temperatures through a third body

Q [6 marks]. The weighting here structures independent practice and is not an official university allocation. A and B each reach equilibrium with an unchanged body C. What follows?
Boundary permeability decides the bookkeeping.Boundary permeability decides the bookkeeping. The three boxes show whether energy and matter terms may cross an isolated, closed or open system wall.What each boundary permitsIsolatedClosedOpenno energyno matterenergy may crossmatter cannotenergy crossesmatter crossesThe wall definition determines which balance terms are allowed.
Boundary permeability decides the bookkeeping. The three boxes show whether energy and matter terms may cross an isolated, closed or open system wall.
  • 3Apply transitivity of equilibrium.
  • 2State the temperature conclusion.
  • 1Identify what does not follow about energy.
A and B are in thermal equilibrium and share temperature, but their internal energies need not be equal.
Sia tip — Use the zeroth law for temperature, not for extensive-energy claims.
Glossary

Key terms

Isolated System
A system that exchanges neither energy nor matter with its surroundings.
Closed System
A system that may exchange energy but not matter.
Open System
A system that may exchange energy and matter.
Thermal Equilibrium
A state with no net thermal flow and stable macroscopic properties.
FAQ

Systems, Zeroth Law and Temperature FAQ

Is an adiabatic system automatically isolated?

No. Adiabatic means no heat crosses the boundary. Work may still cross, and matter may cross if the system is open. Isolation is stronger because it excludes every energy and matter exchange.

What does the zeroth law establish?

It makes thermal equilibrium transitive. If two systems are each in equilibrium with a third, they are in equilibrium with each other. That supports a shared scalar temperature and the operation of a thermometer.

Can two systems have the same temperature but different energies?

Yes. Temperature is intensive while internal energy is extensive and also depends on material, phase and amount. A larger body can store more energy than a smaller one while both have the same temperature.

What full checklist should I use before writing a thermodynamic balance?

Choose the analytical system and draw its outer boundary, then add any internal partitions separately. Mark whether heat, mechanical work and particles can cross each wall, and classify the resulting system as isolated, closed or open. List the extensive totals that are conserved and the intensive coordinates that may act as driving differences.

A conducting wall can imply common temperature, a movable wall can imply common pressure and a particle-permeable wall can imply common chemical potential, but only when that exchange is actually allowed. Test scaling by imagining two identical copies: extensive quantities add, while intensive values remain unchanged.

If a thermometer is involved, distinguish the zeroth-law equilibrium relation from the separate calibration and monotonicity assumptions needed to assign numbers. Finally decide whether intermediate states are close enough to equilibrium for a path description, and whether friction or finite gradients prevent reversibility. Only after this inventory should an equation be selected.

Study strategy

Exam move

Classify the boundary of every tutorial problem before reading the requested quantity. Draw arrows for allowed heat, work and matter transfer, then label fixed walls or movable pistons. Follow with a separate list of intensive and extensive variables so equal-temperature statements are not turned into equal-energy statements. Revise this chapter with diagrams rather than a vocabulary list.

Sketch an outer system boundary and at least one internal partition. For each wall, annotate whether heat, volume displacement and particles can cross. Then state whether the system is isolated, closed or open and explain why the other two labels are unsuitable. Change one wall property at a time and rewrite the allowed balance terms.

This creates a family of related problems from one drawing and prevents boundary classifications from becoming memorised pictures. Make a second table separating intensive variables from extensive ones. Test the table by combining two identical equilibrium samples: temperature and pressure should remain unchanged, while energy, entropy, volume and particle number add.

If an equation violates that scaling, identify which variable or normalisation is wrong. For the zeroth law, practise explaining the logic with three bodies before mentioning a thermometer. State what transitivity establishes, then add the extra requirements for measurement: a reproducible thermometric property, calibration and a monotonic response over the useful range.

Work one item in which two bodies share temperature but not energy, and one in which an adiabatic system is not isolated because work crosses the boundary. Add process language only after the system is classified. Compare spontaneous, quasistatic and reversible by asking whether equilibrium states remain defined and whether system plus surroundings can be restored.

Use a friction example to show why slow motion is not sufficient for reversibility. At the end of a study session, take a coupled-subsystem problem and list the equalities implied by each permitted exchange. A conducting wall leads to common temperature, a movable wall adds common pressure, and a permeable wall adds common chemical potential. Do not impose an equality for an exchange the wall blocks.

The finished page should read like a physical inventory: boundary, permeability, controlled variables, possible transfers and equilibrium conditions. Only then should an equation be selected.

Working through Systems, Zeroth Law and Temperature in PHYS2261? Sia is AskSia’s AI Physics tutor — ask any PHYS2261 Systems, Zeroth Law and Temperature question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how PHYS2261 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 52 of your subjects at The University of Hong Kong, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your PHYS2261 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 4-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works