The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology · FACULTY OF ENGINEERING

MCEE6000D Chap.6 Hierarchical Product Design Framework

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
7 Chapters3-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 6 of 11 · MCEE6000D

Hierarchical Product Design Framework

Four decisions in one framework

Developing a materials product means deciding what to make, how to make it, whether to make it and how to do it efficiently: product, process, business and management decisions.

Module 4 organises them in a multidisciplinary hierarchical framework, a table of three phases in time, product conceptualisation, detail design and prototyping, and manufacturing and launch, against five job functions, management, business and marketing, research and design, manufacturing, and finance and economics.

Planning and gating the work

Objective-time charts break a corporate objective into sub-objectives for a business unit, a site and a laboratory, down to tasks measured in days, and the RAT2IO mnemonic defines each task by its resources, activities, tools, time, information and objective.

The Stage-Gate process reduces risk by reviewing deliverables at each gate, verifying manufacturability and the match to customer needs, and ends each review in one of three outcomes. Technology Readiness Levels, from 1 to 9, give investors and engineers a shared measure of maturity. The framework is multidisciplinary, hierarchical and iterative, and its workflow diagram shows tasks feeding back into one another.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Product, process, business and management decisions

  • 02

    Three phases against five job functions

  • 03

    Objective-time charts

  • 04

    The RAT2IO mnemonic

  • 05

    Stage-Gate reviews and their outcomes

  • 06

    Technology Readiness Levels 1 to 9

  • 07

    Multidisciplinary, hierarchical, iterative

Worked example · free

Decide a gate review for a heat-sink startup

Q [3 marks]. AskSia-authored practice. A startup's graphite-metal heat sink prototype has been demonstrated cooling a server in a data-centre test rack, but its supplier cannot yet deliver the composite consistently. At the next gate the panel must decide. Give the TRL, the decision, and the reason. The marks shown are an AskSia study allocation, not a University marking scheme.
A Stage-Gate review has three possible outcomes.A Stage-Gate review has three possible outcomes. Deliverables from a stage reach a gate where stakeholders either advance the project, retain it at the current stage until critical issues are resolved, or cancel it.StageGate reviewAdvance to next stageRetain until resolvedCancel the project
A Stage-Gate review has three possible outcomes. Deliverables from a stage reach a gate where stakeholders either advance the project, retain it at the current stage until critical issues are resolved, or cancel it.
  • +1A prototype demonstrated in a relevant environment is TRL 6.
  • +1Manufacturability is not yet verified, which is one of the two things a gate is meant to confirm.
  • +1So retain the project at its current stage until the supply issue is resolved, rather than advancing or cancelling it.
TRL 6, and the gate should retain the project at the current stage. The need still exists and no roadblock makes it infeasible, so cancellation is not justified, but advancing would skip the manufacturability check.
Sia tip — Before choosing advance, ask whether both gate tests are met: manufacturability verified and features matched to customer needs.
Glossary

Key terms

Objective-Time Chart
A chart that decomposes an objective into sub-objectives over months, weeks and days to promote concurrent work.
Gate Review
A decision point at which stakeholders from technical, business, legal and safety teams judge a stage's deliverables.
Job Function
One of the five rows of the framework, such as manufacturing or finance and economics.
Workflow Diagram
A diagram of how the development tasks, from studying the market to designing the process, feed results back into one another.
Concurrent Execution
Running sub-objectives in parallel across units, which the objective-time chart is designed to promote.
FAQ

Hierarchical Product Design Framework FAQ

What are the three possible outcomes of a Stage-Gate review?

Advance the project to the next stage; hold it where it is while outstanding critical problems are fixed; or stop it when the need has gone or an obstacle makes it unworkable. The reviewers come from the technical, manufacturing and business sides, joined by legal, supply chain, and environment, health and safety people.

What does each letter in RAT2IO stand for?

Resources, activities, tools, time, information and objective; the two letters T cover tools and time. For each task you define the objective, specify input and output information, list the activities, choose tools, assign people, IP, equipment and money, and estimate the time needed.

How is TRL used in practice?

It assesses how mature a technology is, helps investors, engineers and project managers judge whether it deserves money, more development or deployment, gives research a target for each step up the scale, and gives partners, funders and regulators a common language for discussing status.

What does an objective-time chart do?

It breaks a large objective into smaller ones that different units can pursue at the same time. A corporate goal measured in months is split among a business unit, a manufacturing site and a research laboratory, whose goals split again into tasks lasting weeks and then days, each described with the RAT2IO mnemonic so the work can run concurrently.

Study strategy

Exam move

Memorise the nine TRL definitions in order and practise placing products on the scale. Then rebuild the phases-by-functions table from memory, putting at least one activity in each cell, and recite the three gate outcomes with when each applies. Place both case-study products on the TRL ladder as practice.

Working through Hierarchical Product Design Framework in MCEE6000D? Sia is AskSia’s AI Engineering tutor — ask any MCEE6000D Hierarchical Product Design Framework question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how MCEE6000D is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 13 of your subjects at The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your MCEE6000D tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 3-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works