The University of Hong Kong · FACULTY OF MANAGEMENT

PMGM7004 Chap.3 Costs, Competitive Output and Profit

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters3-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 3 of 9 · PMGM7004

Costs, Competitive Output and Profit

Relevant cost depends on the decision date

Economic cost includes opportunity cost and excludes expenditure that cannot be recovered under any current option. Fixed and sunk are therefore not synonyms. Average costs describe the position of the firm, while marginal cost chooses the next unit.

A competitive firm takes market price as given and expands until price equals marginal cost on its rising portion, then applies the shutdown test against average variable cost. Long-run equilibrium adds entry and exit, zero economic profit and market clearing.

Classify the cost before using it

Ask whether the resource changes across the available choices and whether it can still be recovered.

A forgone alternative is an opportunity cost even if no invoice records it. An earlier payment is sunk when every current option leaves it unchanged. A fixed cost can remain avoidable at the entry stage, so fixed does not imply irrelevant.

Stating the decision date prevents the same payment from being classified once for output and differently for entry without explanation.

Use marginal cost for output and averages for viability

The next unit is worthwhile when its added revenue covers its added cost.

A competitive price-taking firm therefore chooses the rising marginal-cost point equal to price, provided operating is preferable to temporary shutdown. Average variable cost supplies that short-run comparison; average total cost determines whether economic profit is positive after all costs.

Mixing those tests can make a firm stop even though production contributes toward fixed cost, or continue even though each extra unit loses money.

Connect the firm decision back to the market

An individual competitive firm treats price as given, but the market price is determined by aggregate demand and supply.

Entry expands market supply when firms earn positive economic profit; exit contracts it when avoidable returns are insufficient. In a long-run benchmark, those movements can restore zero economic profit without implying that owners receive nothing. Their opportunity costs are included in economic cost, so zero economic profit means the next-best alternative is matched.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Opportunity and sunk costs

  • 02

    Fixed and variable costs

  • 03

    Average and marginal cost

  • 04

    Competitive output

  • 05

    Shutdown condition

  • 06

    Long-run entry and exit

Worked example · free

Choose competitive output and test shutdown

Q [9 marks]. AskSia-authored practice. The marks shown here are not an official University mark allocation. Price is 42 and total cost is C(q) = 90 + 6q + 2q squared. Find output, profit and the short-run production decision.
The marginal condition comes before the shutdown test.The marginal condition comes before the shutdown test. First locate the best positive output, then ask whether price covers average variable cost; long-run survival adds the average-total-cost condition.Choose q where P = MCP covers AVCproduce in the short runP is below AVCshut downLong run adds entry, exit and P = minimum ATC
The marginal condition comes before the shutdown test. First locate the best positive output, then ask whether price covers average variable cost; long-run survival adds the average-total-cost condition.
  • 3Derive marginal cost and choose output.
  • 3Calculate revenue, cost and profit.
  • 3Apply the average-variable-cost test.
Marginal cost is 6 + 4q, so price equals marginal cost at q = 9. Revenue is 378, total cost is 306 and profit is 72. Average variable cost is 24, below price, so the firm produces in the short run.
Sia tip — A competitive firm takes price as given and chooses quantity. Do not write that it sets price equal to marginal cost.
Glossary

Key terms

Opportunity Cost
The value of the best alternative use sacrificed by a choice.
Sunk Cost
A cost that cannot be recovered under any available current option.
Average Variable Cost
Variable cost per unit of output, used in the short-run shutdown test.
Marginal Cost
The change in total cost caused by producing one additional unit.
Economic Profit
Revenue minus explicit and implicit opportunity costs.
FAQ

Costs, Competitive Output and Profit FAQ

Why can a loss-making firm keep producing?

In the short run, fixed cost may already be unavoidable. Producing is worthwhile when revenue covers variable cost and contributes something toward that fixed amount. The firm shuts down only when price is below average variable cost at the best positive output. Persistent losses cause exit later when all costs become avoidable.

Does a higher fixed cost change competitive output?

Not when it is genuinely fixed with respect to output. The positive-output choice comes from price equal to marginal cost, and a fixed payment does not change marginal cost. It lowers profit and may affect entry or long-run survival. If it changes capacity or another marginal relationship, then it is no longer acting purely as fixed cost.

Why does marginal cost cross an average at its minimum?

When the next unit costs less than the current average, adding it pulls the average down. When the next unit costs more, it pushes the average up. The turning point occurs where marginal cost equals the average. The same arithmetic explains the intersections with average variable cost and average total cost.

Study strategy

Exam move

Take ten costs from a business case and classify each as avoidable, opportunity or sunk from a stated decision date. Then solve competitive output questions in a fixed order: price equals marginal cost, price against average variable cost, price against average total cost, and finally entry or exit. Explain each result with one marginal sentence so averages never replace the output condition.

Reclassify the same cost at a later decision date to test whether recoverability, rather than its accounting label, controls relevance. Check the rising portion of marginal cost explicitly.

Working through Costs, Competitive Output and Profit in PMGM7004? Sia is AskSia’s AI Management tutor — ask any PMGM7004 Costs, Competitive Output and Profit question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how PMGM7004 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 52 of your subjects at The University of Hong Kong, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your PMGM7004 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 3-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works